Ice Chest Suggestions

Tumbling Dice

Member
Joined
Jun 28, 2005
RO Number
18044
Messages
102
Hello All,

We need to replace our ice chest. We are in California so it does get warm out here. We have bought expensive ice chests, inexpensive ice chests, some that state the ice won't melt for 3 days or some up to 7 days. No luck. What ice chest do you use and how long does it keep the ice from melting? We usually have it out of direct sunlight.

Thanks for your suggestions

Carolyn
 
The best one I have used recently is the Coleman Extreme available at Wally World.
 
Coleman Extreme is the best for the money. Once it is cold, it will hold the ice for three to four days, even refreezing the ice into a single block if left closed.
 
I had one of THESE on my first boat. The PO left it there. That thing held ice literally for a week in 90*+ weather. I think it was because the lid latched down tight. Wish I still had it. It was that good.
 
For thoise of you with the Coleman Extreme's, how much sun are on them when you are getting the 3 - 4 days? I have a extreme in full sun, outside, and the ice (cubes) put in it in the am are gone by the end of the day.

Thanks
Niles
 
Niles;

It sits on my swim platform in direct sunlight all week-end long. It takes the first 5 pounds of ice to really cool it down, and then it's good to go.
 
I have one of these -

http://www.frigidrigid.com/

It will hold ice for several days depending on conditions. I have a large one (250 quarts) so there's plenty of room for ice also. It's 2" thick all around and it seals so tight that sometimes it's hard to open, it's like you're pulling against a vacuum if it was just closed. They are expensive though.

John
 
quote:

Originally posted by JohnC

I have one of these -

http://www.frigidrigid.com/

It will hold ice for several days depending on conditions. I have a large one (250 quarts) so there's plenty of room for ice also. It's 2" thick all around and it seals so tight that sometimes it's hard to open, it's like you're pulling against a vacuum if it was just closed. They are expensive though.

John






Ton$ o' Buck$?

BTW, There are some RO's who would say that's nothing compared to my ex!!!!
 
The extremes are very good... The trick with any cooler is to get it "charged" in the beginning.
I like to throw a block or two in the cooler the night before and then stock it with drinks, etc. that have been chilling in the frig.

Adding a bag or two of cubes to top it off will keep me in ice for up to 3-4 days (depending on cocktail requirements)...

John
 
save the empty bags from your ice and lay them across the top when it's full. it creates a barrier to help insulate the top.
 
I have an xyz (can't recall the name) cooler from Sam's. It is adequate. It has indents for separators built into the walls. I was wondering if anyone uses dry ice as a refrigerant. I would think that if one kept it separate to avoid freezing one's skin, it would made a great alternative or addition to regular ice.

Thoughts before I do something really, really stupid!!!!!!!!
 
Hands down, the best cooler I have ever owned, YETI. Bought mine at Gander Mountain. Hard shell, can wax and wash it to look as shiny as your boat. Rubber tight seal, non marring anti skid feet (keep mine on the swim deck) But, it ain't cheeeep.
 
quote:

Originally posted by KiDa

I was wondering if anyone uses dry ice as a refrigerant. I would think that if one kept it separate to avoid freezing one's skin, it would made a great alternative or addition to regular ice.

Thoughts before I do something really, really stupid!!!!!!!!






dry ice will freeze the water in whatever you've got on 'ice'. the beverage will separate...saw my parents try this with a keg when i was a kid. it was very funny from my perspective, they looked like hell the next morning. the alcohol rose to the top when the water froze.
 
quote:

Originally posted by onthecreek

quote:

Originally posted by KiDa

I was wondering if anyone uses dry ice as a refrigerant. I would think that if one kept it separate to avoid freezing one's skin, it would made a great alternative or addition to regular ice.

Thoughts before I do something really, really stupid!!!!!!!!






dry ice will freeze the water in whatever you've got on 'ice'. the beverage will separate...saw my parents try this with a keg when i was a kid. it was very funny from my perspective, they looked like hell the next morning. the alcohol rose to the top when the water froze.








And the problem is????

OK.....That's one thumbs up for the dry ice!!!!!
 
I usually just tell the wife to get me a beer out of the cardboard 12 pack behind the helm. IF she goes and gets it, the beer is frosty by the time she throws it at me.
 
I don't have refrigeration on the boat except for ice. The ice blue color Igloo Max Cold is the best bang for the buck. It is also sold (more expensively) by a major boating outfit in white color as "Ultra Cold." You can buy the Max Cold most anywhere cheap, no need to order.

I use two 50 qt. Max Colds for 6-day trips without adding ice. One cooler is for beverages and snacks, the other is food for meals. I get 3-4 days easily with no special treatment. Even with temperatures in the 90's and low 100's I get 6 days from Max Colds if the coolers are covered with wet white towels and kept out of direct sunlight as much as possible. Somewhere near day 4 or 5 I'll move all the remaining ice and food to one cooler. I load each cooler with two 10 lbs. blocks of ice, frozen food when possible and crushed ice to cover. Block ice is your friend. Never drain cold water unless it is to replace with an equal amount of ice. The cold water is only slightly warmer than that last little piece of ice. No cooler grazing with an open cooler lid is allowed. Pick what you want quickly and close the lid.

In fact, the number of days I can stay out at anchor is limited to 6 days by the single load of ice in the Max Cold coolers. My sanitation and electrical systems are not the limiting factors.

http://www.igloocoolers.com/products/FullSize/MaxCold/214/
 
If you use an ice pick to chop up block ice into chunks and also use the blue
things you freeze in the freezer, it will last days, unless you open it a lot.
We also freeze some bottled water to mix with the other drinks and set the blue
things on the sides of the cooler and put a doubled over beach blanket on the
top of the cooler, if you don't have a seat cushion on top of it.
If you also put cold drinks in the cooler before icing down, instead of hot
drinks, the ice will last longer.
 
[




I was wondering if anyone uses dry ice as a refrigerant. I would think that if one kept it separate to avoid freezing one's skin, it would made a great alternative or addition to regular ice.

Thoughts before I do something really, really stupid!!!!!!!!

--------------------------------------------------------------------------------
I've used dry ice on a number of occassions and it works well...sometime too well. Items will freeze solid. Ice cream is a hard as cement...pop cans freeze and expand...meat is frozen so solidly it takes hours to defrost. You get the picture.

It's a matter of trial and error..using newspaper to insulate the ice to regulate the cooling.

Dry ice spread along the bottom of the cooler lasted us about 3 days. It works very well...it's just a little tricky.
 
Back
Top