Idiots and auto pilot

In the know

Active member
exMember
Joined
Apr 12, 2006
RO Number
20824
Messages
2,958
So, we are coming back from Block Island yesterday and heading into the west passage we are over taken by a 35-40ish sportfish flagged out of Long Island.

I see that they are not altering course and are on a heading directly for whale rock. (For those not familiar with the area, this is no hidden local knowledge rock, this is a BFR that is clearly marked and clearly visible)

I am watching them and no change in course.

I get on the radio and hail them on 16.

They answer - this is good.

I ask if they realize their heading is directly on the rock.

Response - "excuse me what"

Me - "Capin, you are headed directly at whale rock"

Response - "really?, what is that"

Me - "Capin, do you not see that big fiberglass destroying, human killing rock directly off your bow?"

Response - "Oh jesus!, thanks - had the auotpilot on and wasn't really paying attention"

Me - "no problem" - as I shook my head in disbelief.

So, what are peoples thoughts on autopilots?
 
Awww come on ITK. You mean you didn't do like most people these days seem to do...grab your video camera and hungrily film waiting for the crash? Imagine that, concern for our fellow man. Wonder whats next :)
 
Autopilots, although I don't have or use one....are okay, BUT you STILL NEED someone at the "watch" The captain at the time still needs to watch for all the variables that can happen out there....another boat....ROCKS....a deadhead (logs floating in the water up here), heck...even the weather! Putting the boat on autopilot does not mean you can leave the bridge and go down and enjoy a drink with your guests, it really just means you don't have to turn the wheel. You're right, if it took YOU to hail him on the radio to warn HIM about rocks he is heading towards.....he is an idiot.
 
Failure to keep a proper lookout, Rule 5.

Some guy on the club searay forum posted a video of his wake, that he took while everyone else was below sleeping. While he's playing around with his camera, who's watching what's in front of the boat?
 
ITK, Good thing you were there and called him. Whale rock is in deed a BFR. Auto pilots are a great tool,they can assist the helmsman and watch hand. However, many people forget they can't see and they can't think.
Just another example of "You can't fix stupid".

John
 
I am more stunned that he was monitoring 16 than that he had his AP on and wasn't paying attention. I only hope your good deed is rewarded in goood boating Karma going forward.
 
quote:

Some guy on the club searay forum posted a video of his wake, that he took while everyone else was below sleeping. While he's playing around with his camera, who's watching what's in front of the boat?



If you read the whole thread !!!.
You would of read that Gary had one hand on the wheel at all times.
And he wasn't looking threw the viewfinder on the camera
quote:

I have no idea where this is... other than the middle of nowhere with no land or boats in sight...



Now you know the rest of the story. :)
 
I use my autopilot all the time. Especially on a long crossing far offshore. A few degrees on one end can be miles on the other end. I would be an idiot to leave the helm or fail to keep watch though. Even when I was watching closely I ended up picking up a bundle of crab pot floats that were drifting 33 miles offshore. They had black slime all over them and and were just barely at the surface. I didn't see them until they went under the hull. Grrrr... Had to clear that $&^% half way to Key West from Marco Island.
 
"...You would of read that Gary had one hand on the wheel at all times..."

Sure he did, sure.
 
Last year I was passed by a 70ish new GB in the icw just south of Norfolk then as the guy was passing the boat just ahead of me he suddenly veered to stbd and cut him off with a few ft to spare before stopping just short of the mud bank

He said his AP had malfunctioned and that he was using the AP because the boat was too hard go steer at low speed

As dumb as it gets

I ve seen many sportfishes passing close on ap...
 
I had AP on my old boat.
I liked it and I hated it.
First time I used it, some guy cut in front of me and the AP went into Auto-collision mode and almost drove me out of the channel.
Thats when I decided using it in a channell, no matter how straight it is, is stupid.
I used it on a few long runs, worked good, straight course, but if you have any kind of seas, then its no good becuase it cuts through the crap as opposed to trying to avoid any peaks in waves.

Personally, unless you run real long straight runs in good conditions, I see no use for it!
 
quote:

Originally posted by CurrentSea

I had AP on my old boat.
I liked it and I hated it.
First time I used it, some guy cut in front of me and the AP went into Auto-collision mode and almost drove me out of the channel.






That is interesting. I don't think I've ever heard of that. What brand was it? How does it tell you are on a collision course with something?
 
I only use my AP when trolling, never when running. It is invaluable as a trolling aid, and at 2-3 knots, you'd have to REALLY not be paying attention for an issue to arise. We're usually fishing around plenty of other boats here on Lake Ontario, so I'm always on the lookout for other guys that aren't paying attention.

Tim
 
quote:

Originally posted by Capt. Bill1

quote:

Originally posted by CurrentSea

I had AP on my old boat.
I liked it and I hated it.
First time I used it, some guy cut in front of me and the AP went into Auto-collision mode and almost drove me out of the channel.






That is interesting. I don't think I've ever heard of that. What brand was it? How does it tell you are on a collision course with something?








It was a simrad unit.
Networked with GPS and radar.
So the autoveer is a setting, that I was unaware of. it was set to like a 1/2 mile I think, so it something was in the radar path, it would auto veer to avoid collision. Scary when you don't expect it and suddently the boat turns on its own!
 
It changed course automatically with no warning?

Do you remember the model #?

Did you have to set up a guard zone on the radar?
 
Whale Rock is a seriously BFR. It is so big that it used to have it's own lighthouse. Unfortunately the light was wiped out in the 1938 hurricane, but you still can't miss seeing the huge rock with the remains of the lighthouse caisson.

Pre 1938
whalerocklighthouse.jpg


Recent times
whalerock.jpg
 
Originally posted by knotme

I use autopilot for tubing when I'm alone.

just kidding.

Funny! [:-shake]
 
So many Whale Rocks, so little time...found at least a dozen of along on the East Coast.....
 
Heading West into Lake Okeechobee, I had the next waypoint preset and when I engaged the AP, the boat slewed to Port. I DC'd the AP and manually steered to Clewiston. Later, I read of a "magnetic anomaly" in Lake "O" that required a course correction mid lake. I know that GPS is diff from a compass, but...?
 
Back
Top