I'm So Confused...continued

Perry

Member
Member
Joined
Mar 19, 2001
RO Number
3836
Messages
887
Folks,
OK, was asked to start a new thread now that fishing is off the table and can now focus on a cruising type boat.

Looking for opinions and some direction. I have been fishing all my life and know little about cruising boats.

Want to spend some weekends on the hook with my wife and 2 small dogs.

trying to understand what the right size boat should be...we just saw a Formula 27' PC which my wife liked but there's a Formula 31' PC for similar money.

Hogan's recent post on gas vs diesels has me thinking do I really need diesels under 35'? Do I need them at all?

Since there's so many cruising type boats Formula, Regal, SeaRay, Cruisers, etc...opinions?

Also, outdrives vs true inboards...I do boat in almost 100% saltwater.

then there's the whole tender groups of questions but for now...let's help me pick a boat or at least narrow this down for me.
thanks in advance!
 
Saltwater would almost dictate inboards unless you travel where it's very shallow or have the need for speed. Even then, I'm not sure it's worth the extra upkeep and maintenance to have outdrives.

As far as WHICH boat, that's almost a personal preference. Crawl all over a bunch of different boats, get in the engine compartment, visualize docking and access to the from the dock as you are pulling along side, is there access to the bow, what is the cabin layout like, how about the cockpit etc., I'm a fan of Sea Ray, but I like the Formula's as well, but we don't see many here in the inland Northwest. Consider resale value and how you will use it along with the typical load of family or friends to determine what fits your need. Keep in mind that the Admiral has to be happy too! I'm at a point in life where our next boat WILL have ALL of the goodies that I currently don't have like a windlass, generator and some other features that up until now were deemed too expensive or not really necessary.

Look at a lot of boats and get owner feedback, then make your decision and start looking for the right boat. I'd go used and save a ton of money by making a low ball offer in this economy!! Above all, don't forget the survey!
 
Lots of options out there for just a cruising boat. Personally, I would really go for a diesel, despite the size. It will be easier to handle, more efficient to run, as well as quicker and easier to sell later down the road. If it were just me and my wife and 2 small dogs I would give the 1998-2005 Mainship 34 rum runner express cruisers a hard look...single diesel power with usually a bow thruster, huge cockpit for entertaining and yes, some fishing, decent cabin for a 34 footer, and well, I just love the classic down east lines. They can be picked up for around $100k or less right now...heck of a good buy and great looking little boats. Again, if we didn't need the extra space for our 2 little kids, that is probably the boat I'd buy!
 
The common wisdom I've heard (and yes, you get what you pay for, I guess) is that if you're under 36', or putting less than 150 hours / yr on your engines, you don't want to go diesel, as the payback isn't there. Maintenance would be more espensive as well, as diesels love to run, they get out of sorts not being run. Gas is a cheaper investment, especially if you're still working on how much cabin you need in your cruiser.

Personally, my minimums would be twin engines, enough cabin to sleep four, big house bank, genny, decent galley and head area. If you're going for a Formula or other express cruiser, I'd go outdrives for manueverability and efficiency (you'll get better range), plus you can pull 'em up if you get into some skinny water at low tide (coming into a bay etc.)

If you decide to go displacement hull, then no matter what, get a diesel, it'll be running all day and loving it!
 
Perry,

Here is my .02

I agree with Tony that there are alot of options but here are my thoughts:

Go for twins - you already know what the current is like in the canal.

Go for diesel on anything over 34' or 20,000#. Agree it may have better value later. Research the boat and the motors before you buy.

I am not an IO fan but if you plan to be in Moriches or Tiana, then that is a real consideration. Just be wary of the maintenance issues in salt water.

I agree there are alot of options in this cruiser category. You need to walk through them all to see what subtle differences appeal to you.

Lastly, consider a Tiara. You can get decent accomodations, diesel or gas and you can easily fish from it.

Good luck. This is the fun part.
 
Your wife might want a boat that has a proper shower stall and that would steer you to boats that are more cabin style. Are you planning to trailer? than you will be limited to about 27-28' in express cruiser if not than I am a supporter of bigger is better.

Cor
 
quote:

Originally posted by mintregila

Perry,

Here is my .02

I agree with Tony that there are alot of options but here are my thoughts:

Go for twins - you already know what the current is like in the canal.

Go for diesel on anything over 34' or 20,000#. Agree it may have better value later. Research the boat and the motors before you buy.

I am not an IO fan but if you plan to be in Moriches or Tiana, then that is a real consideration. Just be wary of the maintenance issues in salt water.

I agree there are alot of options in this cruiser category. You need to walk through them all to see what subtle differences appeal to you.

Lastly, consider a Tiara. You can get decent accomodations, diesel or gas and you can easily fish from it.

Good luck. This is the fun part.






Actually, a 38' Viking sounds perfect for his needs.
 
quote:

Originally posted by In the know

quote:

Originally posted by mintregila

Perry,

Here is my .02

I agree with Tony that there are alot of options but here are my thoughts:

Go for twins - you already know what the current is like in the canal.

Go for diesel on anything over 34' or 20,000#. Agree it may have better value later. Research the boat and the motors before you buy.

I am not an IO fan but if you plan to be in Moriches or Tiana, then that is a real consideration. Just be wary of the maintenance issues in salt water.

I agree there are alot of options in this cruiser category. You need to walk through them all to see what subtle differences appeal to you.

Lastly, consider a Tiara. You can get decent accomodations, diesel or gas and you can easily fish from it.

Good luck. This is the fun part.






Actually, a 38' Viking sounds perfect for his needs.








LOL Thanks ITK but I think it is more than he is looking for.
 
First question is how much are you comfortably willing to spend. That opens up the discussion to figure out if we are talking late 80's early 90's boat or 2000+ boats.
 
hahahahahaha, yea....a few years ago I almost did.

I need to stick with an express.

I agree on the twins. Still stuck on the diesel no diesel decision.

I really don't expect to put that many hours on the engines...genny's another story.

I do like the consideration of bringing another couple and having accommodations.

what about food storage for a weekend away, what do most people bring? that small little refrig is not holding 2-3 meals within.

how longs does a typical water tank hold as far as showers? gal/user?
 
quote:

Originally posted by Perry

hahahahahaha, yea....a few years ago I almost did.

I need to stick with an express.

I agree on the twins. Still stuck on the diesel no diesel decision.

I really don't expect to put that many hours on the engines...genny's another story.

I do like the consideration of bringing another couple and having accommodations.

what about food storage for a weekend away, what do most people bring? that small little refrig is not holding 2-3 meals within.

how longs does a typical water tank hold as far as showers? gal/user?




Here`s a post I feel I can offer some info as your want list is similiar to what we were looking for when we decided on our boat. 98 402 Regal Commodore, twin cummins 330 hp, actually a 37 ft boat that got some "decal upgades" over its lifespan, 18000lbs. 1.2 statute mpg, our use approx 15 gph for both engines and genny. Fullsize fridge/freezer, separate shower, 110 gallon fresh water, lasts the two of us at least 4-5 days on the hook, large one level cockpit that would work fine for fishing, I do occasionally fish, not often.
We haven`t done it but the aft would be fine for the occasional guests, not something you would want to use full time, we like the way it `s wide open.
As stated above, you`ve got some boat crawlin` to do.....and remember, this is supposed to be fun!
 
I agree with mx8. I get the same out of my 120 gal water capacity. As to fridge, full size is nice but your not going to get it in the low 30' range. You can make do with a cooler out in the cockpit and the half size fridge.

In the low 30' range, you're not going to get a separate stall shower either. Some don't mind the combo head/shower but I was never a fan. For the occaisional weekend, I wouldn't sweat it though.

Lastly, I personally don't have any issue with gas motors as long as the boat isn't under-powered. I would have a concern if/when E15 gets mandated for all gas. Nobody really knows what the effect of that will be.
 
You might want to look at a used Rinker 342 or 360 (they're both going for approximately the same price now). The 360 will give you bigger engines (8.1's versus 5.7's), both have decent accomodations for four (six is tight, you're using the galley), both have stand up showers, both have cockpit ice makers and fridges, as well as a 6 cu ft in the galley. Microwave, elec stove, genny, so you should be good to go. My 360 has slept six comfortably, the shower has been a godsend on more than one occasion, and we've not yet run out of poaces to stash food and / or drinks. Worst comes to worst, we add a cooler in the boot for parties of 10+...
 
quote:

Originally posted by Perry

hahahahahaha, yea....a few years ago I almost did.

I need to stick with an express.

I agree on the twins. Still stuck on the diesel no diesel decision.

I really don't expect to put that many hours on the engines...genny's another story.

I do like the consideration of bringing another couple and having accommodations.

what about food storage for a weekend away, what do most people bring? that small little refrig is not holding 2-3 meals within.

how longs does a typical water tank hold as far as showers? gal/user?






Maybe I missed it,and I don't want to confuse you more, but why an express cruiser and not a Flybridge?

If it is strictly cruising, you will have much more usable interior space without that "cave" feeling. Also, you can get a full frisge in the mid 30' range with a Flybridge.

As for gas v diesel - to me the size of the boat is a red herring - the two things you want to look at are 1) the weight, and 2) intended use.
 
If you plan on spending lots of time cruising you will wish you either bought a diesel or if you want gas a Catamaran. Anything short of that and get ready to spend 3 to 5 thousand a year in fuel alone. Now I am probably a bad example but I have spent on average $3800 a year on gas and I haven't even started any long distance cruising. That's why I'm in the process of converting my boat to diesel.
Bill
 
I guess nobody here believes a trawler is a good cruising boat?

I wouldn't start with the gas/diesel arguement, I would start by deciding what style of boat suits your needs and figuring out your budget, both original purchase, and operating/maintenance costs. The boat you like may only be available in one fuel type.

As for all the other questions, there's no harm in asking on a web forum, but if you want to start cruising and you don't have a lot of experience with water and sewage systems, refrigeration, cooking, etc., I suggest that you pick up one or two of the many books on boat cruising. Some are geared to sailboats, but much of the information applies to powerboats as well.

Here's a link to some photos of my trawler:

http://www.picturetrail.com/sfx/album/view/19068769

Here are some of a cruise we took last fall:

http://www.picturetrail.com/sfx/album/view/22575272
 
Ron I don't think anyone is ruling out trawlers. I was recently seriously thinking about 44 & 42 Nova Trawlers. They can be had for a song. I looked at a local 42 NOVA Sundeck Trawler and the only reason I didn't proceed was I don't want to be a 3 boat owner in today's economy.
Bill
 
quote:

Originally posted by Billylll

Ron I don't think anyone is ruling out trawlers.





But nobody mentioned one either. It's an option the OP should be aware of.
 
Folks,
Since I will be keeping my 25'cc i am not going to fish this boat.

My range is about 80k.

For the most part my cruising range will be less than 100miles per weekend as I would keep the boat somewhere near the Shinnecock Canal.

I chose an express because I singlehand almost always. Plus, with the dogs, really need to be on the same level.

I'm reaching out to this crew because you folks actually do the things I'm wanting to get into and are willing to share so I can make a better educated guess when I purchase this next boat.

Gas vs Diesel, that's one of my concerns.

keep it coming, I'm learning a bunch here and it's already sinking in. I did like the suggestion regarding sleeping 4 adults comfortably and I think this takes me to a 33' or bigger. The 35' Cruisers had everything, just needed some big TLC which is good and bad.
 
Back
Top