Insurance update...

A lawyer will take a third only if you sign a contingency agreement. Most, in a situation like this, will work by the hour. The last thing you want to do is inadvertently waive any rights or agree to something that is unreasonable.
 
When you said the exact GPS position I thought it may not be in that exact spot. Things do move as the go down to the bottom. What if they don't find anything at that spot. Then what is the next step? Will they search for it? Would a sonar pick that up?
 
Art,
Greg (Gee BEE) IMO, is right on with this, although L.Keith sounds like he has some knowledge in this field, you may want to PM him. Les also brings out a good point about hiring an attorney on an hourly basis.

I am assuming we have a major claim here (400, 500, 600k) maybe more. If that’s the case, then paying a few thousand to have the “right” attorney keep them honest and in line, may be the prudent thing to do. Otherwise, you may wind up having to do this anyway 6 months from now.

As much as it sucks that you even have to consider this, with a claim this size, you really need to have your rights protected. What those rights are, what is the protocol, what is reasonable and customary, only an attorney can tell you that. You’re a minnow swimming with the sharks (insurance company) and the insurance company knows that!!!

After reading the posts here, my question would not be “do I need an attorney” but “how do I find the right attorney for this type of case”

In your original post “Lost my Boat Today” , there was a post about a guy that lost a big SeaRay of the coast of Long Island. He wound up be arrested and charged with filing a false claim, well many thousands of dollars later in legal fees, the charges were dropped, I would speculate the evidence gathered that got him arrested came from the insurance company. I hope you see where I am going with this, you need representation and you need it NOW.

Just My 2C Art, worst case, you blew a few grand, best case, your not arrested and have to do what you should of done from the beginning.

That Guy with the Searay, I believe still has not settled his claim, maybe the poster of that incident can chime in.

Wish you the best, hope you get representation very soon.

Walter
 
My thought is that the type of dive and diver needed here will also need a pretty good support crew on board a vessel overhead and that won't be any 30 or 40 ft. vessel. It'll be ALOT larger than that so I doubt the weather has really been all THAT much of an issue. Sure you've had some pretty miserable days but I'm sure there have been plenty of days over the past few weeks to have gotten this done.

Get an Attorney. If for no other reason than to make sure you're documenting everything you should be and doing it correctly in case it's needed in the future. Easier to start that all now than to have a few months (and who knows how many a "few" will turn out to be) worth of conversations and documents and E-Mails all stacked up and THEN dump em on an Attorney that isn't familiar with the situation. Easier if you get them involved at the onset.
 
quote:

Originally posted by L. Keith

If you were outside of your policy Navigational Limits at the time of loss, then a positive identification of the vessel/wreck and a confirmed position of the wreck will be very important to the underwriters. Art, are you sure you have not received correspondance from the underwriter stating "we reserve the right to..." or "all rights are reserved..." or anything along that line?






I've received nothing yet but I'm told something was mailed to me that I have not seen yet?
 
Art do yourself a favor as GeeBee, Less, Walter and now me are all telling you to find the right kind of lawyer and pay him hourly. I would think a maritme lawyer but when I think about it they really are for large shipping companies. Anyone know what type of lawyer Art should get? Remember this most insurance investigators are ex police officer's and many are not ex detectives or investigators. The insurance company hires them because they have access through ex officers still working to data an insurance company could never get without a court order. Then if they smell somethings wrong they contact the insurance fraud division in your state and they do have arrest powers in some states, in NJ they do. I know I worked as an insurance investigator for a short period of time.

Bill
 
another vote for a atty.

And think of what you're saving by not boating-hat can be applied to the attys fees albeit a lousy tradeoff.
 
There has been a lot of boat scuttling and fires lately since the economy tanked in 2008, is it possible they are looking for the cause of the sinking?
 
If you are having trouble getting a claim paid you need to give a call to your State Insurance Dept. They are there to help solve these issues. Each insurance Co. must follow the laws of the state where they do bus. They will act in your behalf.
Good Luck!
 
Local bar associations might be able to supply you names of attorneys skilled in maritime law/claims.
 
In the area of "stalling" under the guise of the need to send down a diver --- Big loss of a couple of hundred thou, coupled with a worsening economy = increased hance of fraud. My wife is a commercial insurance agent and has been for years. In tight economic times, the following items have a strange coincidence of catching fire, getting stolen, or sinking...rental property, motorcycles, atvs, campers / rvs, jet skis, and BOATS. Basically, non-essential "toys" Their company has had a min 40% increase on rental(landlord)policies in the last 6 months due to mysterious arson claims.
Even with that being said, any insurance company will not want to pay 1/2 million + dollar claim, especially going into the end of the year. Spend a few hundreds to have an initial consult and retain an attorney.
 
Art, the insurance company can also force you to testify in an "examination under oath" - questioning you about when, where & how the sinking occurred. You need a lawyer who specializes in property insurance defense.

This is a fairly big claim, the company will do whatever they can to "protect" themselves - you need to do the same.

If I were advising you, I would also tell you to post NOTHING about the sinking on a public forum.
 
I appreciate all the suggestions. It appears that the consensus is to hire an attorney? I still feel it's a little too early but I'm going to look for a lawyer experienced in this area & see what the retainer costs will be?
 
Hogan gave you two pieces of sound advise. Get an attorney and cease further public discussions re: this sinking. Do both NOW.

John
 
Waltrev the guy on Long Island was found not guilty by a jury! He is now in court suing the insurance company and that trial is probably going to be early next year. This has been going on for three years!
 
His attorney may be a good lawyer to use? I'll see if I can track the case down. Would you know what county Nassau or Suffolk or any link to the story?
 
OK, I have resisted expressing my opinions on this because of the possible ramifications of this case. But, well, the spirit is weak. IMHO here's what I think:

1. So far, Art's insurance company has done nothing outside the scope of due dilligence. They are faced with a very large claim and they are simply excersizing their investigative prerogitives to validate the merits of the claim.
2. To draw any parallels between Art's case and any other case in existence is, at the very least, ill advised. Each and every case is unique and will stand on its own merits and the circumstances of any other case is just irrelevant.

If it were me, I would, indeed, seek consultation with an attorney. This is usually an hourly rate transaction with little upside or downside exposure. This will at least help to understand what to expect and what the possible scenarios are. Gather information.

But, for now, I'd let it play out just a bit more. As I said, to me, the insurance company, so far, is merely exercising due dilligence.

Patience may indeed be a virtue.

But, and I emphasize, I am not an Admiralty Attorney nor am I a Marine Insurance expert. Tis is just IMHO.

Bob
 
Back
Top