Just need to vent

tcap1

Member
exMember
Joined
Sep 24, 2006
RO Number
23604
Messages
46
Just need to vent a little.
My boat was damaged by a marina fire the end of April, boats across the dock burnt and sank. i got lucky - blisters on the aft hatch, burn holes in canves, bubbled rubrail. If i had my full camper canvas up she would have caught fire also - just had the cockpit cover on. took them rb2@gr5t2 months & they said the cause of the fire was undetermined.

Insurance & surveyor - lost some small battles but won a big one.

The guys that are doing the repairs are another story. Its been issue after issue. The Marina is not doing the work, they have a sub.

Fiberglass repair - small blisters & delamination all over the stern - nothing major. They did a fine job repairing and filling in. The gelcoat spray job is crap. Hard tape lines, missing spots, & didn't match the color. Hiring another company to re-spray for color match. Insurance is covering the re-spray, & i'm not looking a gift horse in the mouth over that.
they replaced a section of rubrail & did run a bead of caulk across the top of the rubrail but they didn't caulk the screws. Also lost some screws and replaced with flathead vice round so they do not recess.
They replaced my transom shower with a Fontana brand - online cost $69.99. They are chargin me $780!! for it. On top of that ran water thru it today & it leak all over the place. Told them i won't pay more than $100, if they don't like it get it off my boat.
The sub & the yard boss called to say the boat was done the other day, went down after work and i blew up. The boat was filthy & work wasn't done. Compund dust all over the place, masking tape still covering the starboard doors, gelcoat color not matching, missing snap of cockpit door, missing S/S flag mount, rubbing compound spill on seats, ...
Sent over a discrepancy list the next day, & got in an argument with the Yard guy. He didn't understand the part of I'm not paying $780 for a $70 transom shower "well, what are they supposed to do with it now ?"
so many other issues - gonna call tomorrow and go over the final bill with the Marina boss lady. Not paying for the shower door, marina storage fee's & holding back some money to cover the re-upholster of my stained seats.
 
Tcap, I feel your pain. Nothing like a bunch of slackers! I don't have an answer but wanted to know I've been through the same (not with the boat but cars) and it really pi$$es me off. Others will chime in as what to do but wanted to let you know there are others that can understand what you're going through.
 
Get out of the yard now. You can't fix shoddy work.

You have no obligation to have a bad yard do the work.
 
It is better to not threaten to withhold $$$ to get what you want/should get. That just encourages retribution----such as rubbing compound spill on seats.

Better find a different yard to do the work. Perhaps visit an attorney? Also complain loudly to your insurance company---with pictures to support your claims.

Good luck!
 
F--k them, twice on sat., three times on sunday.

Get your boat take it out of there now.

Don't say a word to them and if they have a problem tell them to call Dear Abby and send you a letter.

When they do call or send you a letter you send one back with the itemized list and the prices your gonna charge them to fix what they f--ked up.
 
The OP's response to the yard may have talked himself right into a maritime lien on his boat.

He may want to brush up on the Federal maritime Lien Act, 46 United States Code 31301-31343.

It would not surprise me if the work order he signed contains language similar to this


Lien Clause: XXX expressly reserves its rights under Section 6A 7-210 of the General Laws of Rhode Island to auction a vessel if the Owner is in arrears for storage, mooring rental, repair or other charges. In addition, XXX reserves its rights under the Federal maritime Lien Act, 46 United States Code 31301-31343, to have the United States Marshall seize and auction a vessel when the Owner fails to meet his financial obligations. Finally, the Owner also grants XXX a security interest in the vessel under the terms of the Uniform Commercial Code to secure sums due under this agreement. Upon default, this allows XXX to board the vessel and remove any machinery, equipment or materials CBY provided or installed.
 
Time for a sit down with the insurance company the yard and the sub-contractor. Might want to have a lawer with also.
 
I agree with Padraig but I will add hire a surveyor and have him do battle for you.
 
I've made a few mistakes and could have done a few things better - but i have keeped a cool head thoughout this. Only time got a little heated was when the yard boss just didn't get the $70 part and charging $780.
- i cannot and wouldnot - unless it was an extreme condition - just take the boat and go without paying. she's hauled out of the water & the marina would have to put her in.
- I have written timline back from April of times & dates and many, many pictures along the way. so i am in pretty good shape with facts & proof.
- Whats an "OP". either way, today will have a sit down with the yard and discuss the bill & give them a chance to make it right. with the pitcures and info i have i think i am in pretty good shape. Worst case senario i will not let a few hundred dollars threathen my boat. all else fails and the marina / sub do not want to make things right i will pay in full get the boat out of there and then seek legal action, if neccessary & cost effective. then make sure all the other marinas around and other boaters know the treatment i received.
- i will not rattle the insurance co. the latest bill is up in there hands and they did come through for me so far.

still have a few days - my other guy I hired should be re-spraying the transom this week. Gives me time to re-pull the runrail screws and apply some sealant.
 
tcap you have the right idea. ITK is right about marine liens, better to pay the bill and fight in court later. Just make sure in the end that you get the quality of work you require and don't be afraid of getting someone else to finish the job if you have to.
 
its like i told the surveyor, our boat is very personal to us. just want her back in the water where she belongs.
 
maybe the part about maritme liens is one reason the work is so shoddy...?
Buzz
 
Besides the shoddy work, do I understand that you have been without the boat sice April of this year?
 
I don't know what the hold up was/is but IMO this is inexcusable. The sit down meeting with all parties now needs to be a come to jesus meeting. You have lost most if not all of the summer boating season.

Maybe sue for pain and suffering. <G> By now I would be so grumpy my wife would have left me.
 
I feel for you. Bad situation to be in... BTW I saw a Fontana transom shower for $44.95. Best of luck
 
quote:

By now I would be so grumpy my wife would have left me.



we'll no thanks to me - we're still together. she's been pretty good throughout this. I only lost my cool once talking to the yard boss about what part of I'm not paying $780 for a $70 part don't you understand. after it was over and i told her about it she said you finally got your argument. I did feel a littl better after that. Still need to wait until it is all done to really unload. Patience...patience...

quote:

BTW I saw a Fontana transom shower for $44.95.



send me the link if you can. they agreed to only take $100 for the transom shower(which is still a gift) BUT i am going to tell them now to get it off my boat - i am not paying for it at all. It leaks because it has the wrong fittings - its like 2 male fitting with a plastic wing screw that you can only get about 1 thread tight on - major leakag !

went down last night after work to back out all my Rubrail screws and caulk. Seems like Chaparral doesn't believe they should have any on them. Earlier I noticed that my s/s trim piece on top of the rail holds water. so i had this on my list to do. THEY replaced the stbd aft section of Runrail. After i asked them to make sure they caulked the screws and they said "no problem Tom" guess what they didn't do. they also used shorter screws, 3/4" vice 1 1/4. After i removed the S/S trim piece i noticed that 4 screws holding the rail onto the boat just fwd of the section they replaced are missing. Either they "borrowed" them to use in the aft section or Chaparral never installed them.

enough venting for now - getting to worked up again.
 
I hate to say it, but Lawyers have us by a unique language and a great volume of knowledgeable arguments.

Judges are the problem.
1,2,3 etc.
You suffered damage, it was poorly repaired. Now the lawyers have to argue the terms of the contracts.
Restitution and last but not least is the pitiful pleasure of punitive damages to pay the lawyers, get the boat fixed and punish the shoddy workers.

For all the agony of associating with the Skunks, Liars, meddlers, Weasels and the autonomous judges, it's just about as satisfying to put a sign up on your boat, showing the damages, and listing all the names of the people involved.

That worked in Seattle. Eventually somebody paid the protester to take that sign down.
 
Back
Top