Originally posted by Les Hall
You guys need to contact your local CG base for clarification. Up until just a few years ago, even reimbursement for fuel constituted a commercial transaction. The big problem is the potential for someone getting hurt. Then your insurance will walk away and the CG will walk in if there's a violation. US Code says:
(21a) ``passenger for hire'' means a passenger for whom
consideration is contributed as a condition of carriage on the
vessel, whether directly or indirectly flowing to the owner,
charterer, operator, agent, or any other person having an interest
in the vessel.
A tax deduction would certainly be "indirect flow."
[/quote
Les you gave the same answer I got on another forum, but I don't agree that the tax deduction is an indirect flow.
The tax deduction would go to the passenger not the owner. Writing off the fuel used is not a financial benefit to the owner, if anything it is a cost. Lets not mix up the CFR with the IRS, its like oil and vineger
For all the posts about the captain, it does not matter at all whether he was paid or not. It's a matter of whether the passenger paid for the ride.
Since no financial benefit inures to the owner of the boat, I don't think the vessel needs to be inspected nor does the pilot have to have a captains license. (based on 21a)