looking for opinions

Maycpa

Member
exMember
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
RO Number
3197
Messages
220
A local marina donated a boat ride with a "captain" to a charity auction. I believe the captain has a 6 pack license, but there were 12 persons aboard.

My question is, does this constitute passengers for hire? and did the boat technically need to be coast guard inspected?

They donated cash for the ride, is this the price of a ticket?
 
If the captain was not being compensated, then there was no license requirement.
 
I don't think I agree with that. If the passengers paid money to ride on the vessel they would constitute "Passengers for Hire" whether the captain was being compensated or not. IMHO, they needed a captain with a masters ticket to carry that many pax.

The vessel, does have to be inspected if there will be 7 or more passengers for hire.

Bob
 
If one person ONLY paid the money & he invited 11 friends then my opinion is he was covered. If 12 people paid he was in violation & needed a Masters License. Also, 12 paying people boat needs to have a USCG Inspection as passenger ship.
 
They paid at the auction. What the owner of the charter did with the money is his business.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Capt. Art

If one person ONLY paid the money & he invited 11 friends then my opinion is he was covered. If 12 people paid he was in violation & needed a Masters License. Also, 12 paying people boat needs to have a USCG Inspection as passenger ship.






doesn't matter how many actually paid! as long the owner and/or captain is being compensated, it is a charter and the vessel needs a licensed captain (OUPV under 6, master over 6).

If 12 or less, the boat doens't have to be inspected if operated as a bareboat charter. However, teh paperword needs be done right which unlikely to be the case here.

if everything goes fine, i dont' think anyone will get in any trouble... obviously the brown stuff will hit the fan if something goes wrong.

may have been done with the right intentions (fundraiser) but that's not enough these days.
 
Every year my yacht club does a "Champagne Cruise" for charity....Meals on Wheels. Folks pay, usually $40-50 per ticket, to have a 3 hour cruise with champagne and appetizers. Usually 8-10 boats volunteer to participate. They are not compensated for anything, but I think they get a charitable contribution deduction on their taxes for all out of pocket expenses with appropriate receipts.

None of the volunteering boats are licensed/inspected, though some of the skippers [not all] are rated. I think everything is legal.
 
You guys need to contact your local CG base for clarification. Up until just a few years ago, even reimbursement for fuel constituted a commercial transaction. The big problem is the potential for someone getting hurt. Then your insurance will walk away and the CG will walk in if there's a violation. US Code says:

(21a) ``passenger for hire'' means a passenger for whom
consideration is contributed as a condition of carriage on the
vessel, whether directly or indirectly flowing to the owner,
charterer, operator, agent, or any other person having an interest
in the vessel.

A tax deduction would certainly be "indirect flow."
 
quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

Originally posted by Capt. Art

If 12 or less, the boat doens't have to be inspected if operated as a bareboat charter.





Pascal, I'm operating from memory so may be mistaken. But, I think the 12 pax limit applies to vessels over 100 tons. Vessels under 100 tons and carrying 7 or more pax plus crew must be inspected. I believe this is in Subchapter T somewhere in Part 175.

Like I said, it's been a long time since I studied this stuff but as i recall that's how it is.

Also, as long as there is even 1 paying passenger aboard, if there are more than 6 pax the captain must possess a master ticket.

Bob
 
Guys, I think we might be misreading his original post.

Nowhere did it say the captain was being paid...he simply said the passengers bought a ticket for charity (not for paying the captain).

How can the captain get a tax write off if the proceeds are going to a charity? They donated cash for the ride...but the cash went to the charity.

I agree with everyones comments on if he got paid...but it looks like all is well in this story!
 
Bob

if under 100T, and if the boat is chartered under a bareboat contract, the boat doens't have to be inspected as long as it is operated by a Master (not a 6P). There might be a 100t limit above which the vessel must be inspected, that i'm not sure, but not the other way. Bareboat contracts need to be properly written and the crew has to be picked,contracted and paid separately, not imposed by the owner.

also, I dont' think that whether or not the captain is being paid is relevant. the key factor is weather the passengers (any of them) are paying for the ride.
 
The best way to find out the true answer is the also the worst way. Say the charity boat ride goes bad and the boat catches fire and two or three of the guest that are burned badly are high earners. They sue everybody involved, boat owner, marina, charity, even the food and drink provider. After the US Federal District Courts get through with the case you will have your answer, other that way, call the United States Coast Guard (not the local station), District Office of Marine Inspection (OMI) and speak with the head of the office and discuss it with him/her.
 
This deal is most likely a donation to the charity. The people at the auction write a check to the charity for the winning bid. The boat owner donates a boat. The only individual to get compensation is the charitable organization. In a way it is no different than taking friends out for a ride.
 
Except if the charity is tax deductible under the US Tax Codes, they skipper can deduct the cost of fuel and food/beverages he provided as long as the function does not reimburse him.
 
I donated a charity ride on my boat. Our office did a fundraiser last spring for a charity. ALL the money from the winning bidder got paid to the charity. I should be okay. Not only am I not receiveing any compensation, I am spending money out of my own pocket to donate this ride.

Here's the quote Les posted......

<<..."(21a) ``passenger for hire'' means a passenger for whom
consideration is contributed as a condition of carriage on the
vessel, whether directly or indirectly flowing to the owner,
charterer, operator, agent, or any other person having an interest
in the vessel."..>>

So, for it to be "passeneger for hire", not only do people have to pay, there needs to be consideration (payment) that flows either directly or indirectly to either the owner, operator, agent, etc.

There is no payment or other consideration flowing (directly or indirectly) to me as either owner or operator. Nothing. Nada.

The ride is being given this Friday. A co-worker was the winning bidder of the auction last spring, and she is bringing along other co-workers. I will have to suffer as the only guy on the boat with 5 or 6 women. Someone has to do it!
 
Pictures Glen, we are going to need pictures, and we know you own a camera. So don't use that for an excuse.
 
Glenn, I think you will be ok if you do NOT claim a tax deduction for the out of pocket expenses for the cruise. If you do take a deduction, could that be considered indirect compensation? Maybe......

Enjoy your harem!!!
 
Originally posted by Les Hall

You guys need to contact your local CG base for clarification. Up until just a few years ago, even reimbursement for fuel constituted a commercial transaction. The big problem is the potential for someone getting hurt. Then your insurance will walk away and the CG will walk in if there's a violation. US Code says:

(21a) ``passenger for hire'' means a passenger for whom
consideration is contributed as a condition of carriage on the
vessel, whether directly or indirectly flowing to the owner,
charterer, operator, agent, or any other person having an interest
in the vessel.

A tax deduction would certainly be "indirect flow."

[/quote

Les you gave the same answer I got on another forum, but I don't agree that the tax deduction is an indirect flow.

The tax deduction would go to the passenger not the owner. Writing off the fuel used is not a financial benefit to the owner, if anything it is a cost. Lets not mix up the CFR with the IRS, its like oil and vineger

For all the posts about the captain, it does not matter at all whether he was paid or not. It's a matter of whether the passenger paid for the ride.

Since no financial benefit inures to the owner of the boat, I don't think the vessel needs to be inspected nor does the pilot have to have a captains license. (based on 21a)
 
Back
Top