Mandatory AIS ?

kerry good point, EPIRB is really the only game in town for offshore work but it is not really aimed at the coastal market. the rescue 21 system is as most distress calls are in coastal areas. I'm not sure how many VHF radios are sold each year but i'm certain its a pretty healthy # and adding this technology to them is not a big deal when you talk about volume production. if they can put this stuff in a cell phone for next to nothing they can put it in a VHF. the AIS system when coupled with a radio just is'nt that hard, standard horizon is already selling one. I'm sure that for the foreseable future a commercial grade product suitable for a mission critical application like the bridge of a supertanker will remain very costly. but mandating this type of saftey gear for every boat would surely bring production up and costs down. even if they don't mandate it i'm willing to bet my lunch that the product i've described is coming.
 
I think the reason EPIRBS are not mandatory is the resources that would be wasted on false alarms if EVERY moron on the water had one. There are enough problems with 911.
 
quote:

Originally posted by stmbtwle

I think the reason EPIRBS are not mandatory is the resources that would be wasted on false alarms if EVERY moron on the water had one. There are enough problems with 911.






Now the false alerts was exactly the reason the 121.5Mhz system was terminated and upgraded to 406Mhz requiring registration.
 
Since I have AIS if or when it were mandatory then they should drop the radar requirement. AIS is less expensive and sees through fog and around corners. But AIS doesn't see bridges and the shoreline like Radar. I prefer both AIS and Radar. That being said I am putting an AIS receiver on the top of my ham radio 300' tower near Egg Harbor City. From the tower at the top I can see Philadelphia and Atlantic City (on a clear day) this should really help the South Jersey crowd. I will link it to one of the numerous free AIS websites for boaters with an internet connection will greatly benefit from a high receiver like my installation.
Bill
 
I am not sure I understand some of the chat about radar vs AIS. They are very separate functions. Boats run into jetties, containers, piers, ATONs, rocks, and bridges more than they run into each other. The comment about getting rid of radar to use the band width is complete and utter urban legend BS.
 
quote:

Originally posted by vic33004

kerry good point, EPIRB is really the only game in town for offshore work but it is not really aimed at the coastal market. the rescue 21 system is as most distress calls are in coastal areas. I'm not sure how many VHF radios are sold each year but i'm certain its a pretty healthy # and adding this technology to them is not a big deal when you talk about volume production. if they can put this stuff in a cell phone for next to nothing they can put it in a VHF. the AIS system when coupled with a radio just is'nt that hard, standard horizon is already selling one. I'm sure that for the foreseable future a commercial grade product suitable for a mission critical application like the bridge of a supertanker will remain very costly. but mandating this type of saftey gear for every boat would surely bring production up and costs down. even if they don't mandate it i'm willing to bet my lunch that the product i've described is coming.






The Standard Horizon unit, while a nice radio, still has lots of room for improvement (and this is not a knock on SH). First, it's a receiver only and SH is kinda vague on whether it's a true dual channel receiver or single receiver that switches back and forth between the two AIS channels. This makes an appreciable difference on the reception of target data. See: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gwnbRcB5P-s

Right now, the least expensive Class B AIS transceivers cost about $600+. A Class A will set you back a few grand. The technology is improving, but, IMO, nowhere near the same level as something that we take for granted these days like a radio or even GPS.

That being said, making it mandatory presents its own problems too.

First, I do not want my radar/ECS cluttered with 100 pleasure boat AIS targets on a summer afternoon, all trying to use their "gee-whiz, all-in-one unit to DSC call that tug over there" function because the AIS says we're going to get too close. At that point, I am turning off the overlay or setting the CPA/TCPA alarm setpoints to zero, in which case, we're back to square one with me exclusively looking out the window (which I should be doing in the first place).

Second, and this is on a broader note, there is too much of a trend these days to throw technology at the symptom of a "problem" than to treat its root cause. Mandatory AIS does little to treat the problem if the user doesn't understand basic watchkeeping and seamanship. Being on the water isn't/shouldn't be a computer game where you just avoid all the little triangles. I always get a much better kick out of learning something that involves my natural senses, rather than seeing what the latest gizmo is capable of.

AIS is a great tool, but it's use has to follow the demands of good seamanship, not the other way around.

Now, you wanna know something that would actually be effective if made mandatory? Brighter navigation lights. For the love of god, I don't know why something as simple as that is not tinkered with, yet here we are discussing AIS for vessels smaller than a ship's lifeboat.

Lastly, and on more of a personal note, I am tracked constantly at work, always talking with VTS, the USCG, the office, etc... (thank god we don't have a VDR...yet). For just once, I would like to spend an afternoon sailing around with nobody watching my every move. People sailed for thousands of years without AIS, right up until a few years ago. Doesn't take too much of existing tools to continue to do it safely with a sense of enjoyment.
 
Where I work, the AIS is overlaid onto the radar screen.
We have 2 radars and 2 monitors. No special monitors for the AIS.
But it is a commercial application. Pretty much top of the line.
The AIS does not reach out as far as the radar. Sometimes we see
boats out to 30 miles or so on the AIS and sometimes we can only
see them out to 20 or so miles.
The AIS icons are a purple triangle and the radar is the regular
yellow mark. They lay right on top of each other.
Our radars and AIS antennae's are about 100 ft. above sea level.
 
"The comment about getting rid of radar to use the band width is complete and utter urban legend BS." Actually, "Work Boat" magazine ran a column about that very subject about a year or so ago and concluded it was quite possible. Just this week the FCC announced that it would allow Broadcasters to turn in some of their spectrum and to share in the "lease proceeds" when that spectrum was leased to other users.
 
Ok, so we have established that Workboat Magazine at times publishes utter BS. The TV broadcast spectrum issue has zero to do with radar.
 
George all excellent points and factual. I was actually joking about radar vs. AIS they compliment each other. I was the 1st pleasure boat in our area to install an AIS Class B transponder. I have 2 spare units now one I'm installing as a receiver only on my leased 300' tower and it will feed it's data to the on-line AIS networks. I have the NMEA2000 Simrad unit and well it was cake to install and program. I have a commericial FCC license so I can program my own unit. Towards the end of last season the number of targets (AIS-B) was anywhere from 4-12 vessels. It is also a great indicator of enhanced propagation (thats my ham radio side). Another important point I liked was that Garmin had 3 service upgrades to the firmware I downloaded from their website to a memory card which got rid of my original problem with my vessel alarming (thinking it was it's own target).
Bill
 
What I like about my AIS transponder set up with my Garmin VHF200 also NMEA2000 set-up is I can with a push of a button hail the other AIS vessel to a voice channel. It's been kind of fun testing the unit with commercial ships and pleasure boaters. One point guys Class B is only 2 watts and by design will not travel as far as commercial AIS class A units. Now when we have propagation they I have seen AIS Class B vessels off Long Island from the Tuckerton Creek (Little Egg).
George there has been talk of putting AIS units on navigation aides.
Bill
 
You don't even have to physically put the AIS transmitter on the ATON. Since AIS is GPS based, all you (the shore station) have to do is transmit a target with the lat/lon of the nav aid. The receivers interpret that as a target at that lat/lon and displays it as such. For all but floating aids, this is pretty effective, provided that the transmitter can provide reliable enough transmissions at a range that is actually useful for navigation.

It's really most useful for setting up a temporary aid marking a new wreck or obstruction, etc. prior to being able to actually drop a physical mark at the location.

As far as DSC goes, outside of the simulator/training I had prior to getting my GMDSS license, I have never sent one and really can't think of any time I would want to (outside of some distress situations). The only ones I have ever received are on the MF/HF from the morons who keep relaying other calls until it's hopped over to the western Atlantic from the Indian Ocean. Didn't take too long for me to become the master of acknowledging that thing (it's loud).
 
"The TV broadcast spectrum issue has zero to do with radar." On that point you are correct, but it shows the political climate and the direction the regulatory authority is headed. In the United States of America, the FCC has everything to do with radar and the frequencies that the units broadcast on! There is an old saying in broadcasting, What you once got for free, you now pay for.
 
quote:

Originally posted by KPMid

You don't even have to physically put the AIS transmitter on the ATON. Since AIS is GPS based, all you (the shore station) have to do is transmit a target with the lat/lon of the nav aid. The receivers interpret that as a target at that lat/lon and displays it as such. For all but floating aids, this is pretty effective, provided that the transmitter can provide reliable enough transmissions at a range that is actually useful for navigation.

It's really most useful for setting up a temporary aid marking a new wreck or obstruction, etc. prior to being able to actually drop a physical mark at the location.

As far as DSC goes, outside of the simulator/training I had prior to getting my GMDSS license, I have never sent one and really can't think of any time I would want to (outside of some distress situations). The only ones I have ever received are on the MF/HF from the morons who keep relaying other calls until it's hopped over to the western Atlantic from the Indian Ocean. Didn't take too long for me to become the master of acknowledging that thing (it's loud).





The only flaw I see in not actually placing the units at the location is if the aide or target moves then that would create a false location. Otherwise it's not a bad idea.
The AIS to DSC is a very nice feature when integrated into an entire system meaning, communications and navigation.
Bill
 
quote:

Originally posted by L. Keith

"The TV broadcast spectrum issue has zero to do with radar." On that point you are correct, but it shows the political climate and the direction the regulatory authority is headed. In the United States of America, the FCC has everything to do with radar and the frequencies that the units broadcast on! There is an old saying in broadcasting, What you once got for free, you now pay for.





Using that logic (which you are correct about the FCC) it's all about money. How about Microwave ovens? They generate a fair amount of crap especially and older units.
Bill
 
I think the things I object to with a mandatory AIS are 1.)being FORCED to spend money for a product that 2.)is somewhat an invasion of privace. How would we all feel if tomorrow we were told that all cars and trucks will be required to be equiped with tracking transponders (at our cost) in the name of safety? I know most people have cell phones and some have OnStar but imagine the potential for abuse of a system that monitors your every move. We have precious few personal freedoms left anymore and we seem more than willing to give those up in the name of "safety". I really think the AIS issue is more about money than any incremental incerease in safety from any attack.
JMHO
 
This whole area is one that I am very involved in professionally; I happen to be one of those guys lobbying (through CTIA) for more wireless broadband spectrum.

While mandatory AIS is highly unlikely to happen, I can see fees being assessed for any RF device, including wifi, Bluetooth, radar, AIS, VHF, EPIRB,GPS. Your cell phone bill is loaded with taxes, why not these? It would come in the form of licensing, additional FCC certification cost and/or excise tax on the device. Certainly it is politically possible, as the government is bankrupt. Of course, among the inevitable unintended consequences would be lower use and adoption of these important safety devices.

George
Hatteras 56MY
Boston Whaler 130 Sport
More RF devices than you can shake a stick at, but fewer than BillyIII....
 
So are we running out of electromagnetic spectrum? How will putting millions more AIS transponders on line reduce the amount of bandwidth being used? Am I correct in assuming that unless we eliminate some usage somewhere, more will not be available? In effect, we are robbing Peter to pay Paul. Elimination of old school analog trasmissions has freed up bandwidth so it would seem that we need to eliminate all the analog equipment out there now and repalce it with digital tech. to free up space. With that in mind, and in view of the expansion of AIS topic being discussed, it would seem that the entire VHF bandwidth could be eliminated and replaced with some hybrid form of AIS/DSC tech. For boat to boat communications we could use cellular phones or wireless instant messaging from our WiFi enabled laptops or PDAs. I know cellular service is poor along the coast, but couldn't antennas be installed along the coast and offshore (wind farms, fixed aids to navigation etc.) to boost range? I actually hate VHF radio because its so low fidelity its often difficult to understand the transmission. Add to that the number of people who don't use proper procedure when on the radio and the volume of traffic and its an almost unusable system sometimes, and has very limited range. I would be in favor of some kind of subscription service whereby CG and other emergency broadcasts could be transmitted on some kind of internet based device and relayed to my Droid or Iphone in both voice and text format. Subscribers could "broadcast" their own messages to selected others or to the general subscriber community in the same way. This should not use anymore bandwidth than VHF currently does. I relaize this would take a while to put into place and will cost money, but so will any upgrade in tech. Most people already have cell phones or PDAs so some of the platform could include existing hardware. If you can use a Droid as a metal detector, why not have an app for marine communications? There should also be waterproof, submersible, floating cell phones available for boaters now regardless of what other tech. evolves. Who here has ever lost a cell phone to Davy Jones? Or who hasn't? I'm not trying to be a smarta$$, but if we are in fact going to replatform marine safety and communications, why not integrate it into other existing techknowledgies instead of going about it in a patchwork fashion? This could be combined with freeing up the bandwidth that Caltexfla mentioned. Should be a business opportunity for some companies like Garmin et al. It would be much easier for boaters to use a familiar device like a cell phone or PDA than to have to own and learn to operate numerous seperate devices.
It astounds me that in this era of multifunction devices, that so many boaters still have so many individual devices scattered all over their boats. Ever look at some the pictures of the dash boards of used boats on yachtworld? Looks like the electronics displays at Best Buy, stuff on stalks and pods haphazardly strewn around the dash. I think an integrated approach would be much better. This would have to be done along the lines of the Loran deactivation and the digital TV change over. There would need to be a phase in period then a cutoff date after which, the old equipment will cease to be useful. Oh, and this could all be FCC licensed like in the old days of VHF, require a test and certification on operation and charge a yearly acess fee. Would provide jobs and money for the govt. to boot.
Sorry for the stream of conciousness ramble but thats how my mind works sometimes. How about it guys, does any of this hold any water?
BTW what band does HAM radio operate on? Is there any real need for amatuer radio in the internet age? Couldn't we turn that bandwidth over to better use in new applications?
 
Ham bands I operate are
50-54MHz 6 meters
144-148MHz 2 meters
222-225MHz the old 220 Band (lost 2MHz in the late 80's).
432-440Mhz
902-928Mhz the band is larger (shared ISM band) we only need 10MHz of spectrum here
1296Mhz same deal (shared ISM band) only 10Mhz is really needed for ham use
2304Mhz only 10Mhz is really needed here in my opinion This band has had huge chunks of spectrum reallocated and is under fire.
3456Mhz again 5-10MHz max is all that is needed
5760Mhz again (shared with 802.11A users we have a huge spectrum chunk only 10Mhz would be needed max).
10GHz 5 to 10MHz is all that is needed (operations center around 10368.100MHz)
24Ghz activity cebtered around 24.1Ghz 5 Mhz would be all that is really needed.

These are the bands that have real spectrum value.
Hams have tons of lower frequency bands but many of the spectrum positions are held by world treaty so it is just not the US
to say what hams can and can not use.
Many of the bands we are secondary users to the Military they are by far the largest overall spectrum owners/users.
Bill AA2UK
 
Back
Top