quote:
Originally posted by vic33004
kerry good point, EPIRB is really the only game in town for offshore work but it is not really aimed at the coastal market. the rescue 21 system is as most distress calls are in coastal areas. I'm not sure how many VHF radios are sold each year but i'm certain its a pretty healthy # and adding this technology to them is not a big deal when you talk about volume production. if they can put this stuff in a cell phone for next to nothing they can put it in a VHF. the AIS system when coupled with a radio just is'nt that hard, standard horizon is already selling one. I'm sure that for the foreseable future a commercial grade product suitable for a mission critical application like the bridge of a supertanker will remain very costly. but mandating this type of saftey gear for every boat would surely bring production up and costs down. even if they don't mandate it i'm willing to bet my lunch that the product i've described is coming.
The Standard Horizon unit, while a nice radio, still has lots of room for improvement (and this is not a knock on SH). First, it's a receiver only and SH is kinda vague on whether it's a true dual channel receiver or single receiver that switches back and forth between the two AIS channels. This makes an appreciable difference on the reception of target data. See:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gwnbRcB5P-s
Right now, the least expensive Class B AIS transceivers cost about $600+. A Class A will set you back a few grand. The technology is improving, but, IMO, nowhere near the same level as something that we take for granted these days like a radio or even GPS.
That being said, making it mandatory presents its own problems too.
First, I do not want my radar/ECS cluttered with 100 pleasure boat AIS targets on a summer afternoon, all trying to use their "gee-whiz, all-in-one unit to DSC call that tug over there" function because the AIS says we're going to get too close. At that point, I am turning off the overlay or setting the CPA/TCPA alarm setpoints to zero, in which case, we're back to square one with me exclusively looking out the window (which I should be doing in the first place).
Second, and this is on a broader note, there is too much of a trend these days to throw technology at the symptom of a "problem" than to treat its root cause. Mandatory AIS does little to treat the problem if the user doesn't understand basic watchkeeping and seamanship. Being on the water isn't/shouldn't be a computer game where you just avoid all the little triangles. I always get a much better kick out of learning something that involves my natural senses, rather than seeing what the latest gizmo is capable of.
AIS is a great tool, but it's use has to follow the demands of good seamanship, not the other way around.
Now, you wanna know something that would actually be effective if made mandatory? Brighter navigation lights. For the love of god, I don't know why something as simple as that is not tinkered with, yet here we are discussing AIS for vessels smaller than a ship's lifeboat.
Lastly, and on more of a personal note, I am tracked constantly at work, always talking with VTS, the USCG, the office, etc... (thank god we don't have a VDR...yet). For just once, I would like to spend an afternoon sailing around with nobody watching my every move. People sailed for thousands of years without AIS, right up until a few years ago. Doesn't take too much of existing tools to continue to do it safely with a sense of enjoyment.