Most reliable weather forecasting?

Riverbed

Active member
Member
Joined
Dec 2, 2005
RO Number
19680
Messages
1,176
Lots of choices out there for weather forecasts - National weather service, Accuweather, WeatherUnderground, local radio and TV, etc... I've found WeatherUnderground to be pretty accurate for every day forecasting and if I'm just doing coastal cruising, I'll check WU first, then monitor NOAA Wx radio and frequently check local weather rader from TV internet feeds while underway. Haven't progressed to radar overlays on the chart plotter yet. What does everyone else find useful and rely upon? What do you like - what do you hate?
 
WU is just serving the NOAA forecasts just like everybody else...

Intelicast.com Radar is probably my favorite. I always have it on my laptop whenver the weather is iffy (with a cell card). If you dont' have a laptop/air card on board, you can find some decent radar sites you can access from your cell phone browser, although hard to read

what do I hate? NOAA weather radio, it's a lousy tool for mariners... when a strong storm pops up, it goes into emergency mode and focus on that storm only. I've seen cases here in So Fl where the local station on VHF goes into emergency mode about a cell that's well inland and only affecting a few minivan driving soccer moms at the mall... and completly ignoring another cell offshore threatening those who are actaully listening on VHF!
 
Ummmm... I hate to say it, but they'er all presenting pretty much the same data from the National Weather Service. The primary difference is what they choose to focus on most and the quality of their maps. The forecast data is set when they recieve it via their link to NWS. I prefer WeatherUnderground because their products are top notch, always up to date and easy to read.

WeatherUnderground is the fastest with real time data than any other weather service available (yeah, I checked). They have a dual NOAAPORT satellite feed and a dedicated wired connection directly to the NWS servers. They process data so fast that they present hurricane data a full 8 minutes faster than the National Hurricane Center can with their own data!

I use this tool for planning my local boating trips: http://www.srh.noaa.gov/graphical/sectors/tbwMarineDay.php#tabs
It's pretty sweet and highly accurate through 48 hours. Not sure how many areas they are covering with this though.

FYI - I own a weather site :-)
 
SKeetobite is correct. They all use the same data, NWS. They also use the same forecast, NWS. What is different is the presentation, and speed of presentation.

In general, with regard to convective weather, you can only rely on real time data. While the forecast may say, "Scattered Thunderstorms, there is a world's difference between being under the cell and being 5 miles away. While NWS is good for identifying lines of T-stroms, it is useless for individual cells, because you need real time radar. While ship borne radar may be of some use, there is no substitue for a good ground based Nexrad picture, because you get not only an expanded view of the storm intensity, but wind velocities as well. A laptop with a data link is the best thing you can have for this picture.

As a Captain for a major airline, I often look at the Nexrad picture before departing the airport for two reasons. One it gives me the "big picture" and two I get a more detailed picture of storm severity as well as wind velocities than my aircraft based radar. If I have a long delay, I pull out my PDA/phone and look at the Nexrad picture there.
 
I can get satellite and Doppler feeds real time on my TV on two different channels. Those come in handy when I'm on my boat. I get an excellent signal almost everywhere that I boat using my digital converter [AC/DC]. I rarely listen to VHF anymore. Too slow; the voice loop is too long and the broadcasts are only updated twice a day.
 
WeatherUnderground, Navy wind and wave data site, Ocens weather software, Bouyweather.com, Wx from SAT radio displayed on a Garmin, Furuno, etc.

Don't use the VHF weather broadcasts much at all any more.
 
Back
Top