My Deviant Compass

jmicklov

Member
Joined
Dec 23, 2004
RO Number
15952
Messages
188
I've noticed my compass heading compared to my GPS (set to magnetic) heading can vary more than 20-30 degrees in some cases. I'm assuming the difference between the GPS heading and compass heading would be the actual deviation value for that specific heading.
I've been considering constructing a compass deviation table, but wonder if it should be checked first. I suspect it's the original boat compass (1994). the liquid is still clear and it doesn't appear to bind in any way.

Does anyone have any thoughts/suggestions? I'm in the Haverhill MA area if you know of any companies that service compasses or create deviation charts.

Thanks,
Jack
 
I believe that's way to much deviation. It should only be a couple of degrees.

Do you have electronics or anything magnetic near the compass? That will cause problems.
 
It's not too much deviation if only at slow speed in a cross current or at rest. If the vessel is drifting backwards they could read 180* different and both be correct.

GPS and compass headings are completely different concepts. Former is gps movement over ground , latter is direction the compass center lubber lines are pointing , generally the same as the fore/aft axis of the vessel of course. GPS could be set for magnetic or true, conventional compass only magnetic. The compass could need optimum adjusting to compensate for original and added onboard ferrous, magnetic and electromagnetic influence. Before constructing the deviation table which is a really good idea, try a compensation procedure 1st ( http://www.ritchienavigation.com/service/compensation.html ) or hire a compass adjuster as you are thinking of doing. The latter will probably use a portable version of a highly accurate gyrocompass and will give best results for both adjustment and deviation card but you can do it yourself with acceptable results if you are patient and thorough.

http://www.boston.com/jobs/news/articles/2007/10/28/staying_on_course/

All new compasses need adjustments and except perhaps on high-end boats that is generally left to the owner to accomplish. Same goes for any new installs of anything that might effect the compass at later date, especially speakers and some wiring, and care must always be taken when placing things near the compass even temporarily.

I once thought my compass was reading very pecularly and found when I removed a fishook that was sitting on the dash about 10" away the compass card swung nearly 10*. The deviation car will also prove that deviation is seldom if ever the same on all 360* headings . That is You could have a very substantial dviation influence at say , 260* that might not be noticeable at all at 0*, so a good professional compass adjustment is a really fine plan for all of our boats with compasses. (No... I'm not an adjuster :D )
 
Jack,
An easy way to check your compass and GPS is to take a heading between 2 points near you plot the Mag. and True. get your boat on that line and check to see just how far off you really are. you can use 2 buoys or a buoy and a point on land or even a mag. course that is already listed on your charts. Will take no time and may tell you where the problem lies.
 
switch stuff on and off and see it the needle moves. did you have any metal near the compass when you noticed the problem?
 
Thank you all for your excellent comments/suggestions.
I first noticed the variation when i installed my chart plotter and started seeing a difference between the GPS (magnetic)heading and the compass heading, which is really your 'course to steer'. The difference should be the compass deviation.
The chart plotter is mounted on the dashboard, about 2-3 feet from the compass. Everything else is original (as I received it).

Sandy- Thanks for the excellent suggestions. I'm going to plot a few course heading between some channel markers that are also on my chart and see what the compass and GPS indicate. That may only be a few points, though. In some of the courses, I've seen deviation values in the 12-25* range as well. And from those links you provided, there is someone in NH, which seems to be the closest.

I'm not sure I want to get into making compass adjustments and possibly make things worse instead of better.

Jack
 
Do you have Chapmans Guide to Boating and Piloting? They have excellent information on comprass calibration, taking headings and creating a deviation chart.
 
First make sure your compass is in aliginment with the fore/aft axis of your boat. You will find that most are not. Get a papar chart and find a set of range markers in a nearby channel. Most commercial ports have ranges set up that show the centerline of an approach channel. The compass heading for the range is shown on the paper chart. Run the range in both directions, making sure you are in visual alignment with the range marks and check your compass heading (have all electronics turned on, radar transmitting, ETC) Note the difference. This will give you a general idea of Deviation on those two headings. To make a proper deviation card hire a Compass adjuster that uses a transit and the sun. He will check deviation on all the Cardinal headings and prepare a Deviation Card to be posted adjecent to the steering compass. Keep your compass adjusted, you never known when the US Global Satellite system could fail, I hope it never happens during the summer on a weekend.
 
Jack;

are you saying your COG and your compass agree and conflict with the heading your plotter is reading? or is there a conflict between your COG and the actual compass? the COG over a fairly straight line and distance is your actual heading, the compass and the Heading called out by the plotter are both subject to problems of iron or magnetic field being to close to the compass. if you have an autopilot, there is a separate compass in the system that will share heading data with your plotter and if it is located too close to any metal with iron in it, it will goof up the reading depending on which way you are pointed. most auto pilots have a set up cycle that you have to run thru to calibrate the compass. try that first. if the deviation problem does not go away but simply changes orientation after recalibrating your sensor is located to close to an magnetic field or iron mass, try relocating the sensor to the low center point of the boat. hope this helps.
 
Jack, let's check it out Monday night. We can try a few things out as head down river.

And are you sure it's not a deviant owner? ;)
 
Since you first started noticing the variation after intalling new electronics, check to see if the power wires to the new electronics pass near the compass under the dash. An electric current will affect a compass, but this can be largely negated by twisting the power wires to the new electronics. Just a thought.
 
jmicklov, It is important to understand exactly what is being displayed.

Here is an example from my boat:

Magnetic Compass. Ok, fairly self-explanatory. Shows which way the boat is pointing. And subject to certain magnetic issues. ( wrench on dashboard...)

GPS COG: "Course Over Ground". This is the actual path over the sea bottom. It also has only a remote relationship with where the boat is actually pointed.

GPS Heading: Uses the electronic heading sensor attached to the autopilot and networked to the GPS. Like the magnetic compass, it uses the earth's magnetic field to sense the direction that the boat is heading, but is is affected by related, but different external influences. It is also sometimes subject to "transmission delay", as it is a networked device and can sometimes lag the realtime magnetic compass.

--

Setting the GPS to display "magnetic" does one thing, only. It applies the magnetic variation ( as given by your chart and location ) to all directional headings. It is applied ( on my system, as described above ) to both "Heading" and to COG. It is also possible to set it ti "True", and would force both displays to, again, display using the same unit of measure. ( In my locale, variation is less than 0.5 degree, and can effectively be ignored, inmost cases. This is not true in most locations. )

---

Whew. Now that I typed in all that: Which of the possible displays on the GPS ( COG, Heading ) are you comparing to your Magnetic Compass?

If COG, this is normal.
If heading It is time to make a card and or have the compass swung or find what is interfering with the compass.
 
Bill, the magnetic compass shows which way the compass is pointing, the fore/aft axis of the subject vessel must be in alignment with the fore/aft axis of the magnetic compass. It really gets squirrelly on boats with two control stations with two separate magentic compasses. That's why you have to designate a steering compass (PSC).
 
I would have assumed that the compasses are all aligned to the vessel center line. But I see your point: "... a man with two clocks is never sure."

Actually, each compass likely has it's own deviation card as well, so I see the need for the designation.
 
L. Keith, speaking of which, wouldn't the "off centerline error" be corrected by the deviation card for each compass?
 
quote:


Sandy- Thanks for the excellent suggestions. I'm going to plot a few course heading between some channel markers that are also on my chart and see what the compass and GPS indicate. That may only be a few points, though. In some of the courses, I've seen deviation values in the 12-25* range as well. And from those links you provided, there is someone in NH, which seems to be the closest.

I'm not sure I want to get into making compass adjustments and possibly make things worse instead of better.

Jack






Jack- Just to repeat an very important point that I believe is mentioned in the Ritchie link, if you do try adjusting be sure to only correct 1/2 of the error when running each leg, go through all the legs and then repeat all the legs correcting 1/2 each time. If you were to correct the full apparant error ech time , the result is over correction increasing deviation at the next or reciprocal leg and so on so you could end up chasing your tail. Nibbling down the error to best acceptable levels is the ticket.

If you use known true heading runs between charted points, remember to offset by the local magnetic variation found on the nearest compass rose on the chart, updated for this year.

Oh, and you'd want to use a non-ferrous screwdriver-like tool ( wooden , plastic, brass, etc.) to turn the 2 compensating screws.

It's very unlikely you would would make things worse by following Ritchie's directions if deviation is really ~25* already, and if so no matter as the pro could fix it . He could make your compass as accurate as it could get on your boat (until influences change on your boat), but you could make it a lot better. That said, one of mine is long overdue for adjusting though it's still pretty close.

By the way, if you happen to have an autopilot, the displayed heading taken from a recently auto-compensated fluxgate or rate-gyro heading sensor can be a handy heading source to compare your magnetic compass to.
Edit: Oops I see Vic already mentioned that last.
 
No, 20 to 30 is a heck of a lot of deviation. I've never seen in 40 years of flying a compass deviation card with that much.
 
Where's the nearest speaker? And what, exactly, does the compass disagree with? Course over Ground, or Heading?
 
Meant to add, where is the nearest electric motor, as well? Motors and speakers seem to have the greatest influence. A Nextel is also good for a 25 degree fling (we'll not go there, however).
 
Bill, no it would not. Deviation correction is for ship (local) induced error. You can correct the the compass and cancel out the local induced error, but the alignment problem still exist. The boat simply is not heading in the same direction as the heading on the magnetic compass. A 1 or 2 degree error in alignment will not be noticed on short runs, but that same error becomes a major problem on long runs. You compass will be showing say, 90 degrees, but due to the alignement error the boat will be moving on say a 93 degree heading. If you have other navigation devices you will be able to correct. As compassess have become more of a decorative item on boats and not the primary navigation tool, compass placement and alignment have become less important.
 
Back
Top