Navy Beach

mx8

Member
Member
Joined
Nov 28, 2006
RO Number
24359
Messages
600
This place looks interesting for a day stop just west of Montauk, anybody been there?
 
We were there a week ago. Don't waste your time or money. Food is overpriced and under quality. Service was poor. If you have more than 5 - 6 people they make you order "family style", which is that you can only order a couple of dishes to share - and they charge full price for the dishes.

The place is a rip-off, I wouldn't suggest to anyone that they go there.
 
quote:

Originally posted by HOGAN

We were there a week ago. Don't waste your time or money. Food is overpriced and under quality. Service was poor. If you have more than 5 - 6 people they make you order "family style", which is that you can only order a couple of dishes to share - and they charge full price for the dishes.

The place is a rip-off, I wouldn't suggest to anyone that they go there.





More proof that two people can have completely different experiences. Not doubting what happened to Hogan at all, but I was there for the first time last week and the setting and drinks were sublime, the food was excellent and the service was spot-on. Pricey? Yes. I can't wait to go back!

file-33.jpg

file-34.jpg
Untitled.jpg
 
I agree with Sierra - my experiences there have alway been excellent. We have always eaten outside on the beach. Never inside, and never a large party. The drinks, food, and atmosphere were great. Definitely expensive, but we always had a great time.

Vic
 
We went Sunday afternoon, hung out on the boat went in for food and stayed for the sunset and music. Worth the stop, nice setting, food was good but I wouldn`t call it worth the money, but then again your in Lawn Eyegland.
I guess they are closing for the season next week. Just one tip, it`s very deep (40 ftish) just off shore. We stayed the nite and although we stayed put with 250 ft of chain out I woke to a 56 Searay sedan bridge next to me . He dragged and stopped on my chain, only to release itself after a while and drifted off. I watched for the owner to wake up, no sign so i took the dink and did the hull knock to wake him up. He had a real surprised look when he looked around, had to be a good half mile from where he started. Also saw a big Carver drag out into the bay just before we left in the morning.
 
Back
Top