New Navigation Equipment

jim conroy

Member
exMember
Joined
Mar 2, 2000
RO Number
59
Messages
162
I don't want to get into details but I'm pretty disappointed with Raymarine.

I have an autopilot system, Radar/Chart and GPS and it does not work.

It is apparent that Raymarine does not have a clue about what is wrong. I have sent the course computer (AST2G) in, and spent hundreds of dollars (totaly wasted)on following their instructions. Now they want me to pull everything off and send it in, I mean the flux compass (which is new because they had me change it) auto pilot head unit, remote control and the course computer (again). So I'd be without any navigation equipment for who knows how long.

I really want this crap off of my boat.

Is anyone using the Northstar stuff, if so how do you like it?

Jim Conroy
420 DA 2004
 
make sure you copy down ALL serial numbers of every part you send them. They had my unit for 3 yrs, lost it and then MADE ME supply the serial number as proof they had it. There is NOT a chance in hades that I will ever buy another raymarine product.
 
They dont call it ray junk for no reason.

Jim when i ordered my boat I spoke to the dealers electronics guy he said at the time between the 2 choices I had ( rayjunk and northstar ) to go with rayjunk as it was the least worst of the two. They have lived up to there name on my boat as well but not to ur extreme. Id look inot garmin for ur plotter and furuno for radar... but yea unload that crap....

Rob
 
I'm not going to send my stuff back in.

I'm going to try two more fixes then in the scrap heap.

I'll have to go to the Miami show just so I can show up at the Raymarine booth to tell everyone within earshot how crummy thier products and customer service is.

Garmin is one option how about Furuno?

Jim
 
that kind of stuff cannot be diagnosed off the boat... you need a good marine electronic guy to diagnose the problem ON the boat... it could VERY well be a harness, power suply, interference, bad ground, etc...

what does not work. does the GPS/Plotter work? Does the radar work? what function does not work on the AP? is it a problem with the units not talking to each other?

to date, I am not impressed by Furuno but to be honnest that is using 2003 vintage equipment... I find their plotters and the Cmap chips to be absolutely terrible to use... (ex... the colors and numbers of day markers cannot be displayed.. they're all red!!! you have to go thru 2 or 3 menus to find out the numbers and colors...)

maybe the newer stuff is better...

to me, Garmin is a no brainer when it comes to plotters...
 
quote:

Originally posted by jim conroy

I'm not going to send my stuff back in.

I'm going to try two more fixes then in the scrap heap.

I'll have to go to the Miami show just so I can show up at the Raymarine booth to tell everyone within earshot how crummy thier products and customer service is.

Garmin is one option how about Furuno?

Jim






I hear from a dock mate that he is not pleased with his Furuno but strictly from a user friendliness point of view.

I asked here what GPS to buy when my old Ray Loran bit the dust. The overwhelming response was Garmin.

If your engines are SmartCraft compatible, Then Northstar is an option as they are the only manufacturer whose equipment can interfaces with the electronic diagnostics and information gizmos on that engine. If not, then I would go with Garmin based on the responses I received here.
 
Sorry to hear of your troubles. I have an older Ray Marine radar and use Garmin plotters.

So far, no issues with either one but having seperate electronics keeps me on the water in the event there is an issue with just one unit. Can't imagine having to send in the multifuntion display for one component failure and be at a loss without the other needed electronics. Good luck and keep us posted on the outcome.
 
Pascal is 100% right on the need to have it checked on the boat. You need a Certified Raymarine guy who is knowledgeable & can determine the problem. The installation is just as important as what you bought. I've had Raymarine but the installer was on the money.

Further, on the Northstar... I have the two Northstar 6100i Chartplotters linked together & I couldn't be happier with them. They are great! My radar is Furuno but it's a stand alone display except for the Lollypop on the course information. I like them as seperate units if you have the room? Much cleaner view of your obstacles if & when you really need to use it.
 
I have the Raymarine (C70) as well and I am not impressed. I was more impressed with my old Standard Horizon chartplotter.

I do like the Northstar Plotters (Fast clear and accurate) and the Furuno Radar.
 
Pascal,

It is a long story but I have a 'ghost' problem, the heading sensor will all of a sudden take a heading that is as much as 30 degrees from true.
Only on the COG and Autopilot display. The SR Navigator and RL80 CRC will display the correct 'true' heading as backed up by the factory compass.

Then just as suddenly the heading can return to normal.
I have replaced the flux compass, its a factory install so no pumps or hunks of steel nearby etc.
And the problem comes and goes, same problem weather I'm on a 'course' or just a heading.
I've sent the AST2G (course computer) back, performed numerous sea trail calibrations, normal deviation etc.

The problem is that there are NO compenent service techs in my area.

Steve I know Archie real well, however he won't come that far north.
Bought a boat from him way back when, took it from Pastrick to Door County in 6 to 8's (the same night my factory burned) but thats another story.

Jim
 
don't assume the factory install is right...

could be an issue with the wiring harness, a flaky connection, etc...
 
Pascal,

I agree but no one will check and near as I can tell its just ducky.
No one will take any responcibility either.

Sorta sucks to be me.

Jim
 
I have to disagree with Pascal on the Furuno stuff. I have a two year old NavNetvx2 system (1944CBBNT radar and 1920CBBNT networked plotter plus a NavNet Sounder) that use the Navionics Gold chips which show the markers just fine. Plotting a course is easy. We have used this system intensively, virtually daily, for the past year up and down the east coast.

I agree that the Garmin (at least the 2010 that I am familiar with) is a better user interface, but not remarkably so. I like the look and feel of Garmin's charts too, but I have not tried the new NavNet3D stuff. By having the two units, I have redundancy if needed. Furuno still seems to be the "Standard" when it comes to radar and sounders/fish finders.

Sorry to hear about the RayMarine issues; a boat we rented a lot in San Francisco had a Ray RL70CRC system that I liked fine.

George
 
I am not familiar with the AST2G autopilot and I couldn't find a mention of it on Raymarine's website. Is it an older model? Anyway, Raymarine's ST5000 series is famous for its software bug that occasionally injects a 90 degree heading turn when going to a waypoint. I don't believe there's any amount of tweaking the will remedy that situation. Perhaps just upgrading or replacing the autopilot would make your system more usable. I understand the newest Raymarine autopilots dispense with the rudder reference unit which can be problematic and they should have improved performance. Good luck!
 
quote:

Originally posted by caltexfla

Sorry to hear about the RayMarine issues; a boat we rented a lot in San Francisco had a Ray RL70CRC system that I liked fine.

George






This is almost the same system I had (my display was a little larger) RL80CRC + Plus. I was also very happy with this system.

* Another problem your Raymarine can be having is the position of the Fluxgate Compass or Heading Sensor? The position on the boat must be centerline & away from magnetics etc. You do need a guy on the boat?
 
The fluxgate compass is located properly. Sorry it is a S2GAST Smart Pilot with an ST 7001 Autopilot head unit.

I agree when they work they work fine, had many a raymarine stuff for years.
The fustrating part is Raymarines inability to properly service their equipment.
 
Jim, on the Raymarine site there should be a listing of Certified Raymarine Shops near you for sales or installs? If not, then I'd contact Raymarine to literally get somebody to help you locally. If they won't then I'd explain to them this thread & the wide audience of boaters who will know the problems you're going through? These electronics are a major cost & the one you choose is important to have 100% support or why even buy/consider it?
 
george, that's why is said "to be honest it is 2003 vintage"... apparently they improved them... but back then Garmin was already user friendly with superior charts.
 
If you decide to replace, I give another big thumbs-up to Garmin. I have a 4208 w/ GSD 22 sounder and G2 Vision chip, and am very happy with it. Straight forward installation (NMEA 0183 and Garmin network connections) and extremely easy to use. My only complaint is that when the satellite images are overlaid on the map above about 20% opacity, the screen redraw is very slow.

I wish Garmin's touch models had been available when I got my 4208, and had the boat bucks to spend on one. They are sweet.
 
Back
Top