New Prop Problems...Need some ideas?

toofast

Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2004
RO Number
15262
Messages
378
I am posting this for a friend, so I don't have every last detail...but I should have enough.

Bayliner, 24' with a 5.7 Bravo I

WOT with "original prop" was 4500 and he could cruise at 3500 RPM all day at 30 MPH.

Leaving a marina yesterday, due to extreme winds, the water was low and he hit bottom and damaged his original prop beyond repair.

So he goes to the local WM, gives his existing prop # and they cross reference to a new Quicksilver Black Diamond 15 pitch.

So he replaces and we go on a sea trial. Now at 3500 RPM's he can not stay on plane...he needs to run 4000 RPM's to stay on plane and his speed is about 26 MPH. BUT his WOT is still at 4500 RPM?

So he thinks he has the wrong pitch prop, and wants to swap...but what is crazy is his WOT is right on for his engines.

WM verified it is a direct cross match, and we did verify after that indeed it is.

So could the new prop have less cupping that changes the mid range, yet his WOT stays the same?

Any ideas?
 
Is the new one smaller dameter and larger pitch? Same # of blades?
Any other damage from the grounding?
 
Yes, sorry I should have added those details..

new prop is EXACTLY the same diameter and both are 3 Blades....and both are supposidly 15 pitch.

So other signs of damage. The edges of the blades were just damaged...the skeg is perfect and there are no other signs...

Strange indeed....
 
Very strange indeed. Was the original by any chance SS? I see from a search the Black Diamond is thicker & more flexible alu. Hard to believe cup is the difference if WM cross-referenced the original correctly since the Black Diamond apparently is available in single or extra cup so the new likely has the same.

It does sound like he would be better off getting the same make & part# as the damaged one if it's really not worth ("beyond repair") getting the 1st one serviced to ISO 1 spec by a good prop-scan shop.
 
No, original was Aluminum as well...

Well at least I know that I am not crazy....I think that is the only option as well, meaning try to find the original equipment prop !

Thanks for trying...of course if anyone else has any ideas, still open to listening.
 
try a different prop new props can be bad.
 
Is he the original owner? Sounds like somebody put an electronic rev limiter on the engine. I had one on an '83 Contessa to avoid blowing the engine when the prop fouled on eelgrass.

Try WOT in neutral.

And yes, enough cup could make the difference. Read David Gerr's "Propeller Handbook".
 
No this is not the original owner...but I am not sure why you think there is a rev limiter?

I thought the cupping of the prop could be an issue as well, but of course WM says no...but I know better than that...I've already told him to try and find the original equipment prop or take the old and new to a prop show to see what they say. I am out of all other ideas.
 
Find a prop shop and see if they can offer any more expert advise.
 
Agree with the cupping issue and Shadowcruzr. WM retails stuff to stay in business. A prop shop has to know props to stay in business. Huge difference.

Consider a Piranha composite. They have a good handle on the business. Additionally, they have (had) a blade swap program that allowed you to dial in the perfect blade for your boat. I had great luck with them.
 
Different prop manufacturer, different method of measuring pitch.
 
How long has it been since the boat was run. Is there any growth on the hull? It doesnt take much to cause this same issue. A quick cleaning could solve the problem..
 
It's common that props from different mfg's that are the same pitch behave different, differnet prop models from the same mfg. have different characteristics that's why they make them.. If pitch and size is correct, then the rake and cup could both be a problem. A good prop shop is the best answer. If one is not in your area then find a boat shop that will let you test different props.....of course if you mess one up you buy it.
 
quote:

Originally posted by van lafermine

How long has it been since the boat was run. Is there any growth on the hull? It doesnt take much to cause this same issue. A quick cleaning could solve the problem..






Actually the boat was run in the morning perfectly...then dinged the prop, then in the afternoon with the new prop. So pretty sure hull growth is not a factor..but good idea for sure.
 
It's the prop....I've had both Merc and Volvo SS props that were "bad" right out of the box.
 
As an example, I run a 26 pitch 4 blade hydromotive, in a Merc Bravo I 4 blade I would run a 28 pitch. Both good props but they behave differently, as far as RPM but also things such as bow lift.
 
Ok, sounds like for sure we have our answers.

We will try to find original...then if not available try a few other props/designs/pitch, etc.

Finally go to a prop shop if we can't get other test props, etc.

Thanks to all for helping!
 
There is a LOT more to props that just the pitch and don't ever assume 100% that because the prop says its a 15 pitch that it really is.
 
If you get a chance, could you please let us know what you find out? Post a follow-up to this. I'm interested to know what you find out...
thanks..
 
As Mark requested: Please follow up so others may learn.

I got home about 90 minutes ago after testing Saint Max with new propscanned props. WOW! The former 4000 RPM cruise speed by GPS is now achieved at 3400 RPM in the same slack tide.
 
Back
Top