New Users/Members

I agree with Capt.Bill1 and pdecat- listen to suggestions for improvement without judging their merit based on whether or not they have chosen to purchase a membership. It gives us more incentive to provide a site WORTHY of shelling out twenty bucks. IMHO, it's still very much deserving of a membership.

Hang in there getakey, you'll see it's a decent place to visit.

Peter
 
I agree with Capt.Bill1 and pdecat- listen to suggestions for improvement without judging their merit based on whether or not they have chosen to purchase a membership. It gives us more incentive to provide a site WORTHY of shelling out twenty bucks. IMHO, BoaterEd is still very much deserving of a membership.

Hang in there getakey, you'll see it's a decent place to visit.

Peter
 
quote:

Originally posted by BoatCrazy

This guy has been a member since October. Hes hardly posted ANYTHING, but he comes off telling us that he wants to see more people in that area. Really? How about my area? How about down in FL? Its just his specific area he wants to change. If he REALLY wants to make BE better then be a supporting member and anchor up..PLAIN AND SIMPLE. YOU WANT CHANGE FOR THE BETTER, DONATE THE MONEY FIRST.

Dont come to the greatest boating forum and make statements how you want change. He hasnt been here long enough to experience ALL this site has to offer. Ive been a paid member for about a year now, and I just got my feet wet in NBR not too long ago. Let him experience this site for all it has to offer and then lets see if he thinks it needs change.

You could get another 1000 members but I think I can speak for almost everyone here, that BE doesnt need the BS that those other sites have. This is an awesome forum, great people, knowledge is unbelievable, and I truely learn something everyday on this site.

Dont single one area out, say you want more people for all areas. Thats all I am getting at.






Perhaps you should read my original post more carefully before going off. I simply stated that I thought the site would be better with more members - "especially the Bay Area". Perhaps you should encourage people in your area to join as well.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Cobalt 25

I agree with Capt.Bill1 and pdecat- listen to suggestions for improvement without judging their merit based on whether or not they have chosen to purchase a membership. It gives us more incentive to provide a site WORTHY of shelling out twenty bucks. IMHO, BoaterEd is still very much deserving of a membership.

Hang in there getakey, you'll see it's a decent place to visit.

Peter






Will definitely be hanging in and I already know its a decent place to visit.
Thanks for the welcomes - did not expect my post to generate such controversy although I think most of the flame came from one person.
 
GetaKey:

Nobody speaks for me, but me. Welcome aboard. Get involved in the forums that you choose, and help make this a better site. I'm sure your contributions will be appreciated.
 
quote:

Originally posted by carver 2557

Do you use Carrier Pigeon...That's what the Owl wanted you for...he had a message for you from the Pigeon...






Dang, that whole owl incident is becoming much clearer now.
 
Jerry, how could you say this site would be better with my people? You havent been around long enough to really experience it all. Thats all im saying. Dont judge a book by its cover.. Read it and ull love it for what it is not what it could be.
 
Matt; Your RO # is 1500 less than Jerry's and you judge when someone has been around long enough?

"It is what it is"
 
Pete - Right outta my profile Member Since: Sep 25 2008

Right out of Jerrys profile Member Since: Oct 11 2010

2 years buddy seems like enough time for me to be around here to "judge" people. Granted, I havent been around since 2001 like you have, but someone whose been around for just under 4 months come on dude. Im all for new members, and its not up to me how many new people join. However, someone making statements on how this site would be better with more members makes NO sense..He hasnt been around long enough to experience this forum..
 
I think the problem is that you are "judging" me. I read the Forum for many months before I joined. In addition, I don't think it takes years of experience to understand what is happening in the Forum. IMO, the site would be better with more members. That's my opinion. You can have your own.

Also, I don't think whether or not a potential new user has a free email account is a measure of their "quality".
 
I don't believe that you neccesarily need to trade the quality of the forum for new membership. I believe that the two of them can go hand in hand with each other. Getakey makes a reasonable suggestion, and I for one think that makes perfect sense.

Posting on "Ask the Captain, and berating people for not anchoring up is one way to keep the membership down. Boatered is a great site and most of us were registered here long before "NBR" came along. The purpose of the Anchor was to show support to Les and George for providing this boating forum.

Someone should only be "judged" through months of inter-action. As you read RO's post over time you will begin to learn a little something about their make-up, values and core beliefs. For someone to feel the need to Judge another RO based on one post is totally unfair.
 
Im not sitting here judging anyone. Im all for NEW members but to compare boatered to other forums and say how we have very little members compared to other sites its just a dumb comment. No offense Jerry. Part of what makes boatered the best boating forum around is the quality of the people that post. Yeah we get the trolls on this site who cause trouble, but NOT compared to other sites who get it all day every day.

All Im saying is how can you come here make judgments about a site. Great so you've been around here for a few months before joining, thats great. Im glad you joined. You seem like a quality guy, just slow down with the "improvement" list..Take boatered in, youll see as the months change more and more members who have already joined will start posting again..
 
Also, I don't think whether or not a potential new user has a free email account is a measure of their "quality". WHO SAID THAT?
 
quote:

Originally posted by BoatCrazy

Also, I don't think whether or not a potential new user has a free email account is a measure of their "quality". WHO SAID THAT?






My original post stated that I thought removing the restriction on free email addresses to join the forum would add more members. There were replies (including from you) that a larger forum would lower the quality. Thus, some must think that restricting on the basis of free email is the criteria to keep out "low quality" members.
 
I have to agree with In The Know, this thread is nonsense on top of nonsense.
 
I use a yahoo account. There were a ton of other members who use free e-mail accounts and they even said so. NEVER did I say anything about e-mail accounts. All I mentioned was the quality of the members..

This is going no where, turning into a pissing and moaning match..Enjoy the forum
 
quote:

Originally posted by In the know

I have to agree with In The Know, this thread is nonsense on top of nonsense.






kinda like whose lining up illegaly on the side lines?
 
Back
Top