Nuclear Submarine Collison

saltysam

Active member
Member
Joined
Mar 2, 2000
RO Number
26
Messages
1,117
Undamnbelievable but a French and a British Nuclear Submarine have Collided in the mid-Atlantic.

Substantial damage reported to both ships who were operating submerged and independently. Guarded reports from both Navy HQ claim no loss of life, no radiation leakage..Both ships have returned to port. Both are reported to have had nuclear missiles aboard. No confirmation.

A Google search will pull up the scant information available.
Try this:
http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/wor...packed-nuclear-missiles-crash-underwater.html
 
I only wonder how many times it has happened before and not reported.
 
i can tell you it used to happen all the time during the cold war. when we and they had bunches and bunches of submarines out there. sonar back then was not an exact science. at that time if a sub didnt want to be found it wasnt. During war games when it was our time to be found by another sub the CO would often have someone beat on the hull with a wrench to help the other boat find us. generally navies have procedures to keep subs from hitting one another when they are in the same area. but when your talking different navies. If they were not in some type of war game together most likely one or the other or both had no idea the other was out there. And by the way I could neither confirm nor Deny the fact that any submarine I ever served on ever had a collision with another sub nor could I confirm we spent 2 months in dry dock getting repairs.
 
Back in my time (25 yrs ago) NATO submarines, including the French, provided submarine movement reports to all concerned. The French, being French, provided their movreps in french! I can't speak french but I can read a movrep in french. Anyway one would presume that such a system doesn't exist anymore. If it still exits then some staff screwed up in not putting the word out. Most submarines don't run around blasting away with active sonar - makes it hard to remain undetected! Also, if they were head on or nearly so then there would be little chance of hearing one another. Most of the collisions I know about happened near choke points like the entrance to the Med. If this was in mid ocean then it's less than one in a million! Luck. Dale
 
There are a few cover stories circulating. One has it that neither s/m knew about the collision, each reported an encounter with something.The French supposedly hit a submerged metal container lost from a container vessel. Another tale has it that the French were tardy in passing the routine reports to the Brits. A lot of egg on their faces, all round.
 
Could have been they were working together and got the assignments screwed up or one was trailing the other and was a little off.
 
These things exist as a listen-shoot combo. Damage to the sonar can run into millions of Dollars/Euros/Pounds to repair. Not a trivial event. Bondo is good, but...
 
Well, it does indicate that the Brit sub is quiet enough that the French can't hear them... ( under certain, undisclosed circumstances ).

From what little I know, a sub at sub-sea cruise speed is effectively blind. I wonder... Bah. They will never tell us what -really- happened.
 
. . . Isn't possible the French were simply trying to surrender - again?!??!!?
 
Probably a bit of "Search for Red October" going on from both vessels.
 
Enscribe this event as one of "The Mysteries of the Deep Oceans".
 
Back
Top