Offer accepted....any red flags???

Not my kind of boat, but dam, good looking. Slow, little draft, beam to small for the length. Not knowing the use can't say more. I like the traditional look though.

2'6" draft and an 8'6" beam mskes it a pond, bay, lake boat, not a rough water boat. If that is your intended use, then cool. nice boat.
 
quote:

Originally posted by walterv

Not my kind of boat, but dam, good looking. Slow, little draft, beam to small for the length. Not knowing the use can't say more. I like the traditional look though.

2'6" draft and an 8'6" beam mskes it a pond, bay, lake boat, not a rough water boat. If that is your intended use, then cool. nice boat.






Puget Sound, exclusively.

Survey describes it as a "V-hull, soft chined underbody, full keel,skeg mounted rudder, and vertical transom." The seller claims it's a fairly dry boat, despite the low profile.

We're attracted to the .7 gph at cruise (6.5 knots) and that it tracks straight. With previous and current boats, it was always the destination that counted. With this boat, we're hoping it will be the journey.

-Greg
 
Well sounds good then, best of luck, nice looking boat.

Walter
 
<<...."beam to small for the length."......2'6" draft and an 8'6" beam mskes it a pond, bay, lake boat, not a rough water boat."...>>

Having a narrow beam does NOT make it less appropriate for sea-keeping. "Wider is better" is a very common myth. For a given displacement, generally longer and narrower is better. Narrower will also help it slice the waves in in head seas better and is generally more fuel efficient. It's no accident that boats like USCG cutters are long and narrow, as are offshore racing boats. More beam is great for having more roominess and it's great for stability at the dock. But more beams does not translate to better sea-keeping while underway. If given a choice, take more length over more beam.
 
Glen.
"Having a narrow beam does NOT make it less appropriate for sea-keeping. "Wider is better" is a very common myth. For a given displacement, generally longer and narrower is better"

We are talking about boats, not a penis. :)

I am all ears on this, I say that with respect, my understanding is different. With respect, please educate me.

Walter
 
quote:

Originally posted by OLD HOUSEBOATER

Lotsa money for a little bitty boat.






I didn't pay 73k. It's loaded. Also, it's a bit of a cult boat, like the Nordic Tug 26'. Sam Devlin is a very respected wooden boat builder and designer.

-Greg
 
Walter- check out this boat. 57' footer with only an 11' beam- went ALL the way around the world and built for expeditions and fuel economy.

http://idlewildexpedition.ca/theboat.htm

I'm no naval architect but I do believe I've read multiple times that a more narrow boat with longer length will be more economical and still maintain good sea keeping- it's just not as liveable!

I think that is one beautiful looking litle trawler and would most likely be very fun to own!!
 
Just look at USCG cutters, Naval vessels, and Offshore racers. All have a narrow width to long length ratio. Stubby wide beam boats are marketing, and to satisfy that want,.... especially in the U.S.
"Look how roomy this one is honey". As much as I disdain much of what Europeans do, they do make their boats narrower, overall. Wide boats appeal to an American market.
When I have more energy, I'll look up the actual naval architecture stuff about long and narrow versus more stout.
 
Tony,
My comments ment no disrect, and do appreciate any knowledge giving here.
 
I think a lot of the confusion comes from the fact that wider beam boats have more of what is called "initial stability". This is the stable feeling you get on a wide beam boat at the dock or in calmer seas. Underway, and in harsh weather, the "rules change"...or are applied differently, as you no longer have that initial stability. Wider will definitely pound more and "snap" more when subject in rolling motion.

I'll get more info later.
 
I don't want to rain on your parade and not to push this one boat, but I happened to be looking at it online the other day. http://www.yachtworld.com/core/listing/boatDetails.jsp?boat_id=177
6354&checked_boats=1776354&ybw=&units=Feet¤cy=USD&access=Public&listing_id=1673&url=

As a point of comparison, 7 years older, $24,500 less, 6 feet longer, almost 4 ft wider, twin diesels (redundancy) at 4 gph total at trawler speeds, 7.5 gph at 15-17 kt cruise (if you NEED to run fast for weather or other emergency), full shower, more water and holding, more seaworthy, generator.

If trailerablility is important to you, then it looks like you've found a great vessel for the mission. She sure is pretty!

If getting there (and back) more comfortably is the plan, maybe other options at a lesser price are feasible. You can buy a lot of diesel for $24000. Only you can judge.
 
Hey Greg, great looking boat, and agree on the strong following, especially in the sound. I lived in Anacortes two years and ran boats all around up there, and I agree that this boat is great for that body of water and use intended.Congratulations!
 
walterv -

Regarding the length to beam thing, there is an informative site called boatdesign.net . It has a lot of Europeans on it, so it does reflect their preference for narrower beams. But it does so with good reason.

From boardesign.net .... .

"It's generally accepted that for a planing hull for normal service one should not employ a length : beam ratio of less than 3:1, and that thinner is generally better in terms of efficiency and seakeeping."
 
quote:

Originally posted by Chesagansett

<<...."beam to small for the length."......2'6" draft and an 8'6" beam mskes it a pond, bay, lake boat, not a rough water boat."...>>

Having a narrow beam does NOT make it less appropriate for sea-keeping. "Wider is better" is a very common myth. For a given displacement, generally longer and narrower is better. Narrower will also help it slice the waves in in head seas better and is generally more fuel efficient. It's no accident that boats like USCG cutters are long and narrow, as are offshore racing boats. More beam is great for having more roominess and it's great for stability at the dock. But more beams does not translate to better sea-keeping while underway. If given a choice, take more length over more beam.






Agree. My current Pursuit has a length of 31' and a beam of 10.5ft. No sea-keeping problems there.

G
 
Judging strictly by the photos, engine access for maintenance looks difficult.
 
quote:

Originally posted by walterv

Tony,
My comments ment no disrect, and do appreciate any knowledge giving here.






No worries Walter- didn't think you did! :) I don't know anything about naval architecture!
 
I'm not sure I'd call it a "trawler" but I'd be proud to have one on MY dock!

I think we'll be seeing more of that type of boat in the future.
 
Back
Top