One or two engines

MarcJ

Member
Joined
Mar 6, 2008
RO Number
29549
Messages
195
I'm considering a new small boat around 28' and I would like opinions regarding having one or two engines. I understand the safety of having two engines but one engine would be easy to maintain and it would use less gas. What are the chances to be left cold in the water if going out with one engine only? Anybody with experience on that?
Thanks.
Marc
 
Unless your going off shore I would think one would be fine, assuming it's large enough to give decent speed and time to plane when the boats loaded.
 
Basically, you play the odds. However, you decrease the odds of being stranded as long as you do the required maintenance on time. There are many people happy with a single engine. It's all a matter of your comfort level and possibly financial ability. I had boats with only one engine and never considered being stranded. Just can't be paranoid about it. Just make sure you have all the safety equipment and communications required. When you have everything then the comfort level feels better.
 
Two engines will be best from a safety point of view only if all of its components are independent. For instance, they should each have their own fuel tank. If you get bad fuel, then only one engine would be affected. Same with batteries, etc.

Handling is also a factor. A twin engine boat that size is easier to maneuver; if you get a single engine, make it a duel prop sterndrive.
 
On that size boat, the close quarters handling advantage of twins is worth considering. If you're considering an express cruiser of that size, you should consider the relative ease of docking with twins v. a single screw especially in challenging conditions such as wind, currents, etc.
 
First off, what type of boat and what is your intended use. What type of power are you looking at, Outboard, I/O, or inboard. I have owned all possible configurations, and ironically, the only time I have been stranded was with twin outboards. Singles do have their benefits, as do twins. I have been over a hundred miles offshore with a single engine boat and had no worries in doing so.

If it is redundancy and safety you are concerned about, a single with a kicker may be your answer. Also, I would have not issues with a signle IB in a boat that size, in fact I would prefer it over a single OB or sterndrive.

" If you get bad fuel, then only one engine would be affected"

That statement only holds true if you fill your separate tanks from separate fuel suppliers.
 
That size boat is a tradeoff. Twins are better no doubt, but it will be hard to work on twins in a 28' boat. Very tight.
 
" If you get bad fuel, then only one engine would be affected"

That statement only holds true if you fill your separate tanks from separate fuel suppliers."

You have a good point there ITK! Thanks.
 
gas consumption will actually be very similar since the single engine boat would have a big block engine while the boat with twins would use two small blocks. handling will be easier with twins. maintenance with twins is twice as much as for a single engine boat and access to the engines is tougher, so you'll be charged more hours by the marina doing maintenance or work on the engines. one other thing to cosnider, whether you get a boat with one or two engines is performance. even some twin engined boats can be underpowered if not properly equipped. as far as getting stranded because you have just one engine, it's definitely a possibility and a greater possibility if you're purchasing an older boat where maintenance is uncertain and parts are nearing the end of thir life cycle. i had an older 27'express cruiser with a single engine. performance was fine, but i was stranded several times before a problem was diagnosed and eventually resolved. the problem was that the risers and manifolds were corroded and needed to be replaced. btw, this is something that needs to be done every 3-5 years for raw water cooled boats which run in salt water and should be factored into overal maintenance costs (mine cost about $4k - ouch). i've lost either the port or stbd engine on my current twin engine boat, but never at the same time, so i've always been able to get home, albeit slowly. however, docking a twin engine boat on one engine is no fun. regardless of how many engines the boat has, if it's used, you should have it surveyed prior to purchase.
 
Having a good towing service plan is always a good idea! Well worth the peace of mind and one tow will cost more then a year's cost for a plan.
 
a large single with a tow plan is my suggestion...of course that all depends on how you intend to use the craft. Docking is also a consideration...with a 28' boat and a single docking will be harder to do than with twins.
 
Engineers say if you can get all the HP out of one engine, stick with one. Go to two when you need more than one can provide, considering weight/horspower ration of course.
 
And regardless of 1 or 2 engines, the tow plan is a must. If you are operating where winds/currents play a significant factor, twins hands down. Much better control and maneuverability.

And if you're that concerned about operating cost differential of 1 vs 2 engines, think twice about buying a boat unless you put it in your mind you will be spending MONEY and lots of it over the years regardless. Let the boat size and your boating objectives drive whether it comes with 1 or 2 engines.

Jack
 
i think from a fuel and overal cost perspective if you can find a single I/O or 4 stroke outboard your fuel economy and maint. costs will benifit over dual inboards.
 
I have a 28ft boat with twin engines. Everything everyone has said is true. I think at 28ft you are right on the edge for an express. There are larger trawler style boats with singles but assuming a planing hull boat, at 28 ft twin's start to be important for close quarter handeling as well as power to weight ratio. My boat is actually 31ft LOA and 10k lbs displacement. So it's on the big side. But I would definitly want twins on mine. A large single was not even an option. And as for safety of two, not so sure. I did limp home on one engine once. But had I had a single I would have limped home with Sea Tow. If you do the maintenance, either set-up should provide reliablity.

Given the large relative expense of any boat purchase, I would not focus too much on cost savings of single vs. twin. Maintenance may be a bit less but fuel consumption is likely to be about the same. And given all the other cost of boating, better to go with the set-up that will provide the most pleasure and performance than the one you "think might" be cheaper.
 
MarcJ:

You have received some good advice from some experienced boaters.

IMHO, your intended use of the boat is the single most important factor. Where you boat, and how far away from "home" you will go, are really important.

In my case, a tow plan for a single engine 30' diesel boat (or for the twin diesel that I have) isn't of much value, 'cause I go poking around in places so far removed from "civilization" that I can't reach the Coast Guard, the towing company, or any other boat on VHF.

I have made 7 forced single engine trips in 8 years and 2550 engine hours and 4 summers of 2700-3500 nm. The longest was 82 nm over 15.7 engine hours between 7 am 10:30 pm. If you are contemplating that kind of usage, go with twins. I'm glad I did.

Old_Salt
 
Thank you for the good advice.
Because of price consideration, I'm considering either a Bayliner or a Sea Ray or a Regal 28'. They come with either a Volvo Duo Prop or a Mercruiser Brave 3. I also won't be too far from marinas and close to help if needed.
 
I would hands down go for a single on a 28' boat.

1. Cheaper to run (gas, maintenance, etc)

2. Easier to work on

3. A single big block with duo-prop (or bravo 3)is plenty for a boat this size and also very manuverable.

4. For under $150/year, you can have BoatUS towing in case of break downs.

5. I wouldn't consider twins until you step up into the 30' size.

6. Master a single screw before stepping up to dual screws. It will make you a better captain and make you appreciate the ease later on.

Doug
 
I have a 28 ft with twin 350 Merc mpis. On an extended cruise with a friend who has a cruiser with twin 6 cylinders, I got 30% better fuel economy than him. Twins will not burn more fuel if you don't use the extra power....period!!! Aside from that, the maintenance is double... which is expensive. Aside from that, my twins have brought me home on several occasions on 1 engine...I wouldn't go offshore without twins. On a lake its really not a big deal if someone tows you in.
 
After being stranded 3 times with a single, I swore I would NEVER get a single again.

The piece of mind is worth it alone.

I can't imagine trying to handle our 28' without twins.

I vote twin for sure.
 
Back
Top