Piracy--the FUTURE

would'nt it be cheaper for all for the shippers of the world transitting this area, to offer a bounty for pirates caught on the high seas rather than paying outragous sums of ransom? after all its always been about money, why not hire the bums to hunt each other rather than cargo ships.
 
Following the American ingenuity, there is money to be made here!

I will call this new enterprise "Adventure Cruise". We are offering a wide range of firearms on our ships cruising the Strait of Aden ( the only place we cruise, in a large circle), from the traditional "Over-Under" for the eclectic Sporting Clay Gentleman to the railing mounted fitty cal for the testosterone-ladden teenager to the high powered water hose for the jokster.

The only onboard entertainment offered is a variation of fairground favorite "Wack-A-Mole" which we call "Hose-The-Pirate".

Beverages and All-you-can-eat buffets are all inclusive. Professional shot commemorative DVDs of your trip can be purchased at the Souvenir stand.
 
Now that's a great idea, Dom ! With some smart calculations it might be a most profitable venture. Wonderful! Any chance of your running for Congress?
 
The adventure cruise sounds like fun, but you'd have to keep repainting the ship, so they don't recognize it on the next pass. They're not THAT stupid.
 
It's HAPPENED AGAIN

MOMBASA, Kenya (AP) - Undeterred by U.S. and French hostage rescues that killed seven bandits, Somali pirates brazenly hijacked three more ships in the Gulf of Aden, the waterway that's become the focal point of the world's fight against piracy.

The latest trophy for the pirates was the M.V. Irene E.M., a Greek-managed bulk carrier sailing from the Middle East to South Asia, said Noel Choong, who heads the International Maritime Bureau's piracy reporting center in Kuala Lumpur.

The Irene was attacked and seized in the middle of the night Tuesday - a rare tactic for the pirates.

U.S. Navy Lt. Nathan Christensen, spokesman for the Bahrain-based 5th Fleet, said the Irene was flagged in the Caribbean island nation of St. Vincent and the Grenadines and carried 23 Filipino crew. Choong reported a crew of 21, and there was no immediate way to reconcile the figures.

A maritime security contractor, speaking on condition of anonymity because it is a sensitive security issue, said the ship put out a distress signal "to say they had a suspicious vessel approaching. That rapidly turned into an attack and then a hijacking."
 
I think the pirates are just the tip of a much larger organized crime outfits in Somalia. The actual young men that are sent out to capture the ship are most likely the disposable poor that are hired by crime bosses. After all, you need a big infrastructure in place if you are going to hold several large ships and collect big pay-offs from insurance companies. Fixing that problem completely requires fixing the whole failed country.

About the only way to reduce the number of attacks is to change the UN Convention on the Law of the Sea to reintroduce concepts of ‘universal jurisdiction’ and hostis humani generis (enemies of humanity). As it stands now a suspected pirate ship has to be boarded by party led by an officer. If the pirates are taken prisoner there is total confusion under whose laws they should be held. The British navy has been told to let captured pirates go because they are afraid the pirates would be able to claim refugee asylum in Britain. If the rules were changed so that a suspected vessel could be shelled if the crew did not surrender, and prisoners would be tried and convicted under an international law then you are going to at least see a reduction in piracy.

Cheers, John
 
Yesterday, one of the PBS stations had an 'expert' talking about the subject. One of the things he said which made some sense is the insurance companies would rather pay a couple million per ship taken rather than risking a couple hundred million worth of cargo.

In other words, why hire a deterrent when the insurers are willing to pay...and can you force the insurers to risk their cargo as it were.
 
An effective solution to the Somali pirate problem is going to get pretty complicated and will take some time. There is no one-size-fits-all solution. First will be measures on the sea to prevent hijacking including increased patrols, convoys, defensive measures on shipping and control of illegal fishing in Somali coastal waters. Military action against pirates facilities are always a possibility. Efforts to promote an effective Somali government are also required. USN and Somali leaders both support the idea of a Somali Coast Guard if the political situation stabilizes.

Here is an interesting map showing all piracy action in the Gulf of Aden during 2008. This doesn't show piracy in the Indian Ocean which has increased this year.

http://unosat.web.cern.ch/unosat/fr...cy/UNOSAT_Piracy_Gulf_Aden_2008_Lowres_v7.pdf
 
Ok,
Let’s think outside the box here, my understanding is the ships can’t be armed because the port they visit will not allow this. Because of the vast area and the amount of ships that travel this area it is not economically feasible to have a “protection armed boat” that escorts you.

So, with that said, here are two options that may be viable, option 2 is the one I like.

Option 1:
You coordinate trips from ports to travel in a group; therefore all those ships split the cost of a “protection armed boat”

Option 2
A ship leaves a port; they then hook up with another ship that arms them, upon arrival to their destination port , another ship is waiting and disarms them. So in short, what you have is a ship at every port (not sure how many ports that would be) that arms and disarms. I think this is a viable option, all the ships that travel in this area contribute to the security of their vessels, another words, they all share the cost.
 
Walter's suggestions are worth considering. My hesitation is that they each require some dedicated ships,crews and considerable coordination. Who will provide the money and staff services to get either scheme off the deck ?
 
"Who will provide the money and staff services to get either scheme off the deck ?"

Ultimately the customers; either through taxes or raised prices.

My guess the shipping companies have already done the math, and decided that paying the ransom on the occasional ship is actually the cheapest way to go. However the cheapest way is not always the best way, as it encourages the pirates.
 
Another option is to just forget the Suez Canal and go around South Africa. Some shippers have done just that. Not good.

If international shippers were serious about defensive measures they could lobby for changes in international law to allow armed merchant vessels port privileges. This would be a lot easier to do for small arms as opposed to deck guns. As long as they can have national armed forces to pick up the bills or they can pay cheap ramsoms to the pirates they will chose the least expensive solution for the industry.

The international shippers are not the only players in this game. You have private boats and yachts, fishing boats and local shipping in transit as well as illegal fishing boats. Four hijackings happened in the last 48 hours. Two were Egyptian fishing boats. My guess is that they were breaking Egyptian-Somali treaties with illegal fishing.
 
quote:

Originally posted by stmbtwle

"Who will provide the money and staff services to get either scheme off the deck ?"

Ultimately the customers; either through taxes or raised prices.

My guess the shipping companies have already done the math, and decided that paying the ransom on the occasional ship is actually the cheapest way to go. However the cheapest way is not always the best way, as it encourages the pirates.






You may be right Willie, but as this escalates, the costs get higher, now they are threatening, to “kill” the crew on American and French ships, another new twist. Also, I would think that they figured in as part of their costs, an “escort” boat, obviously that makes paying ransom much cheaper. Again, my thoughts on option two, has a fixed cost that is shared by all those that travel this region.
I would also think that the insurance you pay may go down if you subscribe to option two, kind of like having a lojack in your car.
If this type of system was implemented (option two) and you did not want to pay the fee for this protection, well then your on your own, another words, no military intervention, you knew the risk, did not take appropriate action, your on your own.

What do you think the cost was to have our Navy go rescue this ship? IMHO, this is crazy, why should our armed services become security guards for commercial ventures, security guards that work for free.

The owners of these vessels that travel this region are aware of the danger that exists, the crews that pilot these boats are aware of the danger that exists, with that said, they need to do what needs to be done to protect themselves, and the costs involved is a cost to do business. We as taxpayers should not be incurring those costs by protecting them or coming to there rescue. We as taxpayers will incur this cost as increased prices for the cargo they carry and the cost to protect this cargo, that is fair and a cost of doing business.
 
Why not have the affected Navies coordinate a blockade of all Somali ports?
 
There are only two Somali ports large enough to be worth a blockade. "Pirate port" is a myth. The mother boats and chase boats depart from dozens of locations along the two Somali coasts and probably from Yemen as well.
 
Why can't they create a narrow shipping lane, sort of like a canal.
Then they can patrol that canal. Its not a huge open ocean. I realize ships go in all directions but they can come out of gulf of aden, stay straight in narrow zone until they clear Somali area, then branch out.
Using radar surveliance this canal zone can be monitored with a few fast gun ships and funded by money or fees collected from ships using the zone. If you don't use the zone, you are at your own luck.
 
Dave

Dave--You might be interested to learn there is a lot of talk about your idea. There are a few very heavyily travelled
ocean routes and it is quite likely that the many navies that are working the area will start to
concentrate their attention there.

Try to hook up with the Eaglespeak Blog. www.eaglespeak.us is a possible address. There has been a decent discussion as well as charted ship tracks over the past several days.
 
quote:

Originally posted by CurrentSea

Why can't they create a narrow shipping lane, sort of like a canal.
Then they can patrol that canal. Its not a huge open ocean. I realize ships go in all directions but they can come out of gulf of aden, stay straight in narrow zone until they clear Somali area, then branch out.
Using radar surveliance this canal zone can be monitored with a few fast gun ships and funded by money or fees collected from ships using the zone. If you don't use the zone, you are at your own luck.





Take a look at the map I linked earlier in this thread. It's called "Atalanta" and has been in place since December.
 
The mother ships are the key. There is little chance that the high-speed boats used for the boardings can operatre hundreds of miles from port without a support ship. A medium or large ship configured to support the high-speed boats should have a unique signature. No-warning attacks with large caliber weapons to sink every pirate mothership would quickly reduce the threat.

We have precedents for this type of action. No one tried to arrest the Nazi commerce raiders or the orginal Barbery pirates; they were simply sunk as quickly as they could be found.

No compassion, no hand wringing and no U.N. resolutions are required.

Mike
 
Back
Top