Please, watch your wake.

I am glad to hear you are safe and no one was injured. I would pursue this issue with the cost guard, local marine police, and your insurance agent. Make sure you document everthing that has happened as well as getting the name or names of the coast guard individuals you spoke with. Also file a report with your local marine police.
I hope you are able to recover the cost to repair the damages caused by the captain/owner of the vessel.
 
well, let me start by saying that when transiting the ICW I always slow down for vessels anchored and fishing. Slow down mean down below hull speed, minimum wake. Throwing a large wake is wrong and dangerous and what this guy did is inexcusable.

Now, that said... :)

There are way too many people anchoring close to the channel, sometimes even in the channel, impeding traffic. it's like stopping in the emmergency lane along I95 for a picnic...

clearly, these transom poles are for calm waters, not in a spot where you can be waked. if you're going to anchor along the ICW exposed to wakes, you should use a regular anchor which will hold your boat securely and safely.

so "my plea is" ... why don't you go fishing where you will not be subject to wakes? there are many areas along the ICW, further away, behind some of the spoil islands. While i always slow down to minimum wake when passing near small fishing boat, courtesy goes both ways. don't block traffic.

that's south of St Augustine, right? plenty of back water and sheltered spots around there. No excuse to throw a dangerous wake, no excuse to be close to the channel
 
Was it a no wake zone? If not, I'm not sure he did anything wrong. Big boats just can't come off and get back on plane for every fishing boat out there. I boat in Lake Erie, and many Saturday morning there are hundreds of boats out fishing, they are spread may 5-7 miles deep and 3-4 miles wide it is impossible to get thru them without coming closer than you'd like throwing a wake. They are right between Port Clintons channel and Put-In-Bay, a very busy route. They're doing two things wrong, first their boats are too small for the lake, and second they are fishing in a marked ferry route. It's open lake and "no wake" is not required. Sure we all do what we can to help them out, but unless it's a 14 ft. row boat, I'm not comimg off plane. Last year was not a problem for me, I didn't want to spend the money to get on plane, unless the lake was rough or time required it, I stayed off plane.
 
You are responsible for your wake. Period. He did damage to your property, you have the right to sue him now.
 
you dont mention how far you were from the channel.
 
"I was fishing in the ICW near day beacon #102."

By "in the ICW" I assume you mean next to it not in it? And if true, how close were you to the edge of the channel?

The boat should have slowed down. And after you hailed him he should have responded.
But, contrary to popular belief, the "you are responsible for your wake" rule/law is not a blanket one. And depending on the circumstances there may not be much you can do or get out of it.

I think you bare some responsiblity here by using a Power Pole in an area with the strong possibility of wakes coming through. Also that could lead to you swamping I would think.

But you have just as much right to anchor and fish near the ICW as I, running a large vessel, have in transversing the ICW. We just both have to show each other respect and courtesy.
 
100yards/300' the wake would not have been that bad... frankly, i dont' think i would necessarily slow down for someone that far away.

i think this is taking the "you are responsible for your wake" a little too far. get a real anchor, and when you see a wake coming your way swing your boat into the wake. you won't get any damage to your boat.

something else you need to consider, is how deep is the water where you anchor. A boat wake will break when it hits shallow water... it's very obvious, and it's even one way you can see how close you are to the bank. a 2' wake over the deeper water will not be very steep and most little boats can handle it. now, when the wake reaches the shallows off the channel, it becomes steep and it breaks. big difference. If you were at that spot, even 100 yards away that woudl explain the violent motion.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Robyns Nest

You are responsible for your wake. Period. He did damage to your property, you have the right to sue him now.






Are you really responsible for your wake, period? I'm pretty sure that's one of the biggest misconceptions of boating. As a courtesty, yes, as a legal requirement, no. If you are not in a no wake zone, it is not neccesarily negligent to throw a wake. And unless there is negligence, you are not responsible for the result of the wake. Now of course you can sue anyone you want, but that doesn't mean you'll recover anything.

I'd love to see a Coast Guard regulation, or a state law, that says you are responsible for your wake under all circumstances.
 
Well around here, a pleasure boat operator is responsible for any damage their wake causes to shoreline, boats, and property, period. If it can be proven your wake caused injury or damage, you are liable by law, no wake zone or not. This moron shouldn't be boating, to ignore your calls and to not even be considerate enough to stop and see if you were ok.

On the waterway I boat on, we can catch guys like this like rats. Last year we had a guy from the "Quebec Navy", in a new 40 foot woody woodpecker boat, come through the system, not in a no wake zone, but mushing his way through a narrow channel at about 15 knots. A few home owners along the shore called the lock master at the next lock. This fellow mushed all the way into the lock stopping abruptly. Lock master closed the lock and kept him there at the bottom of the lock like a rat in a cage until the police came. He caused no damage except for minor shoreline erosion at the properties that called and complained. He was fined.

The waterways are for everyone to enjoy, not just the ones with big yachts that think they have somewhere they need to be in a hurry. If you can't afford coming on and off plane then stay off plane.

Shel
 
quote:

Originally posted by rnbenton

7. I will let you know how responsible for the wake this guy is since I have already reported to all law enforcement agencies concerned and have consulted a marine attorney.






If you are pursuing legal action, posting about the incident on a public forum is probably not the wisest decision.

Glad you are okay and hope everything works out for you in the end.
 
Robyn’sNest:
Your statement “You are responsible for your wake. Period.”
seems unsupported by law. Here are some applicable references though it is difficult to find any case law on the topic and federal rules don’t mention vessels under 1600 tons.

The USCG appears to have punted the issue to the states (see below) while Florida law and the opinion of the Head of the FL water cops seem in disagreement. It is worth noting that the USCG specifically say the issue is one for the states and courts.

Federal viewpoint
quote:

While vessels under 1600 GT are not specifically required to manage their speed in regards to wake, they are still required to operate in a prudent matter which does not endanger life, limb, or property (46 USC 2302). Nor do the Navigation Rules exonerate any vessel from the consequences of neglect (Rule 2), which, among other things, could be unsafe speeds (Rule 6), improper lookout (Rule 5), or completely ignoring your responsibilities as prescribed by the Navigation Rules.

As to whether or not a particular vessel is responsible for the damage it creates is a question of law and fact that is best left to the Courts. For more information, contact your local Marine Patrol or State Boating Law Administrator. http://www.navcen.uscg.gov/mwv/navrules/navrules_faq.htm#0.3_9





Florida viewpoints

quote:


(2) Any person operating a vessel upon the waters of this state shall operate the vessel in a reasonable and prudent manner, having regard for other waterborne traffic, posted speed and wake restrictions, and all other attendant circumstances so as not to endanger the life, limb, or property of any person. The failure to operate a vessel in a manner described in this subsection constitutes careless operation. However, vessel wake and shoreline wash resulting from the reasonable and prudent operation of a vessel shall, absent negligence, not constitute damage or endangerment to property. Any person who violates the provisions of this subsection commits a noncriminal violation as defined in s. 775.08.
http://law.onecle.com/florida/vessels/327.33.html

Each captain is responsible for the wake of his own vessel, whether he's in a regulated speed zone or not," said Capt. Paul Ouellette, boating safety coordinator for the Florida Fish and Wildlife Conservation Commission, the newly created state agency that now includes what used to be the Florida Marine Patrol. "They can also be held responsible for any property damage or environmental damage their wake causes."
Virtually all states have adopted laws similar to Florida's for careless and reckless operation. In addition, federal law requires all vessels to "reduce speed sufficiently to prevent damage when passing vessels or structures in or along all navigable waters of the U.S." from a BoatUS article. Please not well this quote is from a state administrator not just the opinion of Boat US




 
This is a debate that is getting old.
By us we can have guys fishing all over the channel.
I am not coming off plane for every single one of them.
In my view, channels are for boats to run fast, no wake zones are for boats not to run fast.
Yes, I agree I am responsible for my wake, but at the same time, I don't agree with every person fishing in the channel.
In my view if you fish in the channel you need to be prepared to get hit by wakes.
I didn't buy a power boat to cruise around at 5 mph in the entire bay!!!
 
i'm just trying to explain how you could minimize the impact of wakes on your boat:

1)- watch out if you're going to anchor right when the bottom comes up. Since you are an experienced licensed captain, i'm sure you have seen this many time before: when water gets shallow, right around the 2 to 3' depth you were in, the wave of a medium to large boat will break. this is the danger zone you want to avoid.

2)- use a real, proper anchor. It doens't take years of experience to realize that the power pole will not be able to absorb any wave action, it shouldn't be used along the ICW.

so, had you been closer to the channel, with a proper anchor, you woudl have experienced an unpleasant rolling motion, not violent waves that threw your boat 20' back.

and btw, if you're going to go "legal"... get your facts straight: you dont' have 100 yards, plus 50', from the edge of the channel (at R102) to the bank.

I know the area, on my last run north a month ago I was passed right aroudn there by 2 large Boston Harbor catamaran hulled whale watching boats. It's narrow, with little room to pass but we worked it out. No way you can be anchored 100yard off the channel and still 50' off shore. the banks and the small islands on the west side are about 50' from the channel markers.

my point is that we all need to be courteous and share the waters. Big boat, small boat, sailboat creeping in the ICW at 3 kts, and fishermen off the channel. Courtesy means different things, it means being safe but it also means minimizing your impact on others. again, it works both ways.
 
(it turned out to be a 72' Burger Yacht out of Sanibel, FL)

I don't know if this may be an issue, but don't you have to have a liscensed captain operate a boat that size?
 
Ok, did some more research. As I suspected, there is nothing I can find in FL, or Coast Guard, regulations that says 'you are legally/financially responsible for your wake, period.' People may believe it to be the law, but that don't make it so.

It's no wonder people are confused by this topic; the post above shows a state enforcement adminstrator repeating the 'you are resposible, period' even though his state law says no such thing.

Understand I'm not suggesting that you shouldn't be on the water, or that the 72 footer has the right to do whatever he pleases - but this idea that under all cases a person is repsonsible for their wake is simply not true. And it appears he did in fact leave the scene of an accident, as defined by FL law. Please do keep us posted, as I'm interested to see how this plays out.
 
"(2) Any person operating a vessel upon the waters of this state shall operate the vessel in a reasonable and prudent manner, having regard for other waterborne traffic, posted speed and wake restrictions, and all other attendant circumstances so as not to endanger the life, limb, or property of any person."

this is also means that anchoring using improper ground tackle in an area subject to traffic and wakes, could be considered not reasonable and not prudent.
 
If I could start my career over, I'd be an attorney specializing in admiralty law. This guy may pay up out of the goodness of his heart, but if he tries to file an insurance claim, there isn't a chance in hell they pay you without putting up a fight.
 
First I am sure it was a very scary experience and I'm glad you here to write about rather than reading about it in the paper. But as Pascal indicate you the experienced Captain need to take proprer precations also. You should have anticipated this possiiblity. If this wake would have been caused by law enforcement chasing a large cruiser you most likely would have been seriously hurt from 2 large wakes. Would you have expected them both to slow down as they passed you.
 
Back
Top