Police vessel searches

MIke F

Member
Member
Joined
Mar 2, 2000
RO Number
95
Messages
492
Locally on Lake Erie we have numerous law enforcement agencies which patrol the area water. They include the coast guard, Fish commission, Dept of natural resources, sherif, local police, and border patrol. On numerous occasions vessels are stopped for a "safety inspection" during which anything seen as illegal results in a citation. Recently vessels which were anchored near a concert pavilion, listening to a concert, were systematically boarded and "inspected".

Does anyone know the rules under which the above agencies may be denied access to your vessel? It appears that the above agencies conduct inspections just to show off their authority.
 
Not sure about the locals, but the CG can board vessels subject to jurisdiction of the US at any time for any reason.

Locally, once we are inspected, we get a sticker and usually when the agencies see that you have already been inspected they leave you alone.
 
I think they can board anytime. I was talking with someone from my marina last week. They were leaving Put-in-Bay last Saturday at 1 a.m. They were stopped by the coast guard and searched. The driver had not drank a thing and had to do a breathalyzer, everyone had to empty their pockets and were patted down, every compartment was searched and then they were allowed to go. It is almost becoming harassment. I figured after the breathalyzer of the driver that should have been enough.
 
In VA, the locals have to be w/i their jurisdiction unless there is reciprocity. Even then, there are distance limits. DNR can do the whole state. The locals are the biggest pain as their knowledge of rules of the road, no wake, minimum steerage speed, etc....is lacking.
 
I was under the assumption that all agencies except coast guard (under patriot act?) needed a warrant to board without permission. Locally, it is indeed becoming a harassment issue. Most boaters in our area are quickly becoming upset over the situation. My point was that I was informed that, if you granted permission to board, the agency was entitled to look anywhere for anything, while if permission was refused, boarding without probable cause could only be undertaken with a warrant. The warrant also had to show what the agency was looking for and items not in plain sight could not be cause for a citation and/or arrest.
 
I wonder, if you give permission to board (as most here would) but find the guy is Rambo and looking through your wife's underwear drawer, can you "un-give" permission?

I find it ironic, one of my appreciations of the water was the lack of how do you say "structure". No roads, no lines, go anywhere, any time, stop/swim/anchor just about anywhere, etc. Relatively speaking there are only a few rules and lots of freedom. There is alot of freedom and in some ways, the last "frontier".

Well, it seems like this is the case for law enforcement too. The CG doesn't need a warrant and perhaps local LEOs doen't as well. I'm personally not sure about that. Do they inherit the rights of the CG? Or are they "free" to detain and search without probable cause and without a warrant?
 
I can speak in regards to the Sheriff Department. We have the right to board your boat with or without permission. Asking first is a courtesy. ‘probable cause’ is defined as a reasonable suspicion that a marine law was violated. This is Statue Section 324.80166 of the NATURAL RESOURCES AND ENVIRONMENTAL PROTECTION ACT 451 of 1994 as it is stated for Michigan law:

“Except for inspection of a vessel to determine the number and adequacy of personal flotation devices on that vessel, a peace officer shall not stop and inspect a vessel bearing the decal described in section 80166a or an equivalent decal issued by or on behalf of another state during the period the decal remains in effect unless that peace officer has a reasonable suspicion that the vessel or the vessel's operator is in violation of a marine law.”

The short and long of this is if you have a decal that shows you were boarded and inspected and successfully passed that inspection, we cannot board you UNLESS there is “reasonable suspicion that the vessel or the vessel's operator is in violation of a marine law.”

quote:

“On numerous occasions vessels are stopped for a "safety inspection" during which anything seen as illegal results in a citation.”.




Speaking for us, this simply is not true. Our goal is to educate boaters which hopefully results in a safer boating environment for everyone. We do not write for most infractions (depending on the severity, of course. For example OUI). We issue at least 10-15 warnings for every 1 ticket that is issued. Our Sheriff feels very strongly that our job is not to harass boaters, but to educate them.

We do have reciprocity in multiple counties as do those counties. We do not have reciprocity in Canada. In fact, we cannot even cross into Canada with prior permission from Canada.
 
On Lake Travis here in Austin, any one of the law enforcement agencies (we don't have CG here) can board at any time to conduct a "safety inspection". They do not require probable cause.

Of course, there are many things that can provoke an inspection; and that usually has to do with LOTS of people on any particular boat and the concern that there aren't enough PFDs to go around. Acting like a general moron on the lake is another good way to get you pulled over. I'm always glad to see them get boarded!

I have never been pulled over, but I expect, and am ready for it, whenever/should it ever happen.

So much of this would not be necessary if there weren't so many accidents. It's the inexperienced, idiots, drunks, punks, rednecks, etc, etc, that are causing the law to crack down on boaters in general. At least, that's the case around here. Can't the exact same be said for people on the roadways?

Paul
 
If you feel you are being harassed, you should write down the authority's badge and/or name. You can then follow-up with a written complaint. Besides that, you should just comply and stay out of their way. I would assume that arguing with a cop will only encourage him to move as s-l-o-w-l-y as possible to piss you off. Wouldn't you?

Also, I see registration and/or sobriety check points on the road frequently. What is your opinion of those? They can also be run by local or state police. Do any of you consider those to be harassment?
 
Hi all,

Interesting topic.

RSGS, It is refreshing to hear your side of this debate. Speaking from my one and only experience with the Provincial Police here in Ontario, their goal is similar to yours - education not harassment. I could have been issued a ticket for not have all the appropriate safety equipment, instead I warned and told to obtain the equipment (which I did).

Two Canada Customs agents boarded our boat once when we returned from the US. We had stopped at a CANPASS site to call in and the two Custom's agents happened to be there. We had made the mistake of all getting off the boat; the rules state the boat operator is to get off the boat and call, while all other passengers stay on board. The agents told me that they were going to board the boat for an inspection. I was surprised to find myself, and my family standing on the dock listening to the sounds of each cupboard door opening and closing in the cabin. Then watching them lift the hatches to look in the engine compartment, check under the captain's seat etc. I was surprised because I was not allowed on the boat during their search (I say I wasn't allowed, but I can't remember if they actually told us to stay on the dock or just did not invite us aboard for their search). However, we had nothing to hide, so it was no big deal. Again, it was an education. Had I read the Custom's check in procedure closely, I would have known to have my family stay on board.

In my opinion, most law enforcement officers are good people trying to help out. I cooperate and try to make their difficult jobs a little easier.

Bcat
 
Stephen, although the courts have ruled it is not harassment, I personally feel that it is! However I hope it does reduce the number of drivers who are impaired on the road!

BTW, boarding a vessel w/o a warrant has nothing to do with the Patriot Act! That right is part of maritime law. Basically, you have more rights in your vehicle then in your vessel. They are not equal.
 
Paul, a minor point of contention;

Local law enforcement can certainly stop you on the lake and ask to see your PFD's, fire extinguisher, etc, but do they not have the authority to board without permission without probable cause.

OTOH, most of the locals we see operating on busy weekends (Lake Lewisville and Lake Texoma) usually have a Game Warden with them who does have to authority to board and search without a warrant.

In response to the USCG boarding, they of course have the authority to board and search, with probable cause, but IMHO do not have the authority to force you to take a breathalyzer test. They may give you a field sobriety test or haul you in, but refusing the breathalyzer is still your right. (My respsonse, "I don't trust the machine")

Fred
.
 
I can see it's probably a good reason to stay at the dock even if you've had only just one drink.

It seems to make sense if the bars close at 1:00AM on PIB, that the Coast Guard might be doing sobriety checks. I would agree that if the Captain passed the breathalyzer, that a search of the entire vessel would seem a little extreme.

We have to keep in mind, they are just doing their job to help protect us. If we cooperate and all is in order, it should not be a worry.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Freddy

Paul, a minor point of contention;

Local law enforcement can certainly stop you on the lake and ask to see your PFD's, fire extinguisher, etc, but do they not have the authority to board without permission without probable cause.

OTOH, most of the locals we see operating on busy weekends (Lake Lewisville and Lake Texoma) usually have a Game Warden with them who does have to authority to board and search without a warrant.

In response to the USCG boarding, they of course have the authority to board and search, with probable cause, but IMHO do not have the authority to force you to take a breathalyzer test. They may give you a field sobriety test or haul you in, but refusing the breathalyzer is still your right. (My respsonse, "I don't trust the machine")

Fred
.






Fred:

The USCG does not need probable cause - they can board you at any time for any reason.
 
ITK, I think he means local law enforcemen not including coast guard. On the lake we boated on before going coastal, the coasties never set hull on it. The only LEOs were DNR, county or city.
 
Charlie:

I might be confused, because I was basing my response on the last paragraph in his post.

At the tall ships this year, I saw a boat give the CG a hard time about being boarded, their mind quickly changed when the cover came off the bow mounted .50 Cal.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Freddy

Paul, a minor point of contention;

Local law enforcement can certainly stop you on the lake and ask to see your PFD's, fire extinguisher, etc, but do they not have the authority to board without permission without probable cause.

OTOH, most of the locals we see operating on busy weekends (Lake Lewisville and Lake Texoma) usually have a Game Warden with them who does have to authority to board and search without a warrant.

In response to the USCG boarding, they of course have the authority to board and search, with probable cause, but IMHO do not have the authority to force you to take a breathalyzer test. They may give you a field sobriety test or haul you in, but refusing the breathalyzer is still your right. (My respsonse, "I don't trust the machine")

Fred
.




Thanks Fred. I think there is some grey area between the jurisdictions here. I did a ride-along with an LCRA Sheriff, and he implied that he could and would board if he were conducting a safety check and (here's the part I left out) had reason to believe that the operator was impaired (or underage driniking, etc.).

Thanks,
Paul
 
I'm surprised to hear that they searched the people - I didn't think they could do that.
 
My 2 cent rant on the subject, I was a little surprised a half dozen years ago when the CG showed up and boarded me, at anchor, at 7:30 in the morning, wife was still in bed. Way too early for that kind of BS.
 
Back
Top