Polyform or Taylor Made

Starry Night

Active member
Member
Joined
Jun 27, 2005
RO Number
18025
Messages
1,344
Question:
I am looking at new fenders for our boat which is LOA of 49'. What are the diffences between the two. Pros and Cons. I am looking at Taylor Made Big B 10x26, and Polyform HTM-3 10x26. The one issue that concerns me is that on Polyforms website they state that the HTM-3 should be use up to 40ft boats, however they make sizes up to 12 x 34.

I want to use fenders with the hole in the middle and to add fender covers. Also who makes the best fender covers that are made out of the heaviest, softest polartec fleece.
 
I have the Taylor with center hole & were guaranteed for life. Did get a replacement once by just cutting out inflation valve & sending it in. New fender sent. May still have that warranty ??
 
quote:

Originally posted by Starry Night

I want to use fenders with the hole in the middle and to add fender covers. Also who makes the best fender covers that are made out of the heaviest, softest polartec fleece.






Make them yourself Bob, it's very easy. Sailright has instructions. I'd use the boat blanket fabric as it is MUCH more durable than fleece and Relentless allows it to touch his boat! (I can make you a copy of the instructions if you want)
 
I believe they both have a lifetime guarantee. I'd go one size larger on your fenders. Fenders are cheap compared to fiberglass repairs.

As to covers, I like the soft ones over the canvas ones. Take a look at Fender-Sox. But be aware that fender covers can hold dirt, so wash them off from time to time.
 
I use the Taylor not the Polyform. The 12 x 34 are better for your size boat if you can store the extra size?
 
Don't waste your money on the polarfleece. It does not hold up. I ended up switching to the polyform fender covers. They hold up well & are not abrasive.
Al
 
I prefer the polyform Fenders. I think there a better product. I also have the polyform fender covers and Maine coast fender covers ( fleece ) Just my 2 cents.

Rob
 
i'd go with whatever is sold locally so you can take easier advantage of the lifetime warranties if you ever need to...walk in, swap out
 
quote:

Originally posted by rommer

quote:

Originally posted by Starry Night

I want to use fenders with the hole in the middle and to add fender covers. Also who makes the best fender covers that are made out of the heaviest, softest polartec fleece.






Make them yourself Bob, it's very easy. Sailright has instructions. I'd use the boat blanket fabric as it is MUCH more durable than fleece and Relentless allows it to touch his boat! (I can make you a copy of the instructions if you want)








Rommer,

Please send a copy to me as well. I went to buy some fender socks and about shat when I saw the price.

TIA
 
onthecreek, almost positive; valves have to be sent to MFG.
 
I use HTM-4s (12x36) on a 40 foot boat. Our instructress for the USCGA Flotilla 10-13 said to buy the biggest fenders available.
 
Biggest available? You're kidding right? Those are over 8-ft long & 3-ft across
 
I bought a set of 6 Taylor Made 3 years agon from West Marine and they have replaced all 6 of them at different times with no questions asked. Always the valve has failed but West has been great about the replacements.
 
quote:

Originally posted by KiDa

quote:

Originally posted by rommer

quote:

Originally posted by Starry Night

I want to use fenders with the hole in the middle and to add fender covers. Also who makes the best fender covers that are made out of the heaviest, softest polartec fleece.






Make them yourself Bob, it's very easy. Sailright has instructions. I'd use the boat blanket fabric as it is MUCH more durable than fleece and Relentless allows it to touch his boat! (I can make you a copy of the instructions if you want)








Rommer,

Please send a copy to me as well. I went to buy some fender socks and about shat when I saw the price.

TIA










Can you sew?
 
quote:

Originally posted by Capt. Art

Biggest available? You're kidding right? Those are over 8-ft long & 3-ft across






Why did I just have a flashback from Blazing Saddles........

Excuse me while I whip this out!
 
quote:

Originally posted by rommer

quote:

Originally posted by KiDa

quote:

Originally posted by rommer

quote:

Originally posted by Starry Night

I want to use fenders with the hole in the middle and to add fender covers. Also who makes the best fender covers that are made out of the heaviest, softest polartec fleece.






Make them yourself Bob, it's very easy. Sailright has instructions. I'd use the boat blanket fabric as it is MUCH more durable than fleece and Relentless allows it to touch his boat! (I can make you a copy of the instructions if you want)








Rommer,

Please send a copy to me as well. I went to buy some fender socks and about shat when I saw the price.

TIA










Can you sew?












Me? Sloppily. My daughter OTOH has repaired tears in my carpet protectors and canvas and made them look like monograms.
 
I would absolutely go with the taylor just for the warranty. I have returned fenders that i am pretty sure I did not buy at WM and have never been questioned.

I purchesed Polertec covers from a company in RI and they were very nice and lasted very well. I think I paid abput $25.00/pc.

Dan
 
I use Taylor 10X26 on a loa of 48. My last pair were the Infusion style, and the ?pump on the fender is not very good. It takes forever to pump a very small amount.
 
Ok, so the consensus is the Taylor Made, however the valves tend to fail. I would like to go with the 12x34 however they may be to big. I can probably get 4 of the 10x26's in my forward bow storage locker and two down below or in the garage.

I did locate the company in Maine who makes the polartec fleece covers. They do look nice, however I may make them myself. John I may take you up on your offer.
 
Back
Top