portable genny poll

TIC

Member
Joined
Apr 13, 2008
RO Number
29813
Messages
295
Just to see the results and since it's always such a hot topic for debate, let's see the numbers.. Do you think using a portable generator on a boat is safe?
 
So far it appears the sky is falling crowd is pretty far behind!
 
I, on the other hand, do not feel that there is a "sky is falling crowd". Those who do not operate portable generators aboard also happen to feel that either there is no particular reason to do so, or that, for them, the risks are not worth the benefits.

The whole point of this forum is to encourage people to enjoy boating in a safe way. We all have a different comfort level.

Be safe, be happy.
 
I like my Air Conditioning and microwave oven.. Heat index was 94 today.. Who says it doesn't get hot up north?.We also boat well into fall and the reverse cycle heat is a blessing on a 30 degree morning..I also like being able to recharge my batts w/o running the big V8 after having the fridge on all night.. Oh, we always rent movies too.. Need some hot water?.. fire up the honda for 5 min.. The convenience of the portable genny far outweighs the risks for US..From the results of the poll so far? it appears most feel the same way.
 
Remember to vote early and vote often, the sky is falling crowd could always skew the results and then we would all have to throw our generators off the fantail.

Be safe, be happy, be comfortable, crank that genny.
 
Like the saying goes:

The beatings will continue until moral improves.
 
How about first we take a poll to see if we need another portable generator poll?
 
quote:

Originally posted by Gregory Saracco

How about first we take a poll to see if we need another portable generator poll?






That would be a waste of time and resources. This poll, as well as others in the past, indicate that portable generators can be used safely. I am of the opinion that there are some people who will never get over this fact. Several members have said their CO alarm went off while running the boat's engine but the CO alarm has never gone off while running the portable gas generator. I had this happen to me on several occassions as well. A portable generator can be as safe if not safer than other marine engines on a boat.
 
quote:



This poll, as well as others in the past, indicate that portable generators can be used safely. I am of the opinion that there are some people who will never get over this fact.






That would be the sky is falling crowd.
 
OK, several people run portable Gen.s but where. On the swim platform? In the bilge? If so is the hatch open? What are you doing? The survey doesn't give much detail to vote. On the swim platform wouldn't be any big deal, I seen this all over the place.
 
Swim platform.. it's part of the "common sense and safety precautions" reply option
 
quote:

Originally posted by TIC

Swim platform.. it's part of the "common sense and safety precautions" reply option





Not necessarily. I was actually torn between two answers: Yes, as long as occupants are awake and the "common sense and safety precautions" answer. For me being awake is part of the "safety precautions" for many it is not. I'm willing to admit though that if you have CO detectors you are PROBABLY fine to sleep.
 
And you don't think this poll is a waste of time and resources mandm 1200?
 
I'll stick to my solar "generators". Clean, quiet, safe. NOT cheap!
 
Option 1. Buy a real marine generator, put it in your boat and enjoy. If you can't fit one in, then see option 2.

Option 2. Buy a boat that has a generator already in it and enjoy.
 
Back
Top