Purchase Gone Bad

fizerocks

Member
exMember
Joined
Feb 16, 2005
RO Number
16319
Messages
162
Looking for opinions on whether we have done enough.

I will try and make this as short as possible, however for those of us in the frozen north does it really matter how long it takes to read since we are not boating for another 4 months?

Anyway, going back to last May we sold our Crownline cruiser to a couple in another state. Since they wanted to pay in cash and not mess around with a loan (not sure if they could get one) we at that time agreed to a $5,000 non-refundable deposit with the balance to be paid off within 90 days. We retained the boat along with the title until the entire purchase price was paid.

During the initial 90 day period the buyers did manage to make a few payments to bring their balance down but at the end of the 90 days they still owed us over $10K. In talking with the buyers they had experienced some medial issues along with a mother passing away. My wife and I agreed that we didn't want to see them lose their money and decided on an extension for another 30 days. Again this time came and went without additional money. Finally after reaching the buyers, (we were told the reason they could not call was due to being in the hospital) we told them although we would really like our money we could afford to allow them to make payments until the end of April 2009. We required a new signed contract with the stipulation that should any payment installment be missed they will immediately be in default and have 15 days to pay the entire balance due or forfeit all moneys paid up to that point.

Installments began in October with the first payment ($1500) coming in on time. The second installment due on 11/30 did not arrive until 12/3. We were told this was due to a payroll change and would not effect any future payments. When the third installment did not arrive as scheduled on 12/31 we assumed there would be some type of excuse for it being delayed but would still end up receiving the payment either on Monday (5th) or Tuesday (6th). We did call the buyers on the 5th and left them a message to call us regarding their missed payment but did not receive a call back. Once Wednesday came and went without a payment or call we decided enough was enough.

We sent the buyers a letter by overnight mail on Thursday stating they have defaulted on their agreement and as a result must pay the entire balance due ($7500) no later then Thursday the 15th or they will lose all interest and payments made towards the purchase (they have paid $12,260). The Post Office attempted to deliver the letter on Friday but no one was home so they left notice for them to pick the letter up. In checking the tracking number today they still have not picked the letter up.

Today I plan on sending another letter by normal Priority Mail with just the standard delivery confirmation making them aware of the first letter and of the 15th deadline. I have also already called them again and left a message.

So, assuming we will not receive the full payment by the 15th nor hear from the buyers, do you think we have done enough to say after the 15th this deal is dead? We feel our signed contract which was notarized is specific and protects us in the event the buyers try and make a claim for the boat or moneys paid. Since we are in another state I assume they would need to file any type of small claim court or civil case against us in our home state.

We in no way planned on it coming to this and just hate seeing the buyers walk away from over $12,000 but we have had enough excuses.
 
What a shame. If it were me I would do everything I could to help those people from losing their $12k. They obivously tried to buy your boat in good faith and I would not be comfortable keeping their $12k and the boat. I would sell the boat and refund the difference between the contract price and whatever I got for it. Even though the contract might allow me to keep their $12K, my conscience would not.
 
maybe i'm a dreamer, not a shark, but i'd have some moral issues with keeping the entire amount. I know you did your best to get the deal to work and gave them an extention but i'd probably keep the deposit from the initial contract and refund the rest of the money. The deposit being more than enough to cover the damages you suffered by them not fulfilling their obligations.

yes, they should not have signed and agreed to the purchase and people should stand up to their obligations, but loosing what seems to be 60 or 70% of the boat cost doesn't seem right either, even if it is "legal".
 
The problem now is how soft the boat market is and everyone looking for a great deal. I'm not sure how much we can get now and then if we do give them a partial refund does this open us up to legal issues.
 
I think if it were up to me, I'd still try to work with them but put the boat back on the market. If it sold to another party, keep their deposit, give them back the rest of their money and move on. I'd also want some sort of paperwork stating that this is agreed to by all parties.
 
Significant medical problems change alot of things for alot of people. I'd call the hospital and confirm their stay there, then again give them every possible chance to get you the balance in a reasonable time period. Assuming they get back in touch with you and are genuinely trying to pay you. Get them to sign a seperate contract (referencing the original) agreeing they will pay you interest (at some reasonable % above what you could make by investing it safely) on the money owed until it's paid in full.

JB
 
Resell the boat at today's market and retain money to satisfy the original sale price plus any costs like storage, intrest not earned and advertising you may have or will incur. Refund the balance which I suspect will not be a great amount by the time you are done.
 
You need to try and work with them. Pulling the plug with out trying to work something out is the wrong approach IMO. You were comfortable enough to carry the paper on this deal so they can't be all that bad. Maybe reduce the payment and extend the terms. Of course, it's your right to be a harda$$ if you choose to be.
 
A late fee or interest payment is in order.Pulling the plug on this transaction seems a bit over the top at this time. You are not losing anything if you still have the boat. I hope they get in touch with you soon to resolve any issues.
 
I know it is very fustrating, but right now, what are the chances that you will sell the boat otherwise. I would tell them, that you are going to keep what they have paid you for now, and relist the boat. If they pay you off before you can sell the boat, they get the boat. If you can sell the boat to someone else, they get back the difference between what they agreed to pay, and what you sell it for, plus any cost to you. Cost would be advertising sea trial etc.

Yes it sucks, but I think that is the best you can do. Selling a boat in these times is not easy, and niether is buying one.
 
I agree with newlyn. Most contracts have a liquidated damages clause to stipulate exactly how much money they would have to pay if they defaulted on the original agreement. I don't believe that you are morally or even legally entitled to keep all of the money. Courts don't look favorably on people trying to profit on the misfortunes of others. You still have to prove actual damages.

Forget about calling the hospital. HIPA prohibits them from giving you that type of infomration and it's irelevant anyway.

I'm surprised they haven't contacted you to work something out. They are in danger of losing a lot of money. I would suggest you do whatever you need to to complete the sale. I believe that is what's in your best interest.

In the mean time, I would put the boat back on the market so you don't miss out on any potential opportunities to sell it to someone else. I feel that you should try to sell it and if you do, refund the difference between the two selling prices or the amount they paid to you less the $5,000 deposit, whichever is the smaller amount. In other words, they should be out at least the $5,000 good faith deposit and more than that if you end up having to sell it for less than they agreed to pay.
 
My opinion is that the best thing is to find out if they really want to continue and if so how. If not then unwinding the deal needs to be fairly done. Most courts will only award you an amount of damages you can document such as costs incurred because you held the boat for them and some remarketing costs. Since your sales agreement doesn’t seem to include the buyer paying storage costs I doubt that you can collect that.
My position would be how would I want to be treated in their situation. Clearly circumstances overcame the buyers but none of us know the full situation. IMO you need to talk to them and find out what they want to do before you take the next step unless you want to put the boat back on the market now. In that case you need to get a written settlement with them. Either way you need to talk to them.
 
Tell them you will attempt to resell the boat and return the difference to them and if they do come up with the balance before you sell it the deal stands. Don't wait remarket the boat.
 
yup, the hospital is not allowed to give you any information. Can't even tell you if anyone is/was a patient there.
 
"I'd call the hospital and confirm their stay there,"

Can't do that. It is against the HIPA law.

You're going to have a tough time defending retaining all monies paid PLUS you still have title and possesion of the boat. What you essentially had was a "lay away purchase". You're entitled to some fee, but not 12K. Return their money less damages and costs.
 
Okay, this may be hard to believe but shortly after posting I was finally able to get ahold of the wife. I was told the husband once again went back into the hospital. She asked him about the boat and while he was drugged up and he said he thinks they still owed two payments. I told her they still owed five payments which she wasn't surprised about. Apprently he hasn't been doing too good of a job with the finances lately.

She has promised to send a payment this week and said she will now be taking over sending the payments and contacting me if there will be any future delays. I did tell her we really don't want to see them lose any money on the boat since I know it was exactly what they wanted when they looked at it in May.

We really are very nice boaters and couldn't see just having them walk away from the deal. Since we planned on using the money for debt paydown we were not strapped for the cash. It seems like anytime I end up talking with someone about the deal coming apart it quickly comes back together. Seems like it has done it again.

I'll post if we get a payment this week as promised.
 
good for you, nice to know there are still good people in the world
 
Hopefully everything goes as planned. I agree with others that keeping their money and the boat, should they not continue paying, would not hold up in court if they choose to go that route. For sake of arguement lest say someone was buying an item valued at $25,000. They miss the last payment of $1000. The seller is not going to be allowed to keep the item and $24,000.
In this case I would let the buyers know that they may incurr additional fees due to storage.
 
quote:

Originally posted by fizerocks






Looks like your situation may be resolved, but my view is to do what will allow you to sleep best at night. That is most often the correct decision.

If the payments arrived irratically, and they didn't contact you, something was wrong.

Sounds to me like maybe they shouldn't have bought the boat to begin with.

Also remember if you are in possession of the boat while they make payments you must keep up the boat,and it must be reasonably in the same shape as when they signed the agreement.
 
Back
Top