PWC Weenie

  • Thread starter Thread starter blouderback
  • Start date Start date
Boatbasin ... it is your inexperience and lack or understanding that is showing.
 
I'm trying to teach my daughter about boating rules, she is old enough to ride the SeaDoo with a boating certificate....I won't let her get one until I'm comfortable that she understands the rules and can handle herself ok. Try being the stand on vessel when YOU are on the SeaDoo. Unfortunately she is starting to realize most people, especially on a small lake, don't understand anything about "Rules of the Road". Our conversations start out "ok honey, see this boat coming up to port, he is the give way, so you maintian course and speed...." and end with "ok, he probably doesn't understand the rules, now see this boat coming up on our port side, he is the give way....nevermind, let's find an empty cove so we can ride around some". I'm starting to teach her that everthing to starboard definitly has the right of way, and everything everywhere else you probably will need to get out of the way of.
 
BillK .. It is important that your daughter understand the "rules of the road", but just as important that she learns to do whatever is necessary to avoid a collision. She also needs to understand that many, if not most, folks operating boats do not have a clue what they are doing!!
 
BillK
I agree with you. Put my wife and kids through the boater's safety course. I sat through it with them - it's been 40 years since I'd done it, PWCs did not exist then (special rules) and they got a kick out of the fact that I attended with them. They are much more "the wiser" on water etiquette + legal/illegal today (me too - on PWCs). And YES, the issues usually arise from "friends" who come to visit.

I have a "PWC weenie" story too.
My boys had a couple friends out. I explained the rules and threatened them with their lives if they did not follow them (exaggerating, but I always come across quite firm). Toward the late afternoon they come back to the dock complaining about "a guy" up near the inlet that was cussing them for no reason. There are always 2 sides to the story so I jumped on the PWC and headed over. I asked the gas dock attendant if she's witnessed anything involving 2 PWCs and I encounter this guy, now at the gas dock, who is upset. The story he tells me is different (surprise). 1 of the 2 PWC's was apparrently horsing around in the marina inlet and threw a wake, so this gentleman yells at them (deserved). He get's the Michigan salute in return. I saw the boys ride in to the dock so I asked which color jet ski saluted him - "I don't know" was the response. Hair color of the saluter - "I don't know". Single or double riders - "Definitely single". BINGO - the PWC weenie was identified. Upon returning to my dock I called all 3 out, openly chewed the weenie "a new one", and he was done for the day. News spreads fast amongst our kids friends. Whenever friends come over and I give "the rules" speech, his example comes up from them (not me) and we all have fun but not at the expense of others. I find a little fear seems to be a good deterrent, and they reinforce that I will follow through on my promises.
 
I am not sure if the boat safety course made me a better boater or not. Seems that since most other boaters ignore any rule or reason the only lesson to be learned is protect yourself and be aware. The rest of the rules course is irrelevant 80% of the time.

I thought it silly that we had to go to the course to get a CT boating license from the DEP when 14 miles across the same water there is no license required in NY. But after my short time here, I can see it would do a world of good.

Maybe 5 year refresher courses? Hell the course only cost $10/head.
 
Pete, your last remark was totally correct, I cant believe that boatbasin would not understand the most basic rule of navigation that exists. This just shows that when you get comfortable and you expect others to know the rules then you will be the one to get in trouble. When teaching someone to handle boats I always tell them to assume that the other guy does not understand the rules of the road, and to also throw the rules out when trying to avoid a collision. When approaching a red bow light you must yield to that vessel. I hope he doesnt boat at night. Where is he located I want to make sure I stay away from that area.

Van
 
I'm sure boatbasin just got mixed up with port and starboard while he was getting a picture in his mind's eye.
 
Geeze Bob, you don't have to defend him after he insulted you. You were the stand on vessel.
 
I came to the conclusion many years ago that graveyards are full of people that had the "right of way".
Bob, you did right.
 
I don't want to beat a dead horse but I just can't believe that Boat Basin didnt post a response.

And yes Bob he should apologize to you especially with all of the abuse you take on the forum.
 
Maybe Boat Basin is British? They drive backwards over there.
 
As much as I like to take shots, Bob...you did the right thing. And you were correct in your assessment and action.

It's not just the PWC's...I see this often with all kinds of "boaters". The R'sOR are lost on many and even more are not aware or don't care.

;)
 
quote:

Originally posted by WALSHIE

Maybe Boat Basin is British? They drive backwards over there.





That's not true, is it? I mean, I know they drive on the left side of the road, but their inland waterway rules are the same as the international ones, right?
 
quote:

Originally posted by C_Spray

quote:

Originally posted by boatbasin

He was approaching from your port side at a 90 degree angle? He was the stand on vessel, you were the give way vessel. Then you do not give way and you wonder why he gives the salute. You got lucky, the subsequent posts and your description of the offended party as a "weenie" speaks volumes to your(and their)experience on the water.(right?)





Are you kidding me?

This is the most incorrect post I've seen on this board in 10 years.

Besides Radioactive's reply, why else do you think the red light is on the port side of boats? Red = "No".








One way I've explained this rule to people is to think of it the same way as driving a car. "Right" of way means if 2 cars come to an intersection, the one on the right goes first. Same for a boat, two boats on a collision course, the one on the right is the stand-on vessel. This is not to say that people know how to drive either...
 
Thank you all for proving my point.

No Bob, I was not confused, I guess my sarcasm was not evident enough.

The point I was making is that when someone posts something that is blatantly and fundamentally wrong, there are 10 posters jumping up reminding everyone of the obvious. But when Bob posts something that is just as dangerous and fundamentally wrong the answer is "you did just great Bob", Run down the annoying PWC. Tongue in cheek or not, it makes me sick.

One of the primary rules of navigation is to take all prudent actions to avoid a collision. So many people think that because they are the privileged vessel they must hold course because it is their right, and the other vessel must yield because of that right. They create a crossing situation so that they can show their knowledge of the rules, and proceed regardless of the consequences. Bob, If you had altered course to port even a few degrees when the PWC's intentions became obvious you would not have encountered a situation that required you chop the throttles, or to be within a distance that allowed you to read the expression on his face and to receive the bird.

I assumed you would see the mockery in my post. Should I apologize for that, no. But seeing your civil response, perhaps I was a little harsh.

P.S. Brad, you know what I do for a living, I am surprised you took the bait. The only one I was trying to catch spit the hook.
 
quote:

Originally posted by boatbasin

One of the primary rules of navigation is to take all prudent actions to avoid a collision....

...If you had altered course to port even a few degrees when the PWC's intentions became obvious you would not have encountered a situation that required you chop the throttles, or to be within a distance that allowed you to read the expression on his face and to receive the bird.






We generally have most of Tampa Bay and the Manatee River completely to ourselves since we choose to do the bulk of our boating during the week. Surprisingly, we are often the biggest boat by far (at a whopping 40' LOA) on the river or bay.

When we run in to this exact situation, we alter course a bit as described above to show them a little less hull and more bow. This usually ends all of the right of way arguements long before any corrective action is needed and usually takes us right past their stern depending on our closing rate. That's not to say that some jackass hasn't forced me to chop the throttles and drop off plane more than once. One time it was about 15 miles off shore, with an entire ocean available to him!!! [:(!]
 
"At about 150 yards, I finally back down and he cuts across my bow with a scowl and a single finger salute."

Sorry Mr. Boatbasin, but Bob did exactly the right thing, he knew what HE should do, and he knew what THE OTHER GUY was supposed to do. When it became apparant that the other boat was not goind to yield, Bob did what he had to do to avoid a collision.
 
Bob deserves an anchor for his seamanship! Although we won't see him again if we gave him one.

Right wrong, or whatever the case, the bottom line is to be safe. No one lying in a hospital room (after an avoidable boat collision) can claim to have done the right thing if it ended in an accident. You need to stick your pride elsewhere and do the smart thing to protect you and your passengers.

Oh yeah... and then throw your anchor at him.

MJK

BTW - Bob, what are you getting for a mooring in that new mooring field you bought?
 
"I assumed you would see the mockery in my post. Should I apologize for that, no."

Written speech lacks the tone of voice and body language that conveys sarcasm. Had you thought about what you wished to convey ahead of time, a clash of responses would have been avoided.

Those who are familiar with the "Rules of the Road" are also familiar with what I call "Rule zero": It is stated in several places that no action prescribed by these rules shall justify an accident, and that action to avoid an imminent accident are always considered proper.

You are correct that often, an encounter may be avoided entirely by early action. But such early action is not always possible ( nor is it covered in the rules ), thus the actions described in the original post seem to me to adequately adhere to the RoR. IMO.
 
Back
Top