radar microwaves

Charlie: I doubt that a film badge would show anything. X rays and radar are both described as radiation however I think their effects are very different. Been too long to remember anything more but we should have a physicist here.
 
Google "proper use of radar" and you will find a reference on the first screen that says the USCG interprets proper use as, "if you have it, you should (not must) use it". This explains why we see coasties on our lake run without their scanners spinning, and why they do not stop boats who have it, but are not running it.
 
So proper usage would not include a well thought through plan on when to use the "standby" button?
 
Would appear so. As to the film badge, those measure ionizing radiation generated by tubes or isotopes from machines used for medical purposes. That's different form radar which I believe are mirowave bursts. Not sure about the radar.
 
If some of you know how to use your Radar, GOOD.

NOW, Those who know how to use it, Are you saying it's unnecessary to learn or that there's no need to learn. Do you think anyone can learn the first time they find themselves in the dark or fog? Do you buy a gun and expect it to save your life in an emergency?

If you don't want to learn, Fine! BUT Don't tell others it's not necessary.
 
sorry guys so far i've not seen an applicable statute. section 33 referenced specifically applies ships over 1600 tons. since this is a recreational boaters website does anyone have knowledge of a statute that applies specifically to recreational boats? or vessels operated by those without capatins licenses?
 
< hit reverse, screeching tires... >>

Back to the Op for a moment:

"Does anyone know of a device that will read the amount of microwaves that you may be exposed to on the bridge from your radar?" -- Maycpa

I do not know of a specific device for doing this, but I have no doubt that it can be measured. I would expect that is is expensive, too. Detecting the signal is fairly straightforward, viewing signal quality could be analyzed via a scope and/or spectrum analyzer, but an actual calibrated, quantitative measurement could be fairly involved.

There are alternative methods that might answer your question less expensively, if you stated why such a measurement was needed, and your purpose for the data...
 
Arnold- That's a very good question . I don't know of one & am doubtful there is on of "consumer" afforability & availability.

I have a an express style fishing boat with a "marlin tower" where I spend most of the cruising time at that upper helm. The radome for the 4kw radar is mounted on the same hardtop my feet stand on and about 3 ' forward of my legs, as is very common for this type of tower setup & boat size (27'). The only radar display is at the lower station. For health-safety sake, I always keep the radar tansmitter off when I or anyone else is in the tower.

I'd guess at least 6 times I have been runnng the boat from the upper and have experienced a decidedly uncomfortable feeling in my shins and have jumped down to the lower station to find that a crew member has activated Transmit. I've never felt that feeling when it was not transmitting. No way in "heck" would I ever purposely transmit while anyone is on that tower and I have no desire whatsoever to electronically block out the otherwise normally usable aft "view " of the radar I feel is valuable to have in actual poor vis conditions . However, in the case of all those single station flybridge boats with brow-mounted radars (that really makes me cringe) , in my very inexpert opinion it would be hugely important that a large aft-facing sector of the transmit beam circumference be electronically turned off to avoid potential serious health issues to flybridge occupants. It would make so much more sense to get the radome off the brow and get it up higher ( say, on a hinged mast as on friends' FB boats) to get body parts out of the beam and maintain full radar view. In lowered vis, I run from the lower station with radar on , safe and fully usable.

I respectfully disagree being close to, and in the beam plane, of conventional marine radar comparable to using a microwattage cell phone or standing near a carefully shielded microwave oven, though it might be somewhat similar to standing right in front of a microwave oven rigged to run with the door open, IMO. (Microwave: ~1.8 kw continuous transmit likely for 20? minutes vs. marine radar at rapid ~4kw bursts for hours ?) I'm not going to intentionally do either.

There are some reasonable & rational exceptions to most every "hard & fast" rule. I believe that a rule saying that the radar on my vessel must be transmitting even in good vis weather when someone is on the tower (in the beam) or that it must transmit so no one can ever use the tower while underway is patently unenforcable , and no reasonable person would attempt to enforce that, any more than saying it had to be left on even if the radar was on fire but still displaying targets. In some circumstances there are simply over-riding health issues, whether they are easily quantifiable or not. .

The very-low-continuous-radiation-level Navico broadband radars seem to me to have tremendous potential, but time will tell .
 
Title 33 does indeed, in whole, deal with vessles over 1600 gross tons. HOWEVER, if you will go read it, part 164.35 rule 7 specifically says that while a radar is not REQUIRED for vessles under 1600 tons, if one is installed and operational it must be used. (I am paraphrasing but if anyone wants it I have an entire CFR manuel and would be glad to email the total chapter if needed) :)

quote:

Originally posted by vic33004

sorry guys so far i've not seen an applicable statute. section 33 referenced specifically applies ships over 1600 tons. since this is a recreational boaters website does anyone have knowledge of a statute that applies specifically to recreational boats? or vessels operated by those without capatins licenses?




 
if you can post the section you are reffering to it would be helpfull as it is not available thru the government website. unless i misunderstood the section number you are reffering to.
 
OK, rather than reading the entire manuel you can go to the end of the thread. Look at the Navigation Rules and Regulations, Part B Steering and Sailing Rules, rule 7 (b) Risk of Collision.

It states (quote): Proper use shall be made of radar equipment if fitted and operational, including long-range scanning to obtain early warning of risk of collision and radar plotting or equivilant systematic observation of detected objects.

Yes, the word used in the text is "shall". Not may, might, maybe or could be.

quote:

Originally posted by vic33004

if you can post the section you are reffering to it would be helpfull as it is not available thru the government website. unless i misunderstood the section number you are reffering to.




 
sorry there does not appear to such a section in title 33 section 164. if you can post the specific statute # you are qouting it would be very helpfull.
 
You do have a copy of the Navigation Rules on board, don't you? The Rule 7 being referred to is in there. If you ever get boarded for an inspection, the Coasties will ask to see your copy.

That being said, I do not use my nice radar system all the time. The majority of the time, yes. I have passed lots of USCG boats when my array wasn't spinning, no hassles. It is as others have stated very important to use the radar frequently. The times we have operated in virtually zero visibility situations, the "clear day" practice has been invaluable.

George
Hatteras 56MY
 
yes i agree the following excerpt does specifically address US flagged vessels operating in US waters;

"RULE 7
RISK OF COLISION

(a) Every vessel shall use all available means appropriate to the prevailing circumstances and conditions to determine if risk of collision exists. If there is any doubt such risk shall be deemed to exist.

(b) Proper use shall be made of radar equipment if fitted and operational, including long-range scanning to obtain early warning of risk of collision and radar plotting or equivalent systematic observation of detected objects.

(c) Assumptions shall not be made on the basis of scanty information, especially scanty radar information.

(d) In determining if risk of collision exists the following considerations shall be among those taken into account:

Such risk shall be deemed to exist if the compass bearing of an approaching vessel does not appreciably change;
Such risk may sometimes exist even when an appreciable bearing change is evident, particularly when approaching a very large vessel or a tow or when approaching a vessel at close range."

"proper use" is most certainly an indication to me that under the right conditions you are expected to use if you have it. But it is clearly not a law indicating it must be on at all times, if it were that is what the rule would state.
 
Title 33 CFR, Part 164 is NOT for RECREATIONAL boats. If your boat is for RECREATION, you don't need to have your radar on all the time because you have one.
 
If anyone on this board has experience in court, you will immediately recognize that there are two parts to any law: what the law says and how judges interpret it. Yes, the rule about radar comes both from rule 7 and, to a lesser extent, rule 5. But it is open to interpretation as to whether or not you can put the radar in standby if you judge it not to be needed. Now for court interpretation: it must be on at all times while underway or it will be cited as a contributing factor should a collision occur. All Coasties, Naval Officers, and Merchant Marine Academy grads cover a great deal of case law in order to learn how the rules of the road are actually applied. Careers are broken if a government vessel is at fault in a collision, so the training is very thorough and there is no ambiguity on the use of radar. There is no single source for the conclusion that the radar must be on if fitted and underway (and I've long ago lost the case study texts), but the answer of the courts is unambiguous: radar must be on at all times if fitted, regardless of vessel size. As righteous as you think an argument may be for turning off your radar while underway, courts say otherwise.

However, I've never heard of anyone getting cited for not running radar. The risk you bear only manifests itself in the event of a collision when blame is apportioned. Or I suppose if you really tick off a Coastie and he's looking for something to cite you on.

Brett
 
Back
Top