Yes, they are great cooks and good people. Casey is the bartender, she is daughter of fellow CYC member. She makes a mean Sangria.
You can tell them Chris Walsh said hi but I'm not sure they know me by name, by face and belly, definitely, lol.
First time, I tried steak and it was great. Last time I went I had grilled shrimp and it was amazing. Guy next to me had Chilean Sea Bass and I can still remember it, I regret not ordering that.
If you follow them on facebook, you'll know when they get fresh fish deliveries and what's hot.
I've been there several times already and will go back as much as I can when on boat. They are both Croton guys and started at The Tavern which is also a great destination but more of a beer/burger pub place. Dock your small boat at CYC guest docks (north of building) and walk over bridge, down ramp and 50 yards on the right is the "Tavern at Croton Landing" and "The Ocean House". Please tell them you came by boat and are at CYC, we need community points.