Replace trim tab in water ??

folieadeux

Member
exMember
Joined
Jul 9, 2007
RO Number
27326
Messages
760
Found out last week when my diver cleaned the boat that I lost a trim tab in my recent grounding. I contacted Bennett and they made my a new trim tab since the tabs are custom for my boat. My diver thinks he can replace the trim tab in the water without hauling the boat, but I am not sure.

This is a 28" wide trim tab secured by 10 2" screws into the transom. Diver said he would remove one screw at a time and immediately fill the screw hole with 5200 in a caulking gun. Once all the screws are out, more 5200 in the holes and install the mounting bracket, then the new trim tab.

It will cost me about $400 for a haul out and only $50 to pay the diver to replace the tab. My concern is water intrusion during the time the screws are out until the 5200 goes in.

Any input would be appreciated. Would love to hear from any RO that has actually replaced a tab in the water.
 
Ive never heard of pulling screws out under water and water not getting in.. I dont care how fast the diver is, I dont think its the right thing to do. You have a 2006 model, you paid a pretty penny, I wouldnt cheap out on a 400 haul..

my .02 cents
 
i think you're diver is correct, technically. 5200 needs moisture to cure and he should be able to perform this function in the water.

the downside is that you will not be able to determine if there is any water already in the core if the fasteners breached the outer layer of glass mat where they are mounted. and if they do breach the outer layer you would likely be introducing water to that core.

if its an emergency fix i would proceed with the diver, but if the only difference is $350.00 i would not screw around with it as the downside of a wet transom core is way more than $350.00.
 
the screw holes will fill with water and IMO possible start blisters as water in introduce under the gel coat. Most yards will do it in the slings and probably not a whole lot more than the diver.
 
Yes, to cure fully and faster. In fact misting it with water from a spray bottle will help it cure.
 
Do you need the tab?
If you didn't know until diver went down, I quesiton whether you need it.
If that is the case, then wait for next haul out.
Either way, I woul not let diver do it.
Has the boat been hauled since the grounding? I would haul to check everything out.
A diver under water can't see everything like out of the water.
Maybe a screen for the A/C got rubbed off, maybe there is other issues.
Haul it!
 
quote:

Originally posted by CurrentSea

Do you need the tab?
If you didn't know until diver went down, I quesiton whether you need it.
If that is the case, then wait for next haul out.
Either way, I woul not let diver do it.
Has the boat been hauled since the grounding? I would haul to check everything out.
A diver under water can't see everything like out of the water.
Maybe a screen for the A/C got rubbed off, maybe there is other issues.
Haul it!






Dave-the boat likes a lot of trim at higher speeds on long trips. We have not been able to use the boat much since the long trip when the grounding occurred only short day trips without much speed.

I have decided to haul her to install the trim tab and check the entire bottom.
 
If you haul or intend to haul in the fall/winter, have it done in the water and access the situation on the hard in a few months.
 
I dont understand why anyone would pull screws out from below the waterline, while the boat is in the water..

Good choice Captain to haul the boat
 
Back
Top