Resealing rubrail

cgpuddles

Member
Joined
Jan 5, 2010
RO Number
31926
Messages
82
Last season I noticed that there was some evidence of a past leak from where the deck was joined behind the rubrail. It didn't look fresh so it wasn't high on my to do list. This spring as I am getting the cabin ready it looks like it is getting worse (or more likely just running down in a new spot due to how it is positioned on the trailer) Either way, I noticed it is an active problem. Before I saw it dripping in a new spot I was just going to run a new bead of silicon or similar around the rail in that area and tackle removing the old stuff and redoing the seal all around next fall. My question is how big of a project is this? Time, tools and supplies needed? Price and am I ok to just use some sealant for the year and wait to the fall or should I adress this before the season gets busy?
 
I'm assuming you have the typical installation, a stainless rail screwed over the hull to deck joint, with some type of insert covering the screws?

It's not the rub rail that needs to be sealed, it's the hull to deck joint. If you are lucky, water is simply getting in because the screws came loose. In that case, you need to remove the rub rail insert, remove the screws, and then reinsert them with sealant. Or even better, replace with sealed 'through bolts'. Once everything is all sealed up, replace the rub rail insert, without any sealant.

If the actual leak is not due to the fasteners, and the hull and deck have separated, and can still be fixed, but I've heard and read it's a major PITA.
 
Alk,that is correct. There is a stainless rail over the deckjoint with a rubber rubrail inserted. The stainless rail is then sealed with a white caulk to the hull above and below the rail. Do you think I could just seal this joint a little better for now and remove the rail this fall? Or does this instance warrent a more immediate investigation?
 
I think it all depends on how serious the leak is now and whether it may cause damage to cabinetry, etc.
 
Takes tons of water running across it to even get the carpet on the walls wet to the touch. Right now my concern is I can see it because the hull is coated in dust and road grime and so when it does leak, I get a brown/black little trail on my white wall covering. I guess the other solution is wash the boat (and the evidence) away;-)
 
I had the same problem on my Regal 2465. I took the entire rubrail off. I marked each piece of stainless so it went back on in the correct place and orientation. I got a hawkbill knife and dug out all the old caulk. I was amazed at how poor the fit was between the hull and deck. I filled the entire joint with 5200. At the port and starboard rear corners the fit was so poor, I filled the gap with Great Stuff and let it cure. I carved out a place to apply 5200 over the Great Stuff.

I can't say if using the 5200 was the best choice or not. It was the first time I has ever taken on a project that large and was unaware there were other products that may have been better. I also sealed all the old screw holes with 5200 as well. I reinstalled the rub rail and coated the threads of all screws with 5200 as well. Fortunately, it worked. I did have one small leak a year later. I failed to run a bead of caulk over the top of the rub rail after reseating it. The bead of caulk solved that leak.

I'll see if I can find the pix and load them up on photobucket.

HTH
 
If I were you, I wouldn't mess with it this year. As noted, the leak might be gaps in the hull to deck joint, or it might be due to the stainless rail not sealed to the hull. I would guess it's the former, in which case you've got a pretty big job on your hands. Mine was just loose screws, I never even had to remove the stainless, and it still was a real time killer replacing the insert after rebedding all of the screws.
 
As the leak appears to be "minor" I think for now I'd remove the rubber insert in the vicinity of where the leak appears to be, back the screws out and rebed them with 5200 or maybe 4200. Then replace the insert and pray.
 
My rub rail screws leak on the inside too - only at the stern though. Need to pull off and re-seal. Probably use 5200. Herd heating up the rubber insert helps when removing it.
 
My guess is the leak can be repaired with 5200 after removing the rub rail and cleaning the joint. It is also a guess that water damage from a continuing leak may be nearly impossible to fix. Doing it right the first time is probably the answer.
 
Smooging sealant on the rub rail as a fix for a hull/deck joint problem is just going to make an ugly mess and won't fix your problem.
 
The fall is no time to be replacing a rub rail - too cool. You want the absolute hottest day of the year to complete this project, and even then you will be wishing it was hotter.
 
Black streaks are not good sounds like you could have a wet core or encapluslated wood. I would investigate immediatly. Try tapping around the area to check for rot. Bill
 
I had a similar problem on a 36' Carver and also on a ski boat. On the Carver, my first attempt at a solution was to apply seal to the joint between the rub rail and the deck. That was a major failure.

There are two likely sources of the leak. One possibility is that the top deck is not well fitted to the hull and there is a gap. This fit may have been better when the boat was newer but over the years a few screws have come loose and the gap has increased. The overlap of the top deck would prevent water from the top side from entering the gap but a spray of water off the hull while underway can force water into the gap. If the gap is small you might be able to simply caulk it. If the gap is large then it probably flexes while underway and the caulking is unlikely to maintain a seal. What you need to do is remove the rub rail and refasten the deck, drawing the hull and deck together. Add some caulking as you do this to ensure a water tight seal.

The other possibility is that water is leaking into the boat through the screw holes that hold the rub rail on. Indeed, my rub rail was fastened in many spots with pop rivets, many of which left a 1/8 inch hole in the center after the rivet "popped". Water would make its way behind the rubber strip of the rub rail and then leak into the boat through loose or missing screws and the open center pop rivets. If this is your only problem then you can remove the screws one at a time, apply sealant and reinstall.

Rod
 
I like the way Fountain glasses the hull and deck making it a single unit.
 
Back
Top