I may be taking the path less traveled, but I have many concerns about reusing shrink wrap. First and foremost the investment in shrink-wrapping a vessel is minor in light of the vessel's value and considering the enhanced potential for off-season damage (due to the reused material having compromised ability to protect a vessel), I fail to see the logic in such reuse. Secondly, in the event of off-season damage, an insurance company could consider inappropriate protection of the vessel as an impediment to a claim. I have personally viewed the higher potential damage to reused shrink-wrapped vessels. Third, the increased worry of damage occurring during a storm is not worth the saving of using new material. Forth, the shrink-wrap is recycled by manufacturer (or should be), so the environmental cost of using new shrink-wrap is minor, and indeed actually helps the economy.
For my vessel the increased cost of using new shrink wrap is about $150 (I shrink wrap my own vessel)-- a trivial cost compared to the vessel's value.