Secondary nav system(s)

Radioactive

Well-known member
Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
RO Number
3238
Messages
4,831
Since this likely will veer from the thread that spawned this topic, I've begun a new thread.

--

In the US, at least, we are shutting down LORAN-C. This was an approved secondary navigation system. The question here is:

Now that it is gone, what is your secondary navigation system/method?

Note that the loss of LORAN-C mainly affects those who are coastal or offshore.

There are several methods to gather what I call "single vector" data. Those would include depth data, Radio direction finding, compass and to a degree sextant ( full data is often spread over a full day ).

So what to use? What is "approved". What will you do when the GPS system is "unavailable"for some reason?4
 
The odds of the gps system coming down are very low, so my back up is a laptop with independent receiver and charts. Plan C is indeed DR
 
Along with a few of the items you mention , I'd certainly include CHARTS, radar, visual & sometimes audible "land"marks, sun, moon & star positions, wind & wave & swell & current directions, cloud formations and even sea temp.
 
fwiw, DR is also my "backup", but is seems to be such a reduction in accuracy... ( from primary GPS to secondary DR )

Are there any "approved" systems other than DR and GPS? ( Note that cruise ships have been required to keep LORAN-C as a backup, iirc )

And, yes, the GPS system is robust, but I can think of three methods right off the top of my head that would rapidly remove the GPS system. They are not "likely" but in the long run ( two of them, at least ) are probable: NEA and satellite collision .
 
Loss of a single or even multiple satellites will not significantly degrade GPS operation. Each of the satellites are fully independant (at least for the short term), so even loss of the master ground stations will not cause immediate loss of GPS operations.

A back-up GPS receiver would be a good idea, but total failure of the overall GPS system is so unlikely as to be almost insignificant. The only method I can conceive of that would cause total and immediate shut-down of GPS would be if it was turned off by the Department of Defense. But vast number of dependant worldwide users this is not going to ever happen.

My back-up is a handheld GPS, then DR.

Mike
 
Loss of an odd GPS satellite under some of the scenario's is a long way off track. GPS is also not going to be turned off and IF it ever was then you will have more to worry about than worrying about boating/fishing.

Actually is amazing that some are worrying about how to navigate without GPS and/or Loran? These navigation systems have only been in existence for a wee total fraction of the time man has been navigating on this earth.

Shutting down Loran will probably be the best kick along system manufacturers have had in a long time. All this wait and see Loran stuff for the past 15 years has really stagnated further developments. This might give manufacturers a clearer direction and reason to concentrate on other developments.

Most of the system failure scenario's are centred on GPS alone but there is also Glonass and other emerging systems which are interopable in the one receiver. Manufacturers just need to start seeing a reason or demand for such implementations in base model receivers. At least manufacturers won't have to worry about Loran.

Even China's Compass is on the way up with G-1 being launched in the past few days.
 
DR. It's the rare day I actually use GPS most of the time anyway. Not a problem. It's an inconvenience. GPS is great, but come on, none of us should be trusting ANY electronic 100% and using another electronic for backup.
 
The old methods worked for a long time and are easy to resurect.
 
quote:

Originally posted by pdecat

The old methods worked for a long time and are easy to resurect.






You sure? I can't get across town anymore without the car's nav system.

However my ultimate backup system in the anchor.
 
For equivalent accuracy I would go with an Inertial Reference System like a Sub or Missile (ballistic) uses. Although for a fraction of the cost one can buy charts, compass dividers and learn how to use good old fashioned DR. And for the Down East crowd I hear a Sack of Potatoes end Echo works.
 
Interesting.

So, for all involved the answer is a) GPS won't fail me. and b) I can get equal service out of charts, visual marks etc. ( btw: sub inertial guidance systems are nothing more than dead reckoning except that it is "a bit" more accurate and costs "a bit" more ).

I've had my share of "unassisted DR" while deep sea fishing in the GoMex in the late 60's, before there were so many rigs you could walk to Cancun. And DR was certainly "good enough" to get home. But unless you have references, in particular visual references, DR can stink for accuracy. ( Off shore ). Away from land, ATON and other references, with "random" currents going unknown directions at unknown strength, any DR attempt would ( and remains ) an educated guess at best.

Which is another ( long ) way to say that, for recreational boaters, there is no good, accurate secondary system.

Closer to civilization, in the presence of ATON, landmarks and bottoms with unique features, DR can be quite accurate ( in many circumstances ).

---

By the way, for all of the "charts are king" boaters, I have a response: IF you have reference marks ( regardless of type ) charts are a wonderful thing. With no frame of reference, charts are only good as a coaster for your coffee mugs. You can draw your "rabbit droppings" all over the chart, all day long, but in the presence of currents of unknown strength and direction, your circle of error can rapidly exceed your maximum possible distance from land. ie: use the chart for a coaster.

---

I think that there is room for a secondary system, unrelated to GPS ( and the clones ). GPS can fail catastrophically ( though, as we have all noted, it would be an unusual event ), and there is a need for a secondary system of related accuracy. ( which DR is not )
 
"So, for all involved the answer is a) GPS won't fail me. and b) I can get equal service out of charts, visual marks etc. "

i dont' think this is an accurate summary of what most posters said. first, individual GPS receivers can and do fail, but not the system. maybe that's what you meant...

there is no way that you can get the same accuracy with dead reckoning and charts, but in most cases it will be close enough, at least to a point where radar can be used, especially in low vis. conditions.

i've been using GPS for close to 20 years now, i think i got my first one in 1990 or 1991, a sony pyxis. over these 20 years i don't remember a single GPS failure while underway except the sony which failed after being rained on 6 or 7 years later. Only other failures were temporary resets on Furunos resulting in no nav data for a couple of minutes.

that's a pretty good track record which is why GPS failure isn't exactly something i worry about.
 
So what would this "secondary system" be then?

Keeping in mind that as a backup IF GPS fails (being totally hypothetical) then it MUST provide similar functionality.

MUST be Global
MUST have similar accuracy
MUST be free to air
MUST be cheap to purchase

Suggestions? or does it simply come down to this
quote:

there is no good, accurate secondary system





Mind you right now (today) one can purchase a multi constellation receiver that is not absolutely reliant on NAVStar GPS. All depends on how important these things are to you and how much you are prepared to pay?
 
Pascal, failure of the system is exactly what I mean. I an not discussing "single point receiver failure".

That the system has not failed indicates that the system, as it exists, is robust. But it IS subject to catastrophic failure. ( Which would be a rare event )

For many ( ?most? ) boaters on this board, this is a total non-issue. Most do not even have a need for GPS. This is due to most of us boating within 30 nm of shore. And while LORAN-C was used in this region, it's main use was "on the high seas". Offshore. 30nm+ And out of sight ( vis or radar ) of any mark, of any type.

Kerry simply restates my question. It is poor design to rely on one system only. Just because your primary system is robust, does not mean that you should not have a secondary system that, while perhaps not as convenient, or accurate, it should be more accurate than DR without landmarks. LORAN-c fit the bill. In comparison to GPS, it is a bit more clumsy, not quite as reliable, not as accurate ( though it's repeatability is excellent ). It was also based on a totally different principle from GPS, making it unlikely that whatever caused a failure in one of the systems, would be unlikely to cause a simultaneous failure in the other.

I do not think we have a replacement system. ( which is why I stated the thread ). I think there -should- be a separate, secondary system. And, as far as I know, there not only is none, I know of no plans for one.
 
This is where the age old arguement about Loran (any form of Loran) fails as Loran is/was not a backup for GPS in the context of what GPS does. Loran (as such) had a very restrictive coverage foot print as did Omega when considered against Satellite systems.

I also think many are not giving enough consideration to the separate (secondary in a sort of way) satellite systems that can stand alone as well as be interoperable. There is simply no ground based system period that can/will/would even come close to satellite systems.

As for catastrophic failure of NAVStar then I would be interested in what scenario's are being considered. Catastrophic failure is making a big call and regardless of the rarity what might cause this?
 
"As for catastrophic failure of NAVStar then I would be interested in what scenario's are being considered. Catastrophic failure is making a big call and regardless of the rarity what might cause this?"

As I posted above: "They are not "likely" but in the long run ( two of them, at least ) are probable: NEA and satellite collision ." To which you might add solar CME.

What is the risk of total ( or nearly so ) system failure? Not very high ( as I have repeated over and over ). But the risk does exist.
 
I've navigated 2800nm from the West Coast to HNL dead reckoning, at the end of the excercise only 3 miles off course, then you can do pilotage upon land sighting. If you do dead reckoning correctly, keep a good log it is the most precise of the inprecise navigation excrcises you can do. Any time you are navigating where loss of electronic means would leave you lost on pilotage, you should have a DR Log ready to take over. That is, course, heading, distance and times to the waypoints. Calculate them youself, write them down from your GPS etc whatever. At no time for any reason should you not be prepared to dead reckon. Your most likely failure scenario is loss of ship's electrical in which case, Loran C would be pretty much Tango Uniform as well. So quit worrying about what electronic means you have and do it right if you are going to navigate beyond pilotage means.

I cross the Atlantic once a week. Despite 3 intertials, two GPS units, I have a log of headings, times, speed, distance to DR if it all goes Tango Uniform.

What is a navigator's most important tool? Not GPS, not a sextant, not a plotter, not even a clock. It is a good heading. When it all goes bad and you have your heading, stick to it like glue no matter what. It will get you there, not as fast as you think it should because time stands still in such situations, but it will get you there.
 
I dont understand the concern.

Charts to plan the route, depth sounder to warn of approaching hazards, DR plot to guess location. There would probably be fewer collisions and allisions with nav aids if folks did their own course plotting instead of following the exact line from point to point.

Without a GPS Bob would, of course, have to find the mall the way the rest of us do… buy listening to the admiral.
 
I don't believe there is any concern either, not from the system anyway and not total. The biggest issue will be with the user equipment. The other thing that keeps creaping into this type of discussion is Loran, at last lets forget about Loran, the quicker it goes the better for all.
 
Back
Top