Separating water and E10 gas

pdecat

Well-known member
Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
RO Number
842
Messages
11,588
Since my earliest days whenever I got some water and junk in a small amount of gas I would filter it through a screen or fabric. The gas went through but not the water and stuff. What happens with the new Egas? I figure the ethanol which is hydroscopic would also go though the filter but does the water absorbed by the ethanol get through as well??
 
Bruce- You must have really thick water down there! Whenever I filter the contents of the old gas filters before filling the new I pour it through a few layers of clean cloth to remove the gompgh but it never seems to remove the water, if any, just the particulate gomph.( True a little of both water & gas was absorbed.) I just let it sit in a clear container for potential layer separation. With ethanol, gas & water still goes through but now unless there is enough water for phase separation making both layers undesireable, small amounts of water are there but combined with the ethanol and likely undetectible by eye.( & I wouldn't recommend by taste!LOL) I'm not sure whether the usual kolor-kut or other H20 detection pastes would give any indication for amounts less than needed for phase separation either . FWIIW, Racor ... says... their filter media treatment will let E-10 pass OK while still maintaining a barrier to (most?)water molecules previously attached to the ethanol, so water separation supposedly still takes place even below phase separation levels. I guess that wouldn't be too tough to prove but I just take it on faith. You could open up a Racor filter separator and keep the pleated barrier media on hand for the use you describe , and I might just do that for draining old filters and refilling the new. .
To be way too picky since we all know well what you meant , I think a more accurate adjective for ethanol would be hydrophillic or hygroscopic. Hydroscopic is a different animal and I confuse those terms all the time. :D
 
Supposedly, alcohol will absorb water to a certain percentage until it can't hold any more and it will separate out again.

The thing is, alcohol that has absorbed water will burn fine in the engine...as long as the alcohol content was small. (Sure don't know about when it gets to E85) The thing I haven't heard is after water exceeds the ability of the alcohol to hold the water and separates out, does the alcohol still hold a percentage of water? What separates out with the water? What condition does it leave the gas in?

Oops! Sandy beat me to it.
 
We used Heet in AK. It supposedly drew the water in with its Alcahol and burned the water out of the tank.
 
Oh that was good , Charlie! :D

It's my understanding that when phase-separation level of water saturation is reached all of the alcohol has "attached" to the water so there would be the top layer of just much lower octane-rated gas and the layer of alcohol(all of it) & water combined plus any water beyond what could be snuggled up to the alcohol. Our engines would not like either layer.

Thud , I wouldn't use HEET with gasohol. It was handy enough with the old stuff to absorb a limited amount of water in the tank with the risk of deterioration of old non- alcohol resistent fuel system components. However, as you say, it's essentially a can of alcohol and most marine gas engine mfgrs of non-"Flex" engines recommend preference for no alcohol but no higher % than E10, I believe.
 
Ok, enough being Mr. Nice guy. Charlie is known to have hydrophilic tendencies.
 
Heet was good for the tank in the truck, but Scotch was better for the driver!
 
Just don't mix it with too much water or you may experience the dreaded face separation.
 
Charlie, are they calling you an alcoholic? I'm not sure what they are calling you........
 
Liz it gets worse; Charlie has been a hydrophilic for some time. Now that you have jumped in I suspect you are as well.
 
Back
Top