Slow Pirates?

quote:

Originally posted by Greg Schoenberg

quote:

Originally posted by saltysam

Now that the Arab World--whatever that really is--is involved on both the pirates'end and the ship owner's end, I believe it is best for we poor Anglos to stand back and watch the show develop. The answer IMO lies ashore, within the failed governments of that part of the world. I believe that Piracy is a nasty byproduct of the p-poor living condiditions and lawless activities of all levels of government, from the tribe up to the peusdo-nation. Let them all fight/work/bribe their ways out of this themselves.

For those who want aircraft carriers---wake up to the ecconomic realities of life.






Here's some economic realities.

1. We have aircraft carriers and we pay for them, regardless of where they are deployed.

2. The last attack was against a US cruise liner.

3. If tankers must divert around the horn, then oil prices could rise, reflecting increased shipping costs and limiting their ability to supply demand, thus raising oil prices again.

Given this, are you sure it's strictly an Arab/Africa problem?

-Greg








Greg,

It's a little more complicated than that. A carrier always is deployed with a battle group...inclusive of at least one submarine. How many capital assets, very expensive ones at that) should be deployed for beating the crap out of pirates?
 
Right now, shipping costs of going around the Horn are nil. It costs about 3700 USd per day for a Capesize carrier, down from 238,000 USD per day last June. A Panamax has gone from about 190,000 to 1900 per day. It costs 200,000K to the Egyptians to go through the Suez canal. So right now it is not just safer, but cheaper to go around the Horn.

http://www.ft.com/cms/s/0/b173f21a-b5d9-11dd-ab71-0000779fd18c.html
 
Greg now you see why ships are being "captured", they are insured for far more money than they are worth on the open market.
 
I would think the cruise ship would offer a special price on shooting skeet and pirates to the passengers.
 
PULL!

L. Keith. Yep, the thought has crossed my mind that some of this piracy might be "pay jobs".
 
[/quote]
Greg,

It's a little more complicated than that. A carrier always is deployed with a battle group...inclusive of at least one submarine. How many capital assets, very expensive ones at that) should be deployed for beating the crap out of pirates?

[/quote]
There are a number of carrier groups on patrol at any given moment. Why not send one of them there? It is a hot spot getting hotter. We did this during the Iran/Iraq war when their patrol boats disrupted shipping.

-Greg
 
quote:

Originally posted by Greg Schoenberg
There are a number of carrier groups on patrol at any given moment. Why not send one of them there? It is a hot spot getting hotter. We did this during the Iran/Iraq war when their patrol boats disrupted shipping.

-Greg






Iraq/Iran patrol boats are flagged vessels of hostile nations.

Pirates are unflagged, rogue vessels.

There's a certain mentality involved with dispatching battle groups. The British empire dispatched third and fourth rate ships of the line to deal with the Barbary pirates in the 19th century on the western coast of Africa...no first rate ships of the line were relegated to this task.

The US also dispatched lesser ships in this time period as well to attempt dealing with piracy.

The point being, in todays Navy, a carrier group is a "first rate ship of the line" and as such, it's unique abilities and assets are not going to be wasted on pirates on the eastern coasts of Africa when you have perfectly good hostile nations to beat the crap out of or unnerve by having our presence in their waters.

Again, it's different thinking.

I'll guarantee though, if a rogue state starts waving a potential nuclear or bio bomb threat around, we'll be there with the swatter.

At this point, it's a commercial shipping nuisance and it's up to the companies fielding the ships to figure out how best to deal with it.
 
Actually, I would think a Marine helicopter carrier would be a better use of assets.
 
None of these ships are really "armored"--even an AK 47 burst will do substantial damage to the bridge area, when sprayed there from a "bouncing skiff". Some pirates have far fancier boats than the wooden skiffs you see photos of-(may well be file photos).
RPG are common, heavier machine guns have been used as well as rocket launchers by the pirates. The skipper's responsibility is to avoid loss of life. I have seen a steel vessel raked with a .30 cal and it made some impressive holes--and killed several crew members. Also crew members maning the "sonic" cannons have been shot at with both small arms and RPG.

A cousin took a cruise in this area--and they had the fire hoses laid out to use to repell boarders--as well as night watchmen on the stern with night vision glasses. Not all cruise liners can go 30 knots. If the small boats get in the wake of the ship, the seas are much more managable, and they can get up close.
 
quote:

Originally posted by GeeBee

Actually, I would think a Marine helicopter carrier would be a better use of assets.






You're on the right track. Realistically, a handful of the new generation of Mk V patrol boats would be more than enough.
 
Mike has my vote

"At this point, it's a commercial shipping nuisance and it's up to the companies fielding the ships to figure out how best to deal with it."
 
I've said before that this is not soley something that should be handled from the sea. Here's a worthwhile opinion from a political leader on the ground:

"Somalia has not had a functioning government since 1991, and pirates have taken advantage of the country's lawlessness to la unch attacks on foreign shipping from the Somali coast. Around 100 ships have been attacked so far this year.

Somali prime minister Nur Hassan Hussein said Tuesday that his country has been torn apart by 18 years of civil war and cannot stop piracy alone.

"This needs a tremendous effort," Hussein told The Associated Press. He has appealed for international troops, as his government's Ethiopian allies have said they would pull out their forces by the end of the year.

Ethiopia, the region's military powerhouse, has been integral in boosting the government. But Islamic insurgents have now seized control of all of southern Somalia except for the capital and the parliamentary seat of Baidoa.
 
Aren't the pirates "terrorists"? If so, shouldn't the USA being chasing them down, wherever they are???

Also, why the heck is any cruise ship going into a known dangerous area? And why are folks buying trips which include going through that area? What are they thinking?!!!
 
Mike gves a very good review of the situation. "Once Upon a Time" warship captains had immense and sole authority over their actions. They had a job to accomplish and their leaders gave them authority and the promise to stand behind their actions when faraway and out of comms. It was common, for instance, for Royal Navy Captains departing England enroute a 3 year cruise to the Orient to get very simple and direct ordes. "Protect the Queen's Interests" was a popular phrase in Admirlty Orders of the late 19th Century.

Not so today. UN oversight, changing National politics and instant communications make for a very nasty kettle of fish.

The Indian Navy last month came upon the simple and most effective solution. Kill or drown everyone of the pirates and sink all ships, floatsom and jetsom. Leave no trace. Just do it.
Report upon return to home base. Simple.
 
"Also, why the heck is any cruise ship going into a known dangerous area? And why are folks buying trips which include going through that area? What are they thinking?!!!"

Flutterby look at the map. The Gulf of Aden is the entrance and exit to the Suez canal. These pirates are simply fishing below the hatchery if you know what I mean. The only way for ships in and out of the Med going East is through these waters or around the Horn.

Bill, I wrote something along the same lines a while back. It was not only allowed but the duty of every law abiding Captain on the sea to if able to kill and/or capture pirates, give them a fair Captain's mast then hang them. So called "international law" has defeated that principle. The same people who yell about Gitmo, are the same people behind the neutering of our sea Captain's.
 
So take a cruse ship which cruises the Mediterranean. don't go near Africa by ship. I can understand commercial ships and tankers needing to take the short cut, but no way should any cruise ship be doing that! If ridership goes down, which it probably will after this incident, the cruise ships will change the itineraries.

Also, the US State Dept should put out warnings to US citizens to avoid the Gulf Aden/Suez Canal. It is too dangerous.

In today's world, I find I'm not lured to go outside the North American continent. But I'm getting old and grumpy anyway.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Flutterby

Also, the US State Dept should put out warnings to US citizens to avoid the Gulf Aden/Suez Canal. It is too dangerous.






Paragraph 6 covering travel to Somalia: U.S. citizens also are urged to use extreme caution when sailing near the coast of Somalia. Merchant vessels, fishing boats, and recreational craft all risk seizure by pirates and having their crews held for ransom in the waters off the Horn of Africa, most especially in the international waters near Somalia. There have been numerous such incidents, highlighting the continuing danger of maritime travel near the Horn of Africa. If transit around the Horn of Africa is necessary, it is strongly recommended that vessels travel in convoys, and maintain good communications contact at all times.

http://travel.state.gov/travel/cis_pa_tw/tw/tw_933.html
 
Back
Top