smartrim tabs

Some people swear by them, some say they are a waste of money. I am also considering these for my 21 foot bowrider, mainly because of the cost difference between them and "real" trim tabs that are adjustable. Smart Tabs auto-adjust, that is, they retracton their own when the boat gets up to a certain speed. "Real" tabs can be adjusted by a switch at the helm, and can also be used to adjust list due to uneven load. I just can't see spending so much for "real" tabs on such a small boat as mine.

If you try them, let me know how they worked!
 
I wouldn't put them on a boat I owned if they were free.
 
Actualy Les I have been considering these for my boat....Why would you not put them on..
 
Wayne, I can't begin to tell you the number of times I've used Bennett trim tabs to adjust bow entry into choppy water, adjust a list caused by wind, maximize efficiency, increase speed or for some other reason. But the main reason is in rough water. You've probably never entered an inlet with an outgoing current but an onshore wind. Seas can build high and steep. The very last thing I want is some so-called "smarttab" trying to push my bow down or in any way affecting my steering. I want that bow just as high as I can get it. My life and the lives of my passengers depend on it.
 
I was under the standing that these smart tabs were mauualy set and when you have them set the way you want the boat levelled, you then turned them on to auto which would keep the boat level if someone changed there position in the boat. My wife has a habit of running around the boat and changing her position about every 3 minuits.I thought that smart tabs would help that.At least to the point where I would not have to manualy adjust all the time. Can smart tabs be used manualy in the situation you were talking about?
As far as entering an inlet with an outgoing current but an onshore wind. no I have never done this.
The majority of my boating is done in fairly calm water.
 
I have them on my tender and will be replacing them with Lenco units. The smart things are not "smart" at all and very flimcy, a wast of money, now i am paying twice.

Cor
 
quote:

Originally posted by carver 2557

I was under the standing that these smart tabs were mauualy set and when you have them set the way you want the boat levelled, you then turned them on to auto which would keep the boat level if someone changed there position in the boat. My wife has a habit of running around the boat and changing her position about every 3 minuits.I thought that smart tabs would help that.At least to the point where I would not have to manualy adjust all the time. Can smart tabs be used manualy in the situation you were talking about?
As far as entering an inlet with an outgoing current but an onshore wind. no I have never done this.
The majority of my boating is done in fairly calm water.






That's a different product...Bennett Auto Tab Controller.

http://www.boatfix.com/catalog/322.pdf
 
If you want to do it right, use bennett tabs with the auto tab controller. The smart tabs are set once and that is it. The gas actuators adjust to pressure on the tabs. The slower you go, the further down they are. They are probably fine for use on Lake Whomagooma but that's about it. A touch on a bennett switch will disconnect the auto control and immediately put you in manual mode. The major advantage of the auto controller is that it controls based on vessel attitude and not just stern pressure.
 
From what I'm told, the Smart Tabs WILL help with leveling SOMEWHAT. Like Les says, they are on a gas filled shock that can "sense" the pressure of the water on the tab and will allow it to move up and down appropriately. If the boat is listing because of poor weight distribution, there should be less pressure on one side and the tab *should* automatically compensate. Frankly, I can't see how that would actually work that well.

They can't be as bad as everyone here says. I have heard MANY good things about them.
 
That's one of the things that is great about this country of ours. Folks can accept the recommendations of a guy who doesn't know how what the numbers on a chart mean or from someone with many years of professional experience and a 100 ton masters. With boating, as with most things, there's the easy way and there's the right way. Sometime they are the same, but not in this case in my opinion. To me, this is a safety issue.
 
Going by Walters posting, I knew what I wanted, but was just calling them the wrong thing.
I thoiught they were called smart tabs.....My mistake...It might be cheaper to take the Red Green aproach and just Duct Tape my wife to her seat...
 
I believe 'Smart tabs' are essentially a set of gas "springs", like on a lot of car rear windows,that create tension between the hinged tab plates and the transom. They are "set" to a maximum tab extension and when engine power is supplied,& the bow tends to rise and the stern digs in, the tab plates will have some appreciable effect over not having any tabs but those springs will be compressing most when they are most needed to be extending.

The boat operator has no control over their operation except for presetting at installation. They do not increase tab deployment in response to increased pressure on the tab as Bob/Marcus seems to indicate he believes. The springs merely compress or expand like a spring.

As the hull reaches planing attitude the Smart Tabs will presumably be medium extended & tending to keep the bow lower which can be good in some conditions,but will tend to react to an out of balance to the side condition by allowing the downside tab to retract(raise) somewhat farther, and the higher side tab to lower to maximimum extension. This is essentially opposite of what would be desired for trim control & could make trim worse, unlike the normal operation of what most consider real (operator- or automatic trim controlled , active) trim tabs that are designed to help beneficially correct vessel attitude in any plane.

As Les points out, another potentially more serious danger with the preset Smart Tabs is their tendency to push the bow farther down which increases the possiblility of the bow tripping heading downsea. One should be able to raise the tabs downsea for safety as noted above.

Carver- Just make sure it is in a seat the helps level the trim.
 
I don't think the danger is as much as Les and Sandy make it out to be. With the drive of an I/O or an Outboard trimmed all the way out (up), that bow will rise up pretty good whether you have Smart Tabs, Bennetts, or whatever. So, with Smart Tabs, you can still control the attitude of the bow, even though you can't control the tabs themselves.
 
Les, I guess those 100 ton boats don't have I/O's that can be trimmed, so maybe you weren't aware of that.
 
Bob

Have you ever run in the conditions they outlined?

Ever have to give full throttle just to keep from being pushed backwards when running an inlet? Not so sure I'd want to trim up an IO and lose my ability to make way.
 
BOB;
You are a TROLL...aTROll is someone who will post a thread just to stir crap..BE is an excellent forum for those that want to learn and have questions or concerns and are looking for guidence..You seem to be able to advise fellow boaters with all sorts of technical information, but dont even know how to read a chart..or even know if you need a sticker on a plate for a trailer..When you are questioned, you say stuff like..gee guys I am just looking for some help..BOB you need help...why dont you just leave and let those that really have the want to learn gain from this site.?????Stop trolling.........if you have a legit question post it....if not go away...
ATC is for information.not debate.thats what NBR is for
 
Back
Top