smartrim tabs

quote:

Originally posted by Dome3d

........I operate in the Long Island Sound and rarely encounter rough seas.




Doesn't sound Like the Long Island Sound I run on...[:-bigeyes]
 
John (owner of Nauticus/Smart Tabs) has never acted in any way other than professional, he and Tabman (Bennetts) have posted on the same threads and have both treated each other with the utmost respect, they have never resorted to the tactics I have seen here today with all but name calling by the owner/moderator of this board.
Smart Tabs is a good product, I have a set, I like them, they do what they are advertised to do in all respects. I will not debate the big water, I do not have a clue there, but in the sound, rivers and lakes where I boat they are great. If I were to buy adjustable tabs it would be Bennetts due the the quality of support I have read about on this and other boards. I my personal opinion Tabman and John are a lot alike, they both support their product well and are available on the phone when you need them, they are also both professional people and I don't think either of them would approve of the way this thread has gone.
This is my personal opinion, not trying to start anything or offend anyone, I have always had the greatest respect for this board and the way it has been run, I have recommended it to others as a place for valuable information which it is, I just feel that the attitude is going downhill.
 
Midway

You are certainly entitled to your opinion. Why do you seem to imply that others are not? This is an older thread which has recently been added to with some additional information. Les has a very tough job here and he does it well overall with no compensation. He didn't start this place to make friends. He & Geroge started it to help with boater education.

With any virtual gathering place there are ebbs and flows as the MANY personalities change day to day. This is one of the best run boating sites on the net. But if you think for one minute that any of the people here, admins, moderators, RO's, members or even guests want to see bogus information spread around then you are sorely mistaken. Smarttabs may have their place but in some cases can be dangerous. For a little more money and some extra installation effort you have a much more flexible and safer alternative.

The point of my last post was that even people that originally liked the product, ie Ship Shape, they found over time the limitations outweighed the benefits in their case opting to replace them with the more versatile product.

BTW - I for one do find your comment about "attitude is going downhill" to be very offensive since you are now commenting on something that happened 3 months ago.
 
Wow, that was fun. I re-read this whole thread. You guys really used to despise me. I'm glad we're all friends now!
 
I really dont see how non-adjustable tabs could be anything more than worthless. Just my $.02
Hope I didn't offend anybody [:-spin]
 
Bob, the one thing I have learned in life is to NEVER believe anything you read in full. It is almost always one sided, as in the case of a manufacturer touting it's product. Of course they will tell you what you need to hear, but is not always the case in the product. To me, NOTHING, and I mean NOTHING, beats years of experience, especially when dealing with the oceans. We are always at it's mercy, and usualyy, only the experience of ourselves and from people, like those on this board, save us from it. Cheaper is not always the way to go. I for one, would never put my life or the lives of others on my boat, in danger, because product A was cheaper then product B. In this case, there is no comparison between the two. Like stated, Smart Tabs may have their place in boating, but NOT in any saltwater envirnment. I would love to see you post your experience if you were to install them, and then make your trip to Block Island and back. I believe you will have a new respect for the knowledge and wisdom from all of the OLD SALTS on this board. In the case of these tabs, given the choice of having them or not in a saltwater ocean environment, I would rather have nothing on my boat. I believe I would have better control without them. As a last statement, I have been watching your posts as of late, and I dobelieve you have been quite helpful and insiteful on other topics to our RO's. And for this I applaud you......RANT OVER.
 
Midway says, "they have never resorted to the tactics I have seen here today with all but name calling by the owner/moderator of this board."

I'll take exception to that statement. I have stated my opinion based on many years of both professional and recreational boating. I have been in too many situations where wind, chop and other factors have required major tab position changes to recommend a product that does not offer that capability. This site will always advocate the safest choice, not the easiest one.
 
Les, have you ever operated a boat with SmartTabs(tm)? I don't doubt that you have many years of experience with adjustable tabs, but I was just wondering if you were speaking from experiece with SmartTabs(tm).
 
One doesn't need to test ride a bicycle without a seat to know the pole is going to be very uncomfortable!
 
You know, that argument never worked for me when my mom tried to make me try new vegetables. I just find it interesting that many of you have passed judgment on SmartTabs(tm) without having ever tried them. I'm not defending them in any way, or reccommending them, I am just doing some research and am keeping an open mind.
 
My experience with Smart Tabs is from a friends boat. We boat strictly on 1 or 2 inland (Kansas) lakes and he installed them strictly to help with bow rise while pulling boarders ,skis and tubes.In that regard,they work flawlessly,allowing him to run at less speed with the bow down than he was previously able to before,which is important to boarders as that requires a slower speed than ,say,skiing.They in no way help him with listing(unless he were to set them up for a particular list,but I don't know how that would help overall).And I could see no benefit to using them as Les and the others stated in open,tidal waters,for that I would think you would need fully adjustable tabs(Bennett,Lenco,etc.)depending on the conditions.But my friend is happy with the Smart Tabs for how he uses his boat and his boats size(20')Ours is a fresh water non tidal midsize lake with only occassional wind and light chop to deal with,and in that regard, I believe that Smart tabs COULD be useful on boats that operate in similar conditions or use their boat in a similar way .Just my $0.02 worth.
 
Thanks for relaying your experience with SmartTabs(tm). That's what I'm looking for, real world experience.
 
Back
Top