So what did we learn?

KnottyBuoyz

Active member
Member
Joined
Mar 3, 2006
RO Number
20406
Messages
1,584
I've been following the “Boating Accident" thread quite closely. Not that I'm an expert on Maritime Law and accidents but I have an interest in learning as much as I can about venturing outside of our home waters. The US is a much different place than Canada when it comes to boating and the complexity of the laws and statutes that govern how we conduct ourselves in another country's waters is/can be somewhat daunting.

So I've been asking myself, what did we learn from this “Boating Accident" thread?

1. If you want to be a responsible boater you absolutely have to have a good understanding of the laws, statutes, guidelines governing the areas in which you care to conduct your recreational boating activities,

2. You have to read and understand all the conditions of your insurance policy (if you have insurance) that may inadvertently put you at personal financial risk if you don't,

3. When an accident occurs on the water the determination of who's right and who's wrong is not always clear cut like it is on the roadways,

4. Those who investigate the accident may not be experts in those areas of law that apply to accidents on the water. Would it be reasonable to ask that an officer with proper knowledge be brought in to investigate?

5. Get your story straight right from the start. Waffling around the details is one sure way of discrediting the facts as you know them and this could probably come back to bite you in the butt later on,

6. You might want to disassociate yourself from the event if you want to discuss it in an open forum probably as a hypothetical situation,

What else did you guys/gals take away from that discussion? We're all hear to learn.

Rick
 
What did we learn?.... One troll can ruin an online forum so that no one trusts newbies anymore.
 
Those are good points, Rick. In my opinion, everyone should have, before they ever turn a key on a boat; a basic knowledge of the laws that affect them, a basic understanding of coastal navigation including an understanding of aids to navigation, the knowledge to read charts and take compass bearings, a knowledge of VHF protocol and distress calls, and, as you say, an understanding of insurance limits. There are probably more.
 
The big lesson here, I think is, don't air your dirty laundry on a public forum.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Hyperfishing

What did we learn?.... One troll can ruin an online forum so that no one trusts newbies anymore.





I have to agree with this comment, but a troll can only be a successful troll if they get attention from there posting. It’s obvious that someone will post a question to get different opinions on a concern or question they have. When suggestions are given to the poster and the poster starts arguing with comments that are intended to answer there concerns you have to peg them a troll.
Once pegged a troll they should be banned or ignored.If ignored they will go away.
 
Is a troll someone who tries to hijack a thread? Knotty asked a valid question - let's answer it.
 
I think Knotty summed it up pretty well. I can't think of anything off hand to add to his list.
 
The part that stuck out in my mind was that the owner of the Jet ski's defense was the kids parents said it was ok..... That part made my head explode....

As a teenager with a jetski I never allowed even my friends who did not have experience to ride it ... So as an adult ... WTF was the thought process........

I grew up on boat... Have zero tolerence for people that ignore the rules... in boating u make a mistake PEOPLE GET HURT/ DIE.... not something to be taken lightly... IMHO

Rob
 
Knotty asked "What else did you guys/gals take away from that discussion? We're all hear to learn."
I answered what I learned.....
No intent to hijack...
 
- Any vessel (powerboat, sailboat, jetski, canoe… ) is not a ‘toy’.

- You, as owner and operator of your vessel bear the prime responsibility for it, and those who operate or ride it.

- Think very carefully anytime you consider letting someone operate your vessel (especially if that person is a minor).

- Always consider the worst-case scenario

- If any type of mishap occurs on the water that might be ripe for litigation, get your advice from a legal professional, not a bunch of anonymous posters on a public forum.
 
I hope what was learned is that if involved in a serious accident ( and this turned out to be a serious accident once the details came foward) is to immediately notify your insurance company, and follow their instructions to the letter. Make sure the information given to the investigating authority is accurate (child operating listed as age 11 .. parent says age 12 HUGE difference) and corrected if inaccurate. If you find your insurance is not going to cover you for whatever reason, obtain legal counsel and refrain from public comment.
 
Read and understand your insurance policy and know your rights and responsibilities as an owner.
 
1. Make sure to posts all the facts up front or some people will think you are not being sincere.
2. Don't lend your stuff out to eleven year olds.
3. Take responsibility for things that you do wrong.
 
Hopefully we have also learned to be considerate, courteous and exercise kindness and toleration in our responses.
Hopefully we have learned not to ridicule, critize or demean each other.
Hopefully we have learned to give the benefit of the doubt.
 
1) Even what seems like the best intentions at the time and what appears to be harmless can go horribly wrong in an instant

2) Know your insurance policy (I admit that thread made me re-read mine)

3) If involved in an accident that serios, attach bottom lip to top lip and do not seperate them.
 
Knotty raises a good question. I agree that many of his points are relevant and important. But I suspect most of us were probably aware of points one through four, but may not have paid as much attention to them as we should. Rethinking the responsibility that comes with boating was one very good lesson for me.

I was reminded that (1.) all the rules and laws don't prevent accidents, and (2.) the general rule of responsibility doesn't exonerate you from taking action to necessary to avoid collision. Laws and rules don't keep people from getting hurt. The actions of people determine if folks get hurt or not.

The other thing that got my attention was how different state laws governing boating can be. I don't think about other state's laws very much.

In Texas, if you are under 18 you MUST complete a boating safety certification course approved by Texas Parks & Wildlife before you may operate any vessel powered by a motor 10 hp or more or a sailboat over 14 feet in length. The minimum age if you have completed the required training and testing is 13.

In AZ, from what I have been able to read, the laws are much different - the minimum age is 12 and I haven't seen any reference to any kind of required training or certification. The operator situation we have been reading about would have been quite illegal in TX, but not in AZ.

Overall, I think it was a good reminder and a bit of a wake up call.
 
Unfortunatly I was a bit taken back by the neg responce from anchors here. As a newbeee.

I was also a bit surprised that I could be the only guy here that remembers running high powered boats when under the age of 12. Like this kinda accident never happens with experienced boaters driving! I sent my poor old man over the back of the runnabout when I was like 8. Thats OK cause he got even !!! PFD.

Things happen thats part of life. What would have changed this situation? Sure an 11 year old not driving is an answer but I dont buy that.

Not lending stuff out ? HMMMMMMMM 90 % of the time doing so is not an issue. What I aint goin to let my bud use my tender cause ten years ago some guy cost me a new motor? Motor was probably on its way out any way. How will any one ever build trust or lack of ?

In the day when I had them PWC if I was going to be teaching people on there use. I would run to some place there was no other boat traffic. One of the big problems with these things is owners seem to want to show off. Thats fine as long as the driver is aware of the suroundings. Yes I learned that the hard way. Just lucky no one got hurt. Dont teach people there use in crowded areas.

As far as the legal issue goes follow the cash cause thats who is going to get nailed IMO. The insurance company or companies will come to an agreement as there were no charges laid. He said she said , wasnt me deal means all are accountable. Just what percentage are you going to get. Again IMO. Thank the stars no one was killed.

Geeeez that was a bit over the top kinda sorry for that. But take some advise make sure you have the correct outfit for these machines. You might consider a dry suit along with a good ski vest. The use of white water kayak helmet from experience is simply a good idea. For them that are going to ride aggressive any way.

But I just dont see where any thing has truly been learned on the good old boaters forum?

Reality bites !!!!

Can ya all help the new guy out LOL.
 
3. When an accident occurs on the water the determination of who’s right and who’s wrong is not always clear cut like it is on the roadways,

Not always-I spent a week on Jury duty trying to determine fault in a traffic fatality.
 
quote:

Originally posted by oldfishboat

Unfortunatly I was a bit taken back by the neg responce from anchors here. As a newbeee.

I was also a bit surprised that I could be the only guy here that remembers running high powered boats when under the age of 12. Like this kinda accident never happens with experienced boaters driving! I sent my poor old man over the back of the runnabout when I was like 8. Thats OK cause he got even !!! PFD.

Things happen thats part of life. What would have changed this situation? Sure an 11 year old not driving is an answer but I dont buy that.





What is there not to buy??? That is EXACTLY what would have changed the situation.

The bottom line, based on all news reports, is that a supposedly responsible adult let an underage and inexperience child operate a jetski, and because of the child's inexperience and lack of knowledge of navigation rules, he turned into the path of a boat, causing an accident that almost cost him his life! It was the owner’s negligence in letting the boy operate the jetski that caused reckless endangerment, not only to the boy, but to every boater in the area. That is what caused the situation, and there is little excuse.

If I give a loaded gun to a kid, and he blows his head off, I will be responsible… Period! I not going to get away with anything by saying; “things happen, that’s part of life”, or “I used to shoot a gun when I was his age, so that makes it ok”.
 
Back
Top