Solar Charging Questions

btoran

Member
Joined
Oct 26, 2005
RO Number
19401
Messages
762
I know some of you guys have experience with solar charging your marine batteries and I need some advice.

We just moved our boat from a slip in a marina to a mooring at a boat club. When the boat was in the slip, the shorepower took care of charging all the batteries. we have 2 starting batteries (one for each engine) and four 6-volt trojan t105 golf cart batteries for the house system. the house batteries are wired in pairs and then again together to make 2 sets of 12v batteries with 225 ah per set. i'm told that since the 2 sets are wired together, devices "see" only one large 12v battery.

there is an inverter/charger that charges the house system and a separate charger for the starting batteries. when running the engines, an alternator on each engine charges the starting batteries but i don't think the alternators charge the house batteries.

to prepare for life on the mooring, i recently upgraded the bilge pump to a 3700 gph unit that draws 15.5 amps. i also installed a high water alarm and a system to count bilge pump cycles and bilge pump run time. when on the mooring, these components all run from the house battery system. the bilge pump should only draw current when it is turned on by the electric switch. the counters and high water alarm draw miliamps each.

i'm concerned that without shorepower, the batteries can only lose juice over time to the bilge pump. for safety reasons (to keep the bilge pump operating) as well as comfort reasons, i'd like to keep the house batteries charged as much as possible. even if it turns out one alternator does charge the house batteries, i'm not sure at what rpms the engine would have to spin the charge and the cost/noise involved.

one thought was to run a portable genny on the swim platform occasionally to charge up the batteries, but gennys are expensive, potentially dangerous (carbon monoxide producers), and i would need to go to the boat (potentially in bad weather) just to charge up the batteries.

a friend mentioned solar power and i started investigating. i spoke to two companies and both recommended a single charge regulator connected to two panels of approx 30 watts each.

so, does anyone have any tips or horror stories to tell about solar charging?

are there certain brands to stay away from?

assuming a dry hull (is bilge pump will activate for rain) and mimimal draw on the house batteries otherwise, will 60 watts be sufficient to keep the batteries charged up so when i do take the boat out on a weekend, the batteries are charged and reasdy to go?

thanks in advance for your advice.
 
I love solar... To be honest I'd go with more than 60 watts. The prices of panels is such that a single 135w is cheaper than 2-30w (less labor to install too); your only problem is figuring out where to put it (solar panels get BIG). I'd also put in a larger controller than you think you need, 'cause there's a good chance you'll decide to install another panel later, and it would be nice to not have to replace the controller (been there).

I'd connect the solar system to the house battery, but I'd also install a battery combiner (if you don't already have one) to keep the start batteries charged as well.

Do you still have your original (small) bilge pump? A small pump will do just fine as a "rain" pump; it will pull less off the batteries, cycle less, wear the auto-switch less, and keep your bilges drier to boot. Put a 1" block under the switch to the big pump so it will only kick in if the little pump fails.

I currently have 600 watts installed... it runs the fridge 24/7 and is enough that I can stay on the hook indefinitely without a generator.
 
I can only tell you what I use a pair of 120 watt Kyocera panels and a 180 watt Kyocera panel, they are rated at 24DVC thet are wired in parallel and feed a 25 amp MorningStar controller that has a 12VDC 3 stage output that internally splits 90% charges my house bank and 10% the starting port engine bank. Peak output appears to be 15 amps for 5 to 6 hours a day in Southern, NJ. My house bank is 3 Lifeline 8D 255AH each AGMs for the house bank (all paralleled) and the port starting bank is 2 31 series AGM's (paralleled). I constantly run an efficient 7cubic foot DC frig and bilge pumps. When not on the boaqt. Smaller panels like 30 watt will not be enough in my opinion. When the house bank comes up to full charge a high current BlueSea ACR allows the starboard side starting batteries to charge.
Bill
 
Willie & Bill,

My boat is stored in a covered booth so solar does me no good there, but our typical weekend is anchored out somewhere in the Delta in the warm sun. I currently have to run the gennie about 3-4 hrs a day to keep our battery bank (12-6V T-105's) charged enough to keep going. I've considered solar to supplement the gennie and I have a perfect spot atop the aft deck hard top to mount them. Can I ask approximately what your expense was in installing the solar systems?
 
<< expect about $10/watt, installed. May be lower, but $10 likely >>
 
Dave,

My 600w system was built up over a number of years, and total cost was probably around $3k. Solar panels are a lot less expensive now than they were (especially the big ones), so you should be able to come in under that. I just priced Kyocera 135's online at $385 each; so 4 of them would be $1540 (plus shipping). A Blue Sky 40 amp controller is another $344. Add a shunt, wiring and misc hardware and you're probably around $2500 if you do the work yourself (batteries not included). Google "windsun"

If you're a WEEKEND boater and have shore power available at the dock, it would be a lot more cost effective to simply install more batteries, and let the shorepower charger take care of them during the week.

Mine works great for me because I do NOT have a generator; and it was an either/or proposition. It was the right choice for me but it might be hard to justify in your case.
 
I use solar power in the same range you are talking about: 64W from two 32W panels. I use three group 27 deep cycle batteries: one starter battery and two house batteries. I have enough battery reserve to handle weekends without charging and use solar to keep the batteries charged during the longer stays at anchor. The panels run to a single solar charge controller. One house battery is solar charged per day while the other meets house power draw. The boat is set up to require very little house power at anchor: 30 amp/hrs or less per day. I use thin film flexible panels tied onto the cockpit canvas. The thin film flexible panels tend to be expensive compared to rigid panels but they have the advantage of greater efficiency with low angle sunlight and much lighter weight compared to rigid panels. The 64 watts of panels fully charge my Group 27s during a sunny summer day.

As I understand it, you want just enough solar power to maintain charge on the four T-107s which will be used to power a single 15.5 amp bilge pump. It would help to know how many amp/hrs that pump will require per day as well as any other amp/hrs you expect these house batteries to provide on a daily basis.

The nice thing about your set-up is that you have so much battery reserve. My concern is the type of draw you will get from the bilge pump. Keep in mind that if you expect the bilge pump to operate mostly for rain water removal then your battery reserve is crucial. You can't expect solar panels to produce much power with low angle winter sun and cloud cover during periods of rain. If you figure you have enough reserve available to power the pumps until the panels can operate during sunny winter conditions, then the system should work.

The more panel production you have, the faster you can build back a full charge on those batteries.
 
guys - thanks for the responses. here's a bit more info, including a check i made on the boat tonight.

i boat in the northeast and the boat is stored on land for the winter. so it's only the boating season (may - nov) that i'm concerned about. i have the old bilge pump but can't get access to the hull sides or transom to drill another thru-hiull, so i removed it.

the boat went onto the mooring on sunday. for the past two days it has rained on and off (and heavy at times). some of the water enters small scuppers and finds it's way out without the use of the pumps. but some water definitely collects in the bilge. since sunday the bilge pump has cycled 10 times and run somewhere between 6 - 12 minutes total. the meter reads .1 hrs and it will flip to .2 when the pump accumulates a total of 12 mins run time. i spent a lot of time researching gauges to find one that stores up increments less that .1 hrs (6 mins) internally (in cmos) and combines them when they totaled .1 hours so the figure of between .1 and .2 is accurate.

so, how much juice did i use?

the house batteries read 12.21 volts when i got to the boat tonight. i didn't write down the voltage when i left the boat on sunday but it was somewhere around 12.34 volts.

interestingly, it was the starting batteries that seemed a bit drained. they went from 13.5 volts down to 12 volts during the same period of time. there are a few cables coming off the starting batteries and i'm not sure what they operate. maybe the halon fire system? whatever it is it's using current. i'll figure out what it is but i like the idea of keeping the starting batteries topped off as well.

as mentioned, the price of solar panels has come down and single large ones are defnitely cheaper than smaller ones on a per watt basis. however, i want to be able to set the panels up on the bridge when i leave the boat and then stow them away when i take the boat out. because of this, i don't want them too big. i looked into some 45 watt panels from ul-solar today that are reasonably priced.

so here are a few more questions....

if i connected a single 45 watt panel to the house batteries, how many hours of peak sunlight would be required to replace the energy i lost over the last few days?

how about for the starting batteries?

i know i can connect several panels to a single charge controller and then connect the charge controller to a single battery, but can i connect a single charge controller to multiple batteries? do i have to join the batteries together first and if so, how?

thanks.
 
Here's my calculation. The pump ran 12 minutes or .2 hours and draws 15 amps while running; similiar to running a 3 amp load for 1 hour. That is about 3 amp hours. A single 45 watt panel will output a little over 3 amp hours per hour. So it would theoretically take one hour of good sunlight to recoup your loss.

There are devices, the same ones, that are used to connect different banks of batteries to an alternator using relays. They will keep the banks seperate from each other. When connected properly it would allow the house bank to get fully charged and then switch over the charging to other bank.
 
Well, while you still do not have the consumption side of the equation, you can calculate the theoretical power generation...

<< Tech-ni-cal ON >>

First, you need to know how much sunlight you have. This is called "insolation", and your area ( NY ) is -fair- with an annual avg of about 3.5 Kwh/sq meter/day. In Oct and Nov, the number stinks, below 2, but in the other in season months you are over 5. ( ie: you would receive an average of 3.5 kw per square meter, per day from the sun )

Panels are rated at their max power when illuminated w/ ikwh/sq meter, so you can get the total average daily generation by multiplying the average insolation by the rated panel max output power.

SO, that means each 45w panel, will, on average produce daily 225 watts of energy per day, for most of the boating season, falling off to about 50w to 100w per day in Oct and Nov.

For reference, stated another way, 225 watts /day is roughly the equivalent of charging w/ a 10A charger for 1.8 hrs/day.

(FWIW: at yzer's location, his insolation is about double yours, so the same system will produce about twice the electricity at yzer's location, vs what it produces at your location )

So, I cannot ( yet) answer the question of "will it bu sufficient" because I still do not know your usage numbers. But now you have an idea of what level of consumption to "not exceed".

Note also, that all of this is a) theory, b) using averages! There will be very productive days, and there will be really, really bad days...
 
I can also add that solar panel size as with house battery banks the largest you can install is always better. I would consider installing a wind generator there is almost always wind on the water. Wind unlike sunlight is there almost all the time. So you may want to also install one of the newer wind turbine generators.
I recently purchased a unit and plan on testing it to augment the solar system. If I were in a mooring field I would definately use both solar and wind to keep your batteries charged.
I plan on making my wind turbine removable for cruising.
Bill
 
The only reliable way to determine your power consumption is to install a battery monitor; and while they're great to have they're no small investment. As the discussed system is only to keep the batteries charged when the boat is unattended and the only thing on is the bilge pump, I'm not sure I could justify the expense.

As your 45w panel will probably be mounted horizontally, my calculations give you less power than Bill's, but still over 180 watt-hrs per day, or about 15 amp-hrs per day. If your pump draws 3 amp-hrs, you should be in good shape as far as the pump is concerned. The only question is those unknown loads on the starting battery.

If you check your batteries every week or so for a month, you should have a good idea on whether you have "enough". If not, simply increase the wattage of your system.

To connect your charge controller to multiple batteries, the easiest way would be to simply put your battery switch on "all". However a battery combiner connected between batteries will allow you to keep everything charged, yet isolated. It will also work when your engine is running, allowing you to charge your house bank.

I wouldn't be comfortable relying on ONE pump to keep the boat afloat though. Should the switch fail or the pump pick up a bit of trash, you could have an expensive problem. I'd find a way to reinstall that second pump.
 
You may want to look into one of the monitoring systems that will call you if your high water alarm goes off or if your voltage drops to low.

Or at the very least get a high water alarm and hook them up to a horn and flashing light on the outside of the boat.
 
capt bill - i looked into one of the systems that would call me in a high water condition, but couldn't justify the cost. the mooring is at a boat club with regular launch service so there's a boat passing by regularly. i installed a high water alarm (lights and screaming buzzer) on the bridge so it should get some attention if it goes off.

stmbtwle - i hear you about the second bilge pump and will try to figure something out. i went back to the boat and checked it again yesterday and determined that a) the engines do NOT charge the house system and b) one of the mystery wires on the starting batteries apparently ties the two of them together. i've decided to have one 45 watt solar panel and charge controller handle the starting batteries while another two 45 watt panels and charge controller handle the house batteries. if i have too much juice, i'll just sell it to iran so they'll stop enriching uranium. ;-)
 
I can't see much point in having a separate system charging the starting batteries. Most of the time they'll be charged anyway and the system will shut off. All of my panels go to one controller and it charges the house bank. A $60 Yandina combiner takes care of the starting battery, and also allows the engine to charge the house bank. Works for me.

Well, correction. Having a separate panel on the engine batteries would ensure they stay charged regardless of the condition of the house battery. I'd still use the "combiner" though as any overflow after the start batteries are charged would go to the house bank.

Really small panels (5w-10w) will usually keep your start batteries charged, they're relatively cheap, and they don't require a controller (more savings).

If you put your alarm system on the start battery it'll insure that the alarm still works, even if the house batteries go dead and the pumps quit.
 
Back
Top