Spotlight use question

king5899

Active member
exMember
Joined
Nov 22, 2005
RO Number
19628
Messages
1,432
I had an incident last night and am wondering who was correct and possible other means of avoidance.

Last night we pulled anchor and started heading back. My wife grabbed the helm as I secured our raft to the bow of the boat. We were idling along and all of a sudden I see lights heading strait at us moving fast. I jumped back to the helm and turned my spotlight on for a moment and then off so I would ensure they saw us in front of them. The boat then buzzed by us maybe around 25 mph and the kid (bunch of teenagers) yells "thanks for blinding me bleep, bleep, bleep and so on. Considering the short time to react was I wrong in turning on my spotlight? What other means of avoidance were possible?

Facts:
With the number of drunk boating accidents, I would tend to be cautious
Navigation lights on both boats were lit
There was no moon so it was pitch black
We were coming out of an inlet that normally no one passes through at high speed
I was on the bow so a sudden acceleration could have sent me over.
They came close enough to hear their comments maybe 50' between us at passing

Thoughts - ideas…
 
yes, i think you were wrong since your nav lights were on, there was no need for the spotlight. Blinding an oncoming boat is not only rude, it's dangerous since you cna be sure he would have problems seeing your navlights after a blast of spotlight detroyed his night vision.

maybe, if you suspect the guy may not have seen you, turn it on but pointed away from the oncoming boat...

at night in an inlet, the foredeck is not the right place to be, the dink should have been secured before raising anchor or before getting to the inlet.
 
My spotlight can only be moved while it is on, so I was unable to direct it. It was only flashed on for a split second and I don't believe it was pointed at him directly. Also we had already cleared the inlet and were just outside of it.

Thanks,
MJK
 
I will sometimes hit my spotlight in the same situation on the flood light setting pointed straight down at the water. It reflects up and lights my hull up like the moon.
 
i had one of those spotligths that can only be moved when turned on (lousy design)... i woudl always park it down, pointing at the water in front of the boat.

I see a lot of them parked facing aft, that's real stupid as to turn it around, you have to blind yourself.

well, in or outside the inlet is the same, not the place to be wrestling a dink on the foredeck of a 25 footer, even in calm weather you dont' know that you won't suddenly run into a big wake.
 
Well, if you didn't point it in their eyes it's no big deal. And with the way some people run their boats at night, it's better to be safe than sorry. Just don't make a habit of it.
 
quote:

Originally posted by PascalG

i had one of those spotligths that can only be moved when turned on (lousy design)... i woudl always park it down, pointing at the water in front of the boat.

I see a lot of them parked facing aft, that's real stupid as to turn it around, you have to blind yourself.

well, in or outside the inlet is the same, not the place to be wrestling a dink on the foredeck of a 25 footer, even in calm weather you dont' know that you won't suddenly run into a big wake.






The first time I used it, it was facing right at me and blinded me for a few minutes. Forward and down sounds like a good location to point it when not in use.

Agreed on securing the raft. I should figure a way to secure it on the swim platform. It is a actually a 2 person tube. When I pull my anchor the windlass gets stuck where the rope and chain meet so I have to go forward to get it past that point. I usually tie the tube up front after the anchor is pulled so it is not sitting on the windlass.

Thanks,
MJK
 
quote:

Originally posted by Capt. Bill1

Well, if you didn't point it in their eyes it's no big deal.






My intention was not to shine it in their direction at all, only to increase their knowledge of my presence on the water so they would avoid any collision. As they approached it appeared they do not change their course till they got pretty close so I got a bit nervous.

MJK
 
While I'm against blinding another boat, if you couldn't tell if he had seen you I don't think you had a whole lot of choice in this case.

Just having your nav lights on is no guarantee, particularly if there is shore lighting behind you.
 
"As they approached it appeared they do not change their course till they got pretty close so I got a bit nervous."

I did the same thing on the night of the 4th of July. Boat started coming right at me head on then crossed my bow port to stbd. Hit him with my spot light on his hull just before he crossed my bow to make sure he knew I was there. Turned out it was a tow boat not a drunk. Just goes to show you even the so called pros do dumb things.

And as Willie noted, having your running lights on can be no help if there are lights in the background or the other person is distracted, drunk or both.
 
If he passed at 25 mph 50' from you at night he was probably not thinking very well could have been impaired. I would agree about only shinning the spot light right in front of your vessel and not at the other boat as that will just make the situation less safe.
 
I seem to recall 'broadcast' in my exam. This is the shining of a spotlight and is to be avoided, as you know not to blind the oncoming captain. However being a graduate of the University of Monday Night Quarter Back, I think I would flash the light five times, so as to indicate danger.

You can be right or you can be dead right. Glad to hear no one was hurt.

El Sea,
1976' Thompson 44
Suite 44
St Petersburg, Fl
 
How about blinking your nav lights off and on quickly five times? Maybe blast your horn five times? I would hesitate to use my spotlight for the reasons stated. I have a HH rechargeable spotlight which offers more options.
 
If in doubt of the intentions of an oncoming boat, the rules of the road recommend sounding five blasts of your horn. Should that fail to draw attention, sound five more blasts. Then slow the boat to a safe speed and proceed with caution. Make sizeable course changes so as to eliminate any confusion on behalf of the oncoming boat of your direction of travel.

Use of a spotlight would be the last ditch effort as it can have disasterous effects on a boat operators night vision and not just temporary loss of night vision. I recommend you have someone shine a similar light in your eyes some night and see what effect it has on your vision.
 
quote:

Originally posted by kgd

If he passed at 25 mph 50' from you at night he was probably not thinking very well could have been impaired. I would agree about only shinning the spot light right in front of your vessel and not at the other boat as that will just make the situation less safe.






This was my take on the situation as well. I know there is no speed limit at night, but I believe you are always supposed to maintain a safe operating speed. Based on the darkness and the close proximity, I didn't feel they were maintaing a safe speed and assumed the worst, possibly drunk.

Well I picked up a few ideas for any future run ins and avoided one as well.

Thanks for everyone's input!

MJK

BTW -
Why don't they make a spotlight that returns to a "Home" position when you switch it off. Assuming home would be forward center pointing down. If anyone patents it, I want 20% of all proceeds.
 
I agree with not hurting another boater's vision. One trick is to turn on deck lights if you have them--spreader lights on sailboats or lighting up sails or hull with a lower power flashlight. Of course any light you turn on affects your night vision. I agree that 5 blasts of the horn is appropiate, but it may not be heard considering the noise level in many boats at speed, and with the puny horns on most of oour boats--the case for a good air horn. (or even one of the canister air horns)

In this case you don't know if you blinded the on coming boater or not. If you had put the spotlight on my hull, it probably would have been enough to cause loss of vision--if the light was on the water to the side--it would not. On the other hand, we have to contend with spotlights on the ICW on the Gulf coast where the tugs keep two spotlights on the water a mile ahead all of the time--and we live with it.
At least no one was harmed and you have other options.
 
ChesBay gives the only sensible answer to this post, the sizeable correction of your course should be to starboard. It is your job to maintain an adequate look out, by all means available, in order to ascertain if a risk of collision exist. It is further your job to alter course (to starboard) if a risk of collision is deemed to exist.
 
Anything goes as a last ditch effort, but in this case you were wrong as you were too quick to use a tool that even if not pointed directly at the other boater can significantly destroy his night vision. As mentioned, there are lots of other things to have been tried first.

But hey, things happen fast and you acted. In retrospect, there were wiser things to do. Don't beat yourself up about it, but you asked and the answer is...wrong.
 
I don't think I'd put a spotlight right on the approaching boat unless it was very obvious that I had not been seen & a collision looks imminent. The beam of a spotlight pointed straight UP should be enough to alert others of your presence as a first action.
 
IMHO I think you risk the chance of placing your boat in greater danger by possibly blinding the Captain of the oncoming boat. Again in my opinion if you thought you risked collision, you should have changed you course.

I am not defending the other party,from what you state he appears totally in the wrong, but it is your responsibility to look out for the safety of your passengers, and risking blinding the on-coming boat only endangers your crew.
 
Back
Top