Starboard----Too Late!

Mitchell Kirby ’11 had a lot to be thankful for over Thanksgiving break after he and Dan Greenwald ’81 survived a plane crash at Peter O. Knight Airport in Tampa, Fla., on Friday.
The two met at an alumni dinner and bonded over their mutual interest in flying.

Kirby and Greenwald were flying in an Extra 300 aircraft piloted by Greenwald and were coming in to land when the right wing of the plane clipped the mast of a sailboat that was in the channel located right in front of the runway.

“We had a very nice, uneventful flight,” Greenwald said. “I was flying a normal approach. The end of the runway is right up against the sea wall, and a sailboat without sails flying, motoring at low speed, crossed my path. Any airplane 50 feet above the runway is in a position of compromised visibility. Once the right wing was off, the plane was flying on its side.”

“I knew there was no way we could recover,” Kirby said. “I knew we were going to crash, and crashes like that, people don’t normally walk away from … [Once] we hit, all of a sudden, everything was really calm. I really thought I was going to die.”

Greenwald said that there was little time to react but that his instincts as a pilot took over.

“Drunk people survive car crashes because they’re relaxed, so I made a conscious effort to relax, my second reaction was to clear the sea wall, and my third was that we might die in this accident,” Greenwald said.

The plane was upside down when it came to a stop, and Greenwald was able to punch his way out of the plane.

Four or five people had to flip the plane to remove Kirby from the wreckage, however.

Kirby credits Greenwald’s skills as a pilot as the reason they were able to survive the crash.

“If we were a couple inches lower, we would have hit the sea wall, and we would have died instantly,” Kirby said. “We were going about 100 miles per hour, and Dan completely saved our lives because he was able to clear the sea wall.”

“He’s one of the best pilots,” Kirby added.

Both agreed that the crash was unavoidable on their part.

“I absolutely blame the sailboat because we have right of way,” Greenwald said. “The sailboat … was as close to the runway as it could be. I would certainly not have flown into a sailboat if I had seen it.”

Kirby broke his left leg in two places and fractured five bones in his foot, while Greenwald has broken bones in his left hand and sustained many bruises. Neither will be able to return immediately to school or work.

“I can’t put pressure on my leg for three months,” Kirby said. “I’m in … the biggest cast that anyone has ever seen. They’ve been teaching me how to get around. It’s getting easier, but I’m still pretty weak.”

Kirby plans to return to school in January to take his finals.

“I called the dean of my residential college, and they called my professors, who were all great and said that they’ll do whatever they can to make sure I can finish out the semester,” he said.

Greenwald said he hopes to return to his job as a plastic surgeon in no more than a week and a half, explaining that he should be fine in the operating room because his dominant hand was not injured in the crash.

Though Greenwald said that the crash didn’t scare him and wouldn’t prevent him from returning to the skies, Kirby wasn’t as sure.

“I’ve been thinking about it. I thought that if I got back in a plane, it would be with the same person; he’s just the best,” Kirby said. “I’ll probably get back in, but it might take some time, I guess.”

Greenwald and Kirby both said they were grateful to be alive.

“We were so lucky, it was like a miracle,” Kirby said. “I’m just really happy to be alive.”

“We both survived something fairly profound,” Greenwald said. “The part of me that is most unhappy is the part that worries about my friend.”
 
interesting... i've dealt with boats in the islands, but usually on take off... or trucks on landing... in this case, it's hard to imagine the pilot not seeing the sailboat approaching the runway axis and taking appropriate action, especially considering the speed at which a sailboat moves, it's not like the guy came flying down the channel at 40kts...
 
“I absolutely blame the sailboat because we have right of way,” Greenwald said. “The sailboat … was as close to the runway as it could be. I would certainly not have flown into a sailboat if I had seen it.”Is this true? ie: Does the aircraft have right of way over a motor boat?

( A -seaplane- does not... )
 
IMO the pilot must take responsibility for ascertaining nothing is in his way when he lands. The boat wouldn’t have changed position very much during his landing so he just didn’t see it. It is no surprise that there are sailboats in the area as the airport abuts the sailboats only Davis Island YC.
The guys comments about all the things he was thinking and doing in the seconds between the time he hit the mast and crashed sound off to me. It all would have happened very quickly, too quickly IMO for what he says he did.
 
It depends on where the Mast was, when the pilots eyes went back to the Runway. On short final you are usually pretty well focused on the Runway.
The Cowling would have hid the mast if he didnt see it on his turn to final. In Florida they might not be used to checking for tall trees or Sailboats at that Runway.

In Anchorage, at lake Hood the Hotel owner was going up with three more stories. Somebody stopped him because he would have been in the approach/Departure airspace for the Lake traffic.

If it had been a manned tower, they would have alerted the pilot who might have made a High approach and slipped it down to the runway or went around and made another final approach
Somebody said it: "The Lawyers will be busy with this one for awhile"!
 
quote:



“If we were a couple inches lower, we would have hit the sea wall, and we would have died instantly,” Kirby said. “We were going about 100 miles per hour, and Dan completely saved our lives because he was able to clear the sea wall.”

...

“The sailboat … was as close to the runway as it could be. I would certainly not have flown into a sailboat if I had seen it.”






If the sailboat was as close to the runway as it could be, why were they worried about hitting the sea wall? That doesn't make sense.
 
http://maps.google.com/maps?hl=en&ie=UTF8&q=Peter+O.+Knight+Airport+in+Tampa,+Fla.,&fb=1&cid=13229383867098769172&li=lmd&t=h&ll=27.918966,-82.449303&spn=0.01987,0.029912&z=15
 
Here's a pic from Google Earth. If he were landing on runway 21, hitting the seawall would be a real concern. I think it's maybe 4' high in that area.

Lawyers should have a ball with it...

PeterOknight.jpg
 
Ahhh, the old "Tall ships in the harbor" ops spec question. Have the same issue at BOS Logan only the ships are uhhh noted.
 
That channel is also the route that cruise ships take to port of Tampa. Several times a week Carnival ships several hundred feet high pass next to the airport. Maritime hazards to landings should be common knowledge.
 
That's a pretty narrow channel. It seems apparent that the risk of boat traffic is obvious. The real error is the statement "we have the right of way". Whether true or not, it means the pilot gave himself license to ignore any such traffic. It doesn't take a rocket scientist to figure out that people are not always going to follow the rules, nor does it take a rocket scientist to figure out that the possibility of an adrift object is there as well (unmanned adrift objects having the reputation of not giving a damn what the rules are).

This is a case where its clear to the uninformed (me) that the pilot will be found at least partially responsible. Because one thing that the captain of any vehicle takes the responsibility for is being prepared not just for what should happen, but also for what could happen. Here's a guy we have on record (though all news articles are suspect) as stating that it was not his problem. I believe the state of his plane and body will overrule anything written anywhere on paper.
 
was he trying to check out the girls in bikini's?

seems like there's plenty of runway there, why so low if there could be traffic AND it's in a blind spot.
 
another thing to consider, Time of day. if his approach was on 21 and it was the afternoon, he would of had the sun as a backdrop and the mast would have been a very small target to pick out.
 
More important, being a boating forum, what happened to the sailboat?
 
Just checked out this airport. There is an RNAV approach to runway 21. There is no tall ships notice because a ship properly in the channel does not penetrate the approach plane. If the boat's mast penetrated the approach plane, which if he was outside the channel is likely and because the article says he was right up against the sea wall then he created a hazard to air navigation by placing a high structure in the approach plane to an instrument runway and airport. In which case the boat owner has violated the FAR's. That will go a long way in any civil suit.
 
Greg:
The channel in that area is shown as "cut D" on chart 114161. I dont know how to post a picture of the chart, perhaps someone else does.
Since it is a major dredged shipping channel it is shown using about 80% of the width of water seen in the aerial photo with no marks on the airport side indicating an edge of the channel. Like many dredged ship cuts the dredged area it just stops near the riprap at the airport edge with the deep part as close to shore as practical dredging limitations allow.
It is the location of the annual lunacy in the area known as gasparilla invasion when hundreds of boats plug the channel right at the airport.
If we can get a copy of the chart posted I thing you will agree that there are no limitations to marine navigation other than being shallow at the very edge.
 
Back
Top