Survey "compromise"

Indentured Servant

Member
exMember
Joined
Oct 18, 2007
RO Number
28816
Messages
94
After reading the thread about the Carver, I am left wondering about a less comprehensive survey on an older gas powered boat. I am looking at a late 80's tiara w/ twin 454's fwc. I was planning on just moisture readings, compression check and oil analysis, as well, of course, a visual inspection of the systems, running gear and hull. I want to know about major problems, but I don't want to spend thousands to do it. (I know an engine survey will be less expensive on a gas boat). Upon cursory inspection, boat "appears" to be in good shape.

Any thoughts? Anything else that one would highly recommend?
 
the size of the boat and location will determine the cost of the survey(s). even in an expensive market like the metro ny area, a 30ish ft boat with full hull/mechanical survey, seatrial, and engine oil analysis should be signifcantly less than 2k. however, that would not include a full engine survey.
 
"Appears" is a classic weasel word in a survey. Sounds like you want a price not a survey. Call one of the guys at Stevie Wonder Marine Surveyors, they should be able to help you out. If they are busy call one of folks at Ray Charles Marine.
 
quote:

Originally posted by L. Keith

"Appears" is a classic weasel word in a survey. Sounds like you want a price not a survey. Call one of the guys at Stevie Wonder Marine Surveyors, they should be able to help you out. If they are busy call one of folks at Ray Charles Marine.






LKeith:

I believe the OP meant the upon HIS cursory inspection the boat appears to be in good shape.

Indentured; you may want to post this in the survey section of BE. One of the best in the business is the moderator and he would be more likely to see it there than here.
 
Always perform full due diligence. It is the cheapest way to buy anything. (Thank you former billionaire boss who gave me this pearl)
 
Thanks, KiDa, will try there if he doesn't see this!

Dana

L-Keith- Shouldn't you be over on the BoatUS forum?
 
if you go ahead with a purchase it's likely that the existing owner will pay to have items fixed that show up in the survey or will reduce the agreed price by an appropriate amount for the items to be fixed by you. in the end, the survey pays for itself. if you're not proceeding with a purchase after survey because a) the boat had major problems and/or b) the existing owner won't lower the cost, then the cost of the survey probably saved you much more down the road. the best "compromise" i can think of is to have someone who knows boats very well, but it not a professional surveyor, look the boat over with you informally. if he thinks it's in good enough shape to seatrial and survey (and if you like the boat and price) then go for the seatrial first, then the survey.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Indentured Servant

After reading the thread about the Carver, I am left wondering about a less comprehensive survey on an older gas powered boat. I am looking at a late 80's tiara w/ twin 454's fwc. I was planning on just moisture readings, compression check and oil analysis, as well, of course, a visual inspection of the systems, running gear and hull. I want to know about major problems, but I don't want to spend thousands to do it. (I know an engine survey will be less expensive on a gas boat). Upon cursory inspection, boat "appears" to be in good shape.

Any thoughts? Anything else that one would highly recommend?






My experience with surveyors is they check out the boat, NOT the mechanicals. For that you need to hire a mechanic.

My history with 2 surveyors and mechanics was they provided dubious information concerning the total well being of the boats in question. There are those who beat the "get a surveyor" drum. I am not one of them!

Yes, I had my boat surveyed prior to completing the purchase but I was forced to. One cannot get insurance (at least around here) without having a survey report. If I could have purchased insurance, I would never have hired a surveyor. I feel surveys are over rated.

Foggy
 
I just wonder how long it'll be before someone swears I'm Keith in disguise. Why aren't all you Group Huggers all over HIM?
 
I always use a surveyor. I do my own preliminary inspections then if I actually decide to make an offer I get the best surveys possible because there are probably many things that a full survey will uncover. The cost of surveys have always been offset by the value of the discount or work done based on the survey. Sellers generally have less resistance to a third party experts comments than a buyer's complaints. Smart sellers also realize that hiding the results of survey from a subsequent buyer opens them to claims that they hid known problems from the next buyer.
 
Indentured, I think it all depends upon the value of the boat. The higher the price, the more protection from loss you need. Thus, as price increases a more comprehensive survey would be in order.

In your case, with a late 80's Tiara, I would be looking for a basic hull survery -- make sure there are no soft spots, rot, stringer issues, etc. The surveyor would probably look at the electronics and other systems as well. I would then have a mechanic do a simple compression test on the engines. Add a sea trial, and you should have enough info to make a reasonably informed decision. Good luck.
 
I.D., I don't do Boats are US.

If you want a surveyor that comes to an opinion by means of mutual concession or compromise, the phone book is full of them, the faux names I gave are representative of that class of surveyor.

A lower priced survey, may prove to be most costly in the long run.
 
What Greg did in his post was great, but pulling out the big guns (diesel survey, and boat survey) before running through the boat yourself can be costly.

I would recommend, a test ride and going through the boat yourself first, also bringing some knowledgeable friends along would be a big help.

Once you did this, two things will happen, first, with what you have found, do you still want to consider this boat? Second, is the person you are buying the boat from willing to repair the items you found?

Once you decide the boat and the seller, are good, and then by all means bring out the big guns.
If your looking at boats that are not in your area, then ask a BE member to take a look and shoot some pictures for you. If you ever need me to look at a boat (LI, NY), I would be more than happy to help.

Walter
 
<"A lower priced survey, may prove to be most costly in the long run.">

This sentence is good advice. I have had 2 surveys done in my life. The total on both was less than $2000. I walked away from the first boat because of the survey results vs the selling price and no price negotiation on the part of the seller. Most surveys are going to be pretty comprehensive. A good surveyor will not jeopardize his or her reputation by doing less.

If you tell us the manufacturer of the boat you are looking at you may get some feedback from a current/former owner right here. If you go to the "insert boat manufacturer name here" owner club you will probably get a ton of info as well. There is only one owners club that I know of that is swayed too much by emotion to bad mouth the brand. Pretty much all the major brands are represented here in their own forums and this is a no holds barred place when it comes to telling what is good and bad about a brand. I wouldn't surprise me if manufacturers monitered this site like hawks.

HTH
 
Thanks for the advice. I have already determined that the boat is worthy of serious purchase consideration and survey if we can come to terms (hoping to hear today (long story)), as I spent about 45 minutes looking through the ec, bilge, transom, etc. Not withstanding, I would still like to get some moisture readings and hull/structure analyis by a pro. My regular mechanic is equipped to do the compression test and oil analysis (he sends it out). My hang up was spending thousands of dollars on a comprehensive survey for a boat that is not worth megabucks. If we come to terms and test ride is OK, then I will have the limited (i.e. Golfman's post) survey completed and take my mechanic on the seatrial. Thanks to those who helped!

Walter-

Thanks for the offer. If this boat doesn't work out for me there are a couple similar boats down in LI that "appear" to be worthy of preliminary consideration.

Dana
 
"What Greg did in his post was great, but pulling out the big guns (diesel survey, and boat survey) before running through the boat yourself can be costly.

I would recommend, a test ride and going through the boat yourself first, also bringing some knowledgeable friends along would be a big help."

Actually I should have made myself clear, we did look at the boat last week before I made an offer. We snooped through it carefully. In the bilge we saw some anti-freeze which distrubed me, but that is why you bring in the big guns. However, things like the shaft seals and the vibration did not come to light without some extensive running. I felt a sea trial is best accomplished with the surveyors on board. Quite frankly, I leave sticking my head in the bilge of a running diesel boat that I don't know well for the pros.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Tanqueray

I just wonder how long it'll be before someone swears I'm Keith in disguise. Why aren't all you Group Huggers all over HIM?






Man, you a re always somewhere stirring it up aren't you... Get a life already...
 
We have come to terms on price. Now time for survey/sea trial. He is taking my boat on trade. We will miss it as it has been a great boat and the first one I owned by myself. Lots of memories with my older daughter on it.....

Thanks to all those with helpful comments!

Dana
 
Back
Top