The "Trawler" Premium

glenncal1

Member
exMember
Joined
Sep 9, 2006
RO Number
23116
Messages
593
In looking at boats for sale (just for fun) I am amazed how the addition of the word Trawler seems to add to the price. A mid 80's 40' Taiwan Tub will have an asking price considerably higher than a comprable Chris Craft, Uniflite, Tollycraft etc. I just dont see it, while the Taiwan boats aren't bad I don't think they have the quality of the U.S. built boats. If you want to save fuel you can always slow down.
 
I am also looking at Trawlers and you are correct they have taken hits but nothing like the rest of the fleet of boats that pleasure boaters would purchase.
Bill
 
You nailed it.

The funny thing. No, the hillarious thing, is that 95% of the boats with the "trawler" name are anything but. They are the very same semi-planing hulls that are on the rest of the boats out there.

Obviously I'm biased, but in your neck of the woods Tolly's are not well known. If I were you, I'd be more than happy to take advantage of depressed boat prices to get ahold of one. Even Hat's this far west are not always significantly appreciated. Go for quality and take advantage of a situation that won't last forever.

Knowlege is power!
 
Hhost is correct; 95% are trawler in name only. Folks dont know so they buy the word and pay extra for marketing baloney.
 
There is one other style boat that has not lost much value the Catamaran, especially power CATs.
 
keep in mind YW asking prices are all over the place... it's not because most trawlers owners are asking more that they will get that...

now with diesel under $2 these days, i wonder if trawlers aren't going to follow the rest of the market.
 
Not so different from the "downeast" premium. Very comparable in that most boats that are marketed as being downeast, have nothing in common with a true 'built down', smooth chined hull.

Dan
 
And then there is Hinkley trying to have a monopoly on the term 'picnic boat', a name for a style of NE boats that has been around for many decades before Hinkley started to build powerboats.

Back to trawlers. One big reason for a trawler retaining value is the fact that they don't date themselves. The same style using the same molds etc. are used for years. The production builders are forever changing styles to outdo or keep up with each other. What is new today will be very old fashioned looking in 5 years. With a trawler builder you can't tell the difference unless you have knowledge & an eye for detail.
 
Veebyes, you make a very good point which many of us had not considered.

What about "fishing" boats? Install a fresh water tank instead of seating, a fishfinder and call it a fishing boat and the price goes up $20k on a new boat. That is craxy!!!!
 
I will agree that there are some manufacturers that add the name trawler to thier model line, just for the sake of saying they manufactuer trawlers.
Some of the only true trawlers being manufactured today are Nordhaven, Kady-Krogen, Grand Banks and Outer Reef, and all of them will cost you over 1 million new before being splashed for the first time.

However, there is a lot to be said for some of the used Taiwanese trawlers that are out there for sale.

First of all....asking price and actual selling price are two different things. I just bought a used Taiwanese trawler this past October, and I paid 40% less than the original asking price a few months earlier. The economy had a lot to do with that, I am sure.
Secondly, my prior boat was a Silverton 34 Convertible that weighed in at 12,500lbs, this trawler is 4 feet longer and 1 foot wider and it weighs almost double at 24,700lbs. So there has to be quite a difference in the amount of materials that is used in building the boat.
The draft of the Silverton was 36", while the draft of the trawler is 48" with a full length keel even though both are built on a semi-displacement hull. The added draft and keel give this boat a much more comfortable ride and stable feel. Therte is no way that this trawler will ever "get up on plane", so I feel hull design has little to do with it. (Difference between semi-displacement vs displacement)
The Silverton had a total horsepower of 540, and a fuel (gasoline) burn of 20GPH at cruising speed at 16 knots. The trawler has a total of 270 HP and a fuel (diesel) burn of 4GPH at cruising speed of 9 knots.
Tank capacity is also quite a bit different, 40 gallons of water on the Silverton compared to 140 on the trawler, 10 gallons of waste compared to 70, and 220 gallons of fuel compared to 310 gallons.
I also believe that trawlers, being built for long range coastal cruising are better fitted out than their weekend cruising counterparts.
The number of items, and quality of these items that I received along with my purchase was phenomenal.
The prior owner had just a few years earlier installed a Raymarine electronics package valued at over $15,000. There was an array of spare engine parts, tools, filters, etc valued at $6,000. Misc items, such as 12 fenders, 26 dock lines, 2 magma grills, 3 anchors of varying weights and styles, Weaver davits, St. Croix davits, dinghy cradle, crane, two year old full size Norcold AC/DC refrigerator, propane stove with oven, propane lockers and cylinders, 1 year old diesel generator, 4 year old inflatable dinghy & motor, and the list goes on and on.

All these extra items add up, and therefore, the reason for a higher asking price than other comparable weekend cruisers.

All in all, you need to compare apples to apples before saying that one type of boat cost more than the other.
 
Albaris hit the nail on the head.

Also, with less flat in the hull design, in rough conditions,that Trawler will be riding diferently in the water at 9 kts than any of our twin screw cruisers.

RWS
 
There are big differences between cruiser & trawler owners too. The first thing a potential cruiser owner asks is "How fast?" followed by "What is the ride like?" The trawler buyer wants to know the tankage, not fuel, fresh water & holding tank. He already knows that he can go a long way on little fuel without having to touch shore. He will also prefer propane for cooking. He most likely will not look for the biggest genny for the boat either. His cabin spaces are naturaly well ventilated with hatches & ports that work & he will only want the AC on the warmest of nights. Being constructed of light weight materials so that his boat can go skipping across the surface of the water is not an issue for the trawler owner. Heavy is better. Once the weight is moving not much energy is required to keep it moving at near hull speed.

True, most US 'trawlers' are built on semi displacement hulls which are not as efficient as the true displacements like Krogen. For true displacements with little hp & drop dead georgeous finish check these out.

http://www.linssenyachts.com/index.php?language=en
 
I have to disagree with albaris on the Grand Banks. While there are nice boats with a long reputation of a higher quality build, its pretty obvious seeing one out of the water that they follow the identical formula of the rest of the "coastal cruiser" crowd.

This is not a trawler in any true sense of the meaning. People buy them for status, not sea crossing ability. In fact its the icon that frames the issue better than any other.
 
Again Ghost is correct. the only thing the Grand Banks boats have in common with a true trawler is low power and the name trawler. Generations of boat buyers have been fooled by great marketing.
Now I dont mean that anything is wrong with GBs. They are pretty boats design deficiency but no more economical than many other non "trawler" boats when going slow. They do suffer from lack of bow flare though.
Fuel use is proportional primarily to speed everything else is second or third order.
A true trawler is designed for sea keeping and low drag when heavily loaded but mostly that seems a myth in pleasure boats as stabilizers of some sort are frequently very desirable as roll stability is less than satisfactory on many.
 
Trawlers are a mindset. You must be happy with 60 to 90 miles per day at 8mph. Most of us do not have the time nor are we inclined to be restricted to 8 mph. However, we enjoy that speed almost every time we take our boat out. But we have the capability to shove the throttles up and proceed at 25 mph to our destination. There are no perfect boats. Every boat is a compromise.
 
"Every boat is a compromise."

Probably one of the best statements that could possibly be made.

I like this one too.

"They are all different. They are all fun."

bp
 
The right boat can be used fast or slow depending on circumstances. So atleast in that sense no compromise is necessary.
 
<<..."This is not a trawler in any true sense of the meaning."...>>

I guess I'll be the curnudgeon, and disagree with all of you. None of the boats you all are discussing are trawlers in the TRUE sense of the meaning. A true trawler is used for TRAWLING, ususally dragging a net. It is a commercial fishing vessel. It "trawls."

All the above boats being discussed are a type of pleasure boat,...some with displacement, some with semi-displacement hulls, and with various power arrngements. None of them are set up to trawl.

Growing up near the fishing communities of southern RI, this is the only kind of trawler I knew. This is a true trawler.
trawler.gif
 
Glenn: In order to provide true trawler experience several trawler companies have announced that their bilges will now contain dead fish.
 
<<...."Glenn: In order to provide true trawler experience several trawler companies have announced that their bilges will now contain dead fish."...>>

Now that there was funny!
 
Back
Top