The "Trawler" Premium

quote:

Originally posted by pdecat

Glenn’s commercial only argument aside, many great points were made above however the folks buying the "trawler" idea think they are getting something more efficient or more seaworthy. Mostly they are not, so it is not baiting to inform folks as Ghost has done so well that if they are focused only on boats called "trawlers" they are being misled.
My assessment of that Camano that I didn’t post to avoid argument is that the posters pictures show flat sections aft, hard chines, square transom and probably lack of serious low ballast. It is a semi planning hull that will rise up somewhat with sufficient power and probably likes to roll.
.
Second to speed when considering economy is drag. If you want to see what a low drag hull looks like look at a sailboat or a submarine.






The bottom line for me is that a few years ago, I saw a Camano Troll at the Savannah boat show and I really liked it. When one became available locally, my wife and I looked at it and eventually bought it. It's a lot like a small apartment inside; no need to remove and store a table to make up a berth, large windows to let the light in, a flybridge for driving and sunning in good weather, a lower helm and enclosed cabin for bad weather, a galley equipped with a propane stove, oven, and broiler, etc., etc., etc.

When it rains, my slip neighbors at the marina rush to find and install their canvas, I close the door.

I can't get somewhere as fast as the others, but I can get there using far less fuel and in comfort.

As for low ballast, I have nothing to compare it to, but the engine, and fuel and water tanks sit low in the hull.

On the down side, it's difficult to back into a slip.

Would I trade it for a 31' sport cruiser? No way.
 
*******************************
This discussion focuses on technical versus the general usage of a term. Absolutely true, a trawler means a type of fishing boat and this was its initial meaning. But the English language is not static and is constantly evolving. <<..."Also true, the word trawler has been applied to pleasure boats and accepted for use in the description of a certain class of boat. I disagree that “trawler” so used is a just a marketing term but acknowledge that it has been used for marketing purposes. There are many terms used to describe certain general classes of boats and “trawler” belongs. YachtWorld uses it in their Search functions. Is it a perfect descriptor without flaws? Of course not, but it is useful as we share information about our boats. "...>>
***************************

I do understand that word meanings have changed. I just found it amusing that you all were discussing what really makes a "TRUE" trawler, when none of them were true trawlers.
 
Some trawlers in in the Port of Galilee. Narragansett, RI

Trawlers and Block Island Ferry
GalileeRI.jpg


Galilee-7.jpg


Very seaworthy trawlers that head out as far as the Georges Bank and the Grand Banks
Galilee2.jpg


Heading home from Block Island Sound to Harbor of Refuge, Port of Galiee. Narrgansett, RI
Galilee4.jpg


A BIG one.
Galilee5.jpg
 
ok. here's a question / topic that hasn't come up about "pleasure" trawlers (as opposed to commericial ones). do pleasure trawlers (either the kadey krogen displacement type or the recently branded "fast trawler" type) steer any better at slow speeds than a non-trawler that is running slowly. for instance, i can slow down and save lots of money on fuel by running my boat at hull speed, but steering is a pain as there's a lot of slop and it's very easy to oversteer. on plane, my boat steers just fines. i'm assuming the displacement type pleasure trawlers steer nicely at slow speeds since that's all they can go. what about the steering on "fast trawlers" running at hull speed?
 
Pleasure trawlers usually handle better at lower speeds than true planing hulls. Most have full keels and large rudders which help low speed handling.

-Ron
Mainship 350 "Trawler"
 
Glenn has the right pictures of what a trawler is. Applied to recreational boats, as mentioned above, the term is almost meaningless. Boats called "trawlers" have every kind of hull form possible. So you can make no generalizations about handling or seaworthiness; it is a boat by boat issue.

George
Hatteras 56MY
(with plenty of experience on almost every flavor of Grand Banks and Mainship "Trawler", all of which I like, BTW)
 
quote:

Originally posted by btoran

ok. here's a question / topic that hasn't come up about "pleasure" trawlers (as opposed to commericial ones). do pleasure trawlers (either the kadey krogen displacement type or the recently branded "fast trawler" type) steer any better at slow speeds than a non-trawler that is running slowly.



Yes, my Mainship 34 steers and handles as well at 7 knots as at 15, its top speed.
 
I notice that Yacht World has two categories for boat types to differentiate between commercial and pleasure relevant to the discussion. Trawlers mostly show pleasure craft or fishing boats which may be used for sport or commercial fishing. The large boats with outriggers used for dragging nets as pictured above are listed under Trollers in the commercial category.
 
Bruce:

You cant generalize. Your boat has it's individual handling characteristics as do Krogans. If you want an interesting experience try backing a single screw Krogan without thrusters. My Carver handles superbly at any speed. What's the difference? Certainly not the brand name or the description of aft cabin or trawler, the difference is bottom profile, windage and weight.
.
Sweeping generalizations are invariably wrong. Trawlers don’t handle better than planning boats, planning boats don’t make bigger wakes at slow speed. Trawlers dont all have low drag bottom profiles, aft cabin or sedan cruisers don’t handle worse than ‘trawlers” etc, etc
.
A big part of the confusion about the different boats is the almost total lack of bottom profile information from power boat companies. The most important issue is hidden from buyers while all the focus is on above water line stuff. Sail boaters have long known that what’s under water is one of the most important predictors of suitability for intended use.

I just looked at the Krogan web site, at three boats, and could not find a single comment about or picture of any boat bottom. Amazing
 
some time ago we had posts of different bottom profiles that would help with this thread but I cant find it now.
 
Glenn those last two are NOT trawlers. I'm pretty sure they're seiners (though admittedly the hull form is similar).

But then anyone who is familiar with the Texas or Louisiana coast is familiar with a "Lafitte Skiff" and it's Texas variant. Many of them ARE trawlers in that they are commercial fishing boats that DO drag a trawl. But they still have flat or nearly flat planing hulls and most can get up and MOVE.

So it's all a matter of semantics. Most "yachtsmen" wouldn't be happy with a "true" round-bottom full-displacement trawler, the speed reserve isn't there and the roll can be frightening. You'll notice in most of the pix above that most of the trawlers (and seiners) have flopper-stoppers (those things hanging off the outriggers). They're there for a reason and it ain't style.

On the other hand an offshore commercial fisherman probably wouldn't be happy with anything else.
 
OK, since my boat is apparently not actually a "trawler", what should it be called?

And while we have the attention of the boat naming experts, what is the difference between a cruiser, sport cruiser, express cruiser, and pocket cruiser? And a day cruiser?
 
I see it called a performance cruiser in some articles, that works for me but if I was selling it I would call it a trawler to attract the market, despite the lack of rust and dead fish smells.

quote:

And while we have the attention of the boat naming experts, what is the difference between a cruiser, sport cruiser, express cruiser, and pocket cruiser? And a day cruiser?



Marketing.
IMO the name is somehow supposed to be indicative of function but we lost that battle years ago. Just try to find a condo not described by the builder as "luxury".
 
<<...."You'll notice in most of the pix above that most of the trawlers (and seiners) have flopper-stoppers (those things hanging off the outriggers). "...>>

Willie -

The Yankees call those stabilizing devices "birds", probably because of their shape. As for trawler versus seiner, the term seiner really isn't used in the northeast, whether they're pulling nets, dragging, etc, they refer to it as trawling.... (which in itself, might be technically wrong).

The confusing plot thickens.
 
quote:

Originally posted by pdecat

............... Just try to find a condo not described by the builder as "luxury".






My other boat is for sale. It's "pre enjoyed". [:-bonc01]
 
Back
Top