Too much anchor scope?

  • Thread starter Thread starter blouderback
  • Start date Start date
B

blouderback

Guest
OK, I know we're always telling each other that the reason our anchors aren't holding is because of not enough scope, that 5:1 or 7:1 or even 10:1 is desireable.

Besides too much swing, is there every a time that I can have too MUCH scope? I generally anchor in relatively shallow water, like 8-10 feet, and I generally tie off my 100' anchor line and 6' of chain at the end no matter how deep the water is. So, if I'm in 8' of water, I might have a 10:1 + scope. Is this a problem, other than the huge amount os swing I'll get?
 
The two problems that I'm aware of are swing and getting laughed at. I rarely have anything close to 7:1 and would never have 10:1 out. Where we anchor, that's just too much swing room. Partially, that's why I watch my tide charts so closely so I can have the confidence to anchor in shallower water where I can ultimatley put out less chain.

Look at it this way. If I anchor in 80 feet of water, and have to put out all 600 foot of chain, well that's a might big circle I'm throwing.

3:1 is about minimum what I put out and like to have 5. Use some good chain, and use one size up anchor and unless you expect a storm, its going to hold well.
 
If you are in a crowded anchorage area it could be.
 
swing room in a crowded anchorage is the only issue with too much scope. Or the idiot who doesn't understand the benefit of scope and motors over your rode....

What i laugh at quite a bit are the guys who make multiple attempt to set a hook with short scope and reversing too fast. always entertaining! Saw a few this week end... also saw a number of boats dragging when the wind picked up yesterday.

I had dumped another 50' of chain, probably close to 10:1 and did't move an inch.

Obviously, up in the PNW with deep waters the requirements are different, but in the typical 10/20' depth, there is no such thing as too much scope, unless you are in a crowded anchorage.
 
An easy rule of thumb, rather than calculating scope (And you have to add the distance from the water to your pulpit to the depth) Is to just make a 45 degree angle with the line. You can eyeball it. You should be fine with that. You don't have to worry about depth and you don't have to try to figure out how much rode you let out. If you were anchoring overnight or leaving your boat at anchor, of course, you would let out more.
 
A lot of scope makes for a little better sleep. The boat won't jerk near as
hard as it would if you have a short scope.
 
eyeballing the angle works when you're watching the clown from the side, but from the boat itself, it's a recipe for disaster as it's not easy to judge the angle. Also depends on how much pulling you're getting from the wind or current and how much chain you have... all will affect rode angle.

How hard is it read your sounder, add your bow height and tide and multiply by 7 ???
 
"Anchoring Follies" are always good fun to watch. The 'Anchor toss' is always the best event, where the anchor, chain & a good amount of knotted up line is thrown in some direction only to lie as a useless mess on the bottom. Why not motor up to where you want the anchor to be, lower it, then let the wind/current take the boat back. Then there is the 'Set it like a hurricane is coming' event, usually done with far too little scope, where the skipper repeatedly 'sets' the anchor with full astern power & wonders why the anchor keeps pulling out!!!!

Too much scope is good too where it is somehow believed that one is supposed to used everything in the locker, even if the water is very shallow & holding power of the bottom is good. The skipper is left wondering why others in the anchorage are invading his 'space' as he swings far & wide. I've seen one oever sandy bottom, 3' water, with 100' of line out & cursing others in the area.
 
"Anchoring Follies" are always good fun to watch. The 'Anchor toss' is always the best event, where the anchor, chain & a good amount of knotted up line is thrown in some direction only to lie as a useless mess on the bottom. Why not motor up to where you want the anchor to be, lower it, then let the wind/current take the boat back. Then there is the 'Set it like a hurricane is coming' event, usually done with far too little scope, where the skipper repeatedly 'sets' the anchor with full astern power & wonders why the anchor keeps pulling out!!!!

Too much scope is good too where it is somehow believed that one is supposed to used everything in the locker, even if the water is very shallow & holding power of the bottom is good. The skipper is left wondering why others in the anchorage are invading his 'space' as he swings far & wide. I've seen one oever sandy bottom, 3' water, with 100' of line out & cursing others in the area.
 
I watched a guy and his kid drop a ton of scope a few week ago. kid is in the bow and the anchor drops. "Dad" starts motoring in reverse as kid is watching the line feed out thru the anchor locker. I saw the end of the line hit the water. Gone.. The whole shabang.
 
Bob,
My advice would be add more chain if you've got the storage. I went from 10' to 30' of chain and it made a huge difference
 
I'm a little confused by the 45 degree angle approach.

If I'm in 7' of water, with a 3' bow for a total of 10' off the bottom, my old friend Pythagoras says I can have a 45 degree angle with 14.14' of anchor rode. I'm pretty sure that's not going to be enough even if it's all chain...
 
quote:

Originally posted by aholst1

Bob,
My advice would be add more chain if you've got the storage. I went from 10' to 30' of chain and it made a huge difference





Thanks for the tip, but I'm not having a problem. I'm just too lazy to do the math, and I just alway let out all 106' feet.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Erik

I'm a little confused by the 45 degree angle approach.

If I'm in 7' of water, with a 3' bow for a total of 10' off the bottom, my old friend Pythagoras says I can have a 45 degree angle with 14.14' of anchor rode. I'm pretty sure that's not going to be enough even if it's all chain...





Yeah, according to my math, the angle should be about 81.5°, not 45°, for a scope of 7:1.

P.S. I'm not too lazy to do the math in the office with Google at my fingertips: http://www.easycalculation.com/trigonometry/triangle-angles.php
 
boulderback,

This maybe a little off topic but what anchor or anchors are you using that require so much rode. Go for the biggest anchor you can handle with twenty feet of chain and see if that helps to reduce the amount of anchor line you put out.

Billy K.
 
yes you can have too much rode out if you are on all chain in very deep water and find yourself trying to lift nearly the entire length up from the bottom at once and its too heavy to pull it up. in that case you would want a fair amount of chain and anchor line combination which would be much lighter to lift. this would only apply to very deep water, ie over 150 feet.
 
"I generally anchor in relatively shallow water, like 8-10 feet, and I generally tie off my 100' anchor line and 6' of chain at the end no matter how deep the water is. So, if I'm in 8' of water," -- blouderbeck

First things first: In your boat, how much line out = a 1:7 scope? Remember that it is not -just- the water depth, the the water depth plus the distance from the water to the deck ( I will assume you have 2 ft above the water. Could be more ). So, in 8 ft, you need a total of 70 ft ( for 1:7 ) and in 10ft you need 84 feet. For a 1:10 scope, the numbers are, 100ft and 120 ft.

So, you actually have very little extra rode out, and in most cases you are between a 1:7 and 1:10 scope. ie: By accident, you are doing it right.

--

But back to the other question, "can you have too much scope"? If you ask me while I am hauling in, by hand, 250 ft of rode when I really only needed 100 ft, the answer would be, "Yes." Ditto the answer vic33004 gave: with all chain, how much can you lift? But from a sheer holding standpoint more is better. Just remember that there are tradeoffs with scope, such as swing room and lifting capacity of the anchor wench.

If your anchor wench is unusually attractive, you may need to let out 300, 400 or even 500 ft of rode. Your call.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Veebyes

"Anchoring Follies" are always good fun to watch. The 'Anchor toss' is always the best event, where the anchor, chain & a good amount of knotted up line is thrown in some direction only to lie as a useless mess on the bottom. Why not motor up to where you want the anchor to be, lower it, then let the wind/current take the boat back. Then there is the 'Set it like a hurricane is coming' event, usually done with far too little scope, where the skipper repeatedly 'sets' the anchor with full astern power & wonders why the anchor keeps pulling out!!!!






That always amazes me - what do they think they will accomplish by throwing the anchor???
 
quote:

Originally posted by HOGAN

[That always amazes me - what do they think they will accomplish by throwing the anchor???





And yet how many times have you seen the phrase "toss out an anchor"?

On a recent episode of ShipShape TV, one of the staff was observed "tossing" an anchor.

To the OP - No you cannot have too much as long as there's nothing to swing into but you can certainly put out more than you need. At some point, more rode does no more good.
 
When I was a kid, my dad had a 25' Trojan. We used to go claming in a shallow bay most weekends. One trip, we took my aunt, uncle and cousins. We got over the sandbar, dad tells my uncle to put out the anchor, which he does, then all the menfolk proceed to get in the water to clam. The women stay on the boat and crab. All is going well until the wind shifts, and we, in the water, notice the boat moving farther and farther away from us. My dad asks my uncle if he put out the anchor, to which he replies yes. Dad then asked how much rode he put out to which he repiles "all of it". Dad carried about 400' of heavy nylon rode and I don't know how much chain. The boat is now swinging in a circle with a 400' radius, and its being carried off the sandbar into deeper water. We are in the water all swimming as hard as we can to catch the boat as no one onboard knows how to run the boat. I can tell you that the wind was moving the boat away from us faster than we could catch up to it. We all looked like six million dollar man running in slow motion trying to catch that boat. What saved the day was a shift in the wind that brought the boat to us, or I think we would still be trying to catch that boat. So to answer Bobs' question, there are times when more scope is a bad thing.
 
Back
Top