Trim Tab Question. Need an Engineer?

David M

Active member
Member
Joined
Mar 5, 2005
RO Number
16492
Messages
7,393
We have almost solved the trim tab wiring issues in this thread: "LINK"

I have a question about the shape of the tab itself. Saint Max and other 330's I have seen on the hard have tabs shaped sort of like this:

-----------
|
|



Sorry, can't do pix from here.

This would be the port tab looking at the boat from the stern.

I have seen newer Sea Ray's with flat tabs and older Wellcraft with flat tabs.

I was wondering if the 90* down angle is a help or a hinderence to effeciency. In that I am adding an extension to my tabs, would I be better served having the 90* bend lessened to say 45* or 60* like this:



' -----------
'/
/


Or should I remove it altogether.

I spoke to tabman many moons ago. He told me the new (then) Sport Tab system's design gave 16% greater lift than a flat tab. The sport tab has a 90* down bend on each side of the tab and a slight up angle (don't know how many degrees) from the center. The 90* down angle when viewed from the side looks like a 30/60/90 triangle with the short leg aft, the long leg parallel the tab chord and the 30* angle of the hypoteneuse forward and the 60* angle aft and down.

I know from reading an article on the MY Mephistopholes many years ago that what works for little boats will not necessarily apply on bigger boats.

In that Saint Max will be on the hard and the extensions are going on regardless, what say you gurus regarding the best bang for the buck at the welding shop?

Any and all comments welcome.

TIA
 
Gee I dunno Dave. The angle would add stiffness and stability to the tab. Looks like it should help direct flow but I'm not so sure what that would accomplish. It may add a modicum of direction/steering/alignment.

I always assumed the bigger the boat, the bigger the tabs had to be to affect trim.
 
It's akin to putting winglets on aircraft. It will help stop flow around the edge of the tab, more water making the trip down the tab, more mass (water = mass) deflected, more trim force for same deflection of the tab.
I would guess a 45 degree edge would be the biggest bang for the buck, but tabman probably would have test data, you really need data to determine it.
 
the 90 deg bend is also there to make the tab stiffer.
 
This is called a DROP FIN.

Several years ago before I did the diesel refit I took all of my running data to the Ft Lauderdale boart show and spent some time with an engineer from Bennett. He looked at all of my data, GPS sog, RPMs, knots and tab applied.

We determined that the vessel was a$$ heavy from a running angle standpoint and we replaced the 9" flat tabs with new 12" tabs with drop fins.

These tabs were direct bolt in replacements and increased the total amount of lift by nearly 50%

The new data showed a marked increase in effeciency at the sweet spot cruise RPM and gave me an additional 1.5 kts average increase.

The most interesting note is that now after the refit, the tabs have no effect on increasing kts per hour at any given engine RPM.

Of course, they still can adjust the running angle to compensate for choppy seas, etc but no increase in effeciency as before.

What IS apparent is that with the diesels, and the larger props, her a$$ end is running correctly and the whole boat has a better running angle than before.

A side note is that perhaps those tabs made such a difference because the 454's were a bit on the tired side.

33' vessel with a 13' beam.

Hope this helps.

RWS
 
That helps a lot RWS. Thanks.

I spent about 22 hours in Newark Airport on Friday and Saturday and examined the winglest on different jets. They appear to differ by plane type. The angle goes from 90* on the larger jets to about 60* on the smaller business type jets. I'll take a swag and see how it works. As you eluded, I am sure the length of the tab is going to do more than anything else.
 
the legnth of the tab is important, however the "drop fins" keep the water from sliding out the sides, thereby increasing the amount of upward pressure or lift on the tab as compared to a standard flat tab.

RWS
 
Water is much different than air. I am an areo-engineer, the angles on the sides will have an affect, can't say the right angle is right, like I said, I would guess, 45 degrees would stiffen the tabs, and keep the water in to the tab, not going around the sides.
 
i think the salient issue is whether the fins are parralell with the water flow in your particular application. if they are, then the lift should be increased with their installation over and above the marginal drag, if not the additional lift may or may not offset by the additional drag.
 
We are a$$ heavy, and I added the 90 kit to our 12's. Ordered from B-fx. for about $45, and it made a huge difference getting the boat up and running at lower rpm's on plane. If you go this route, be aware that the tabs are hard to drill for the side plates, so make sure you have a few extra drill bits, when you do this.
 
Back
Top