TWIC Card?

Don't fight the problem. You need to get this redundant idiotic TWIC card.

Also, it is absolutly good for nothing at this point. Went into Anapolis, the Airport, Station NY USCG and tried to use it as an ID. Every one of them looked at me like I was showing them a bubble gum card and demanded other ID.
 
Don't try to enter the Ports of Mobile, New Orleans, Gulfport, Baton Rouge, Fourchon or Houston with out it.
 
Capt Bill 1 is correct. If you hold a USCG lic or creditial is will not be valid without a TWIC card on 4/15/09. You cannot renew your lic(every five years0 without the TWIC card. Bottom line, if you wish to keep a USCG ticket you must have a TWIC. They are in fact starting to ask for the card, even though 4/15/09 is not here yet.

This limbo stuff is a wish it were so thing. The purpose of a USCG ticket is for carrying passengers for hire. Regardless of wheter you carry passengers for hire or not that is its intended purpose. As of 4/15/09 you must have a TWIC to have a valid USCG ticket.

John
 
So.... you guys that are not buying into the Limbo thing.....

what happens to your ticket on April 15th if you don't have a TWIC?
what happens to your ticket if, let's say, you get the TWIC on May 15th?

What state was your ticket in during the time between April 15 and May 15th....... void, invalid, inactive, limbo?

It's very similar to the time between the 5year renewal date and the 1 year grace period.....you can't use it to carry paying passengers, but you have to do some paper work to make it active again.

If you are carrying passengers for hire, you need the TWIC by April 15th. No where does it say that you have to carry passengers for hire if you have a ticket.
 
I have to show my TWIC to get on any helicopter to fly offshore.
I have to show it again to be able to go on a platform or rig unescorted.
I have shown it at airports instead of my drivers license with no issue.
I did it just to see how it would work out. TSA knows what a TWIC is.

Like L. Keith says, not only those ports, but every port on the coastin La.
and Tx. are not letting anyone on their ports without one, unless you have
an escort/sponsor.
 
quote:

Originally posted by dominic

No where does it say that you have to carry passengers for hire if you have a ticket.






It DOES, however, say that if you have a ticket you must have a TWIC.
 
"If you are carrying passengers for hire, you need the TWIC by April 15th. No where does it say that you have to carry passengers for hire if you have a ticket."

Your right, if you're are not and will not be using your license, then no, I guess you don't need to get a TWIC card. But you license is not in a state of limbo. It's basicaly no good.

And remember, many times insurance companies demand you have a current license to run or deliver a larger boat. So you may need it for more than just carrying passengers.

But hey, do what ever you want. As far as I'm concerned, the TWIC thing may be a good deal. If for no other reason than it may weed out some of the hobbyists in this industry.
 
USCG told me that no, they will not revoke any ticket due to not having the TWIC card. Not in the first year after April 15 anyway. I asked very specifically, and they answered very specifically (after being pushed for a clear answer). Said they put that in there just to scare people into going on and getting it. Just like they told people a TWIC center may close down at any time, requiring travel to another TWIC center some distance away. Just a tactic used to encourage people to go on and get the TWIC.

Clearly, if you want your ticket, you have to get the TWIC. IF you use the ticket for work. But there are plenty of captains out there that have it because they wanted to get it, not because they need it for their work. Those guys can't renew at 5 years without the TWIC. But they certainly don't need to rush out and hand the government $132 right this minute. Just apply for it 6 months before your renewal is due.

What a bunch of hogwash this TWIC program is. Require it for guys that need port access. NOT for every licensed mariner. I'd bet the number of captains that need it vs those that do not is huge. Like was said, 90% of it is a money thing. A bill was introduced to get rid of the requirement for those that don't need secure access, but last I heard, the senator that introduced the bill (Coleman) was fighting over his re-election. And the co-sponsor from my state lost her re-election bid (Dole). So for now sounds like we're stuck. And with no strong, organized voice speaking out for captains, we'll probably be stuck for a good while.

JB
 
I was told my the USCG that if I don't get a TWIC by April, my license was no longer valid.
I was told by the company that I fly with that I have to have a TWIC offshore.
I was told by my company that if I am a permanent offshore employee, I have to have a TWIC.
I have to have my license to keep my job.
I got my TWIC, with much difficulty. The Lockeed Martin employees I dealt with are very dumb.
If the USCG told you that you do not need a TWIC, I would ask someone higher than who you asked.
 
I applied for the TWIC card last week, except for the $132 cost, it was relatively quick and painless...
 
I just read the info on the TSA Site. This is not even close from a security standpoint aa to what they need. My Dept of Defense ID card does more and that ain't a lot compared to the potential. It appears they gave a computer wonk the term biometrics and the person ran with it from an IT perspective as opposed to an ID (identification) perspective.

I would like to say it's a start, however, the technology they are using is antique.

Rommer was right. Follow the money.
 
rduhon, if you need it, get it. But if you don't need it for your work, and you just have a captain's lics because you just wanted to get one, like I suspect a whole bunch of captains out there have, then all I'm saying is you don't have to hustle out there and worry about getting it before April 15th. Which wouldn't happen now anyway. It does take a few days/weeks to get one.

Again, what a bunch of BS. I'd guess that most captains in the US are charter boat captains. And most of those have no need whatsoever for port access. To require ALL captains to get this TWIC, as opposed to just those that need port access, is nothing more than a money grab. And we as captains have no group or organization that can really speak up politically for us. So we get stuck.

JB
 
TWIC has nothing to do with port security. It is the beginning of a federal government ID program. Just wait and see...
 
quote:

Originally posted by Capn Tony

TWIC has nothing to do with port security. It is the beginning of a federal government ID program. Just wait and see...






NUHN UHHH. I read it on the internet. On a government site. They said it was for security. Are you saying our government lies?
 
quote:

Originally posted by Capn Tony

TWIC has nothing to do with port security. It is the beginning of a federal government ID program. Just wait and see...






I believe we have those already. They're called a SS# and a passport.
 
All you nay sayers are about two to three years too late with all the comments. I would suggest you guys do a better job of keeping up with current events within the marine community if you want your opinion to matter. From what I've read here I'd guess some of you folks get up every morning and scan the horizon for Black Helicopters and wear tin foil hats at night.
 
I got mine. I have nothing to hide.
If the gov't wants to see my TWIC,
they just have to ask.
I am not scared of the gov't. But
I do have issues with how they
spend my tax money.
 
L Keith, no, I tried my best to do something about TWIC. Called Coleman and Dole's office when I found out about their bill. Called NACO. Posted a bunch on boards around the country trying to drum up support against the TWIC required for ALL captains. It just seemed captains were not very interested in fighting it. Everyone (well, far and away the majority) said they were against it unless it was needed for their work. Most of those that needed it for work were OK with it for the most part. But I could see no way to confront TWIC with any type of organized effort. I truly believe it's due to the fact we do not have any kind of association to represent the interest of captains. We tend to be an indepenent sort, and I think that hurts us politically. I even tried to get the database of all captains from USCG, in order to try to contact captains directly to ask if they had an interest in fighting TWIC (again, just the requirement for ALL captains to have to get it.

So... no, I didn't just suddenly decide TWIC was a bad thing. You shouldn't just keep up with events in the marine community, you should jump in and try to help to change things. I hope you did in the case of TWIC. And BTW, it's never to late to seek and promote change.

JB
 
Regulations.gov

There are lots of ANPRMs and NPRMs that invite reasonable, professional, public comment. Those comments become part of the permanent public record in a related docket, and those comments must be addressed in subsequent rule makings.

Folks truly do get the government they deserve. The system does work, but most people prefer to watch Paris Hilton on TV, rather than take responsibility for helping to guide regulations affecting them. Every person, business association and business interest can have their say, no matter how small. Uncle Sam wants to hear from you, but few are willing to place professional comments in the rule making docket. Very odd, but true.

As a professional captain myself, I kinda like TWIC. It constitutes a barrier to entry into marine related businesses for many folks with "issues", or who refuse to obtain a TWIC. We all learned about supply and demand in High School right? Hence, I suspect the long term wage effect will be positive for TWIC holders...look at the maritime help wanted ads...MUST HAVE A TWIC CARD, is prominantly featured in many of them.

Hummm, I wonder what effect this is having on maritime related wages?
 
There are groups and organizations that re[resents Capatains. Depending on what areas you use your ticket for you will find local,state and national groups. If you are not gainfully employed as a capatain you don.t need rpresentation?

NACCO is a Charter Boat Captains organization, one of many that did in fact speak out against the need for all Captains to have a TWIC. Several members of Congress were in fact sympatheic to the argument, as was part of Homeland Security. The deal breaker was the USCG.

Personally, as one who makes his living as Capt., I am not as concerned about the TWIC, as those of you who do not work in the Industry.

John
 
Back
Top