USCG Boarding....loooong

firepiper

Member
exMember
Joined
Aug 7, 2006
RO Number
22740
Messages
148
Hello all. So I've been boating for 25 years, up until the last two, as a rec boater. Now I have my lic and have been doing charters etc. Never ben boarded by th CG. Yesterday, boarded. Very nice crew, seemed very 'by the book', as the crew read from a little book as to what I was to have on the boat, pfd's, placards ext, etc. It was not a charter,but, just me and two friends out fishing. At the end, the LT. asked if I had any boating education. I replied, 'yes, I hold a 100gt masters lic." All went well, an he told me I was the most squared away boat he'd been on in quite a while
So, I'm telling another friend about it last night, and he said I got off easy cause I was in the bay, and not in federal waters. I said why? He tells me the CG is much more stringent in federal waters. I don't understand. I was in Cape Cod Bay, inside the boundary line. My friend says they can only enforce state regs there. I think thi is BS. Thier juristiction goes up to a quartermile inland of the coast, I think. This guy i a Captain as well, with a lot of time on the h2o.
What else would they want? Everything is/was above and beyond regs, for both rec and coastwise.
Please chime in if you have any info. Thanks, Mark
 
You got off easy because you were polite and squared away. Had you been sloppy and missing stuff, it might have gone differently.

There is no difference in how a boarding is conducted depending on the waterway area that I know of. Mike can clarify. And according to the new rules Obama put into place, all waters are federal waters. Even your bathtub...
 
Actually, they cannot enforce state regs at all. Certain categories of vessel, such as documented fishing vessels, may require additional equipment when operating a certain distance beyond the boundary line, but all of the laws and regulations that the CG enforce are federal laws.

There are some state regulations that directly effect federal regulation, however. The age at which children are required to wear PFD's is a great example - the federal regulations, under certain conditions, incorporate by reference the age specified in the state regs for vessels operating within that state's waters.

Out of curiosity, how long did the boarding take?
 
a couple of months ago, i was also boarded for the first time in almost 30 years. took less than 10 minutes, they didnt' even asked us to stop (we were in the ICW by Port Everglades havign just picked up charter guests in FLL). Naomi took the helm, a couple of them stayed up on the flybrdige filling out the boarding report while i took the other two guys downstairs to show them the placards, fire bottles, and sealed holding tank sea cock.

painless process.

never heard that USCG woudl enforce the rules differently offshore or inland... makes no sense.

Mike, BTW did you get me email? are you on the island?
 
CG only enforce federal regulations. 4100 boardings all follow the same procedure regardless of the waterway.
 
About 15 years ago I was with my wife and a couple of her visiting family members on board our 36' Trojan crossing the Chesapeake from the mouth of the Potomac to the eastern shore of Maryland. Smack in the middle of the Bay I notice a vessel is closing dead on my bow and every time I eased off to starboard he altered course to keep dead aim on me. He gets closer and its a USCG cutter in the 50' range - the loud hailer comes on and the voice sez "This is the United States Coast Guard - heave to Captain. We are going to board you!" In light of the fact that there was Coastie standing behind a 20mm cannon on the forward deck of the USCG vessel and aimed squarely at me, I by god hove to right smartly. One crew member boarded, asked to see my federal documentation and some personal I.D. and he informed me that as part of specially assigned U.S. Customs duties, he is going to inspect my vessel for drugs. I told him the vessel was at his pleasure and he went below and commenced to looking in every cabinet and storage space on board. Now, the I.D. I had handed him was my US Army ID card as I was still active duty at the time and I sat on the bridge during his 30 minute inspection noticing that his vessel had backed away about 50 yards but the cannon on the forward deck never wavered from my vessel.
He comes back above, hands me my documentation and ID, politely thanks me and his vessel slides up to my starboard beam (cannon still aimed pretty much right at my forehead). He steps off and away they go.

That's the only time I have been boarded by the USCG and I started boating in the 1960's in Miami. They weren't rude, but I do sort of think the cannon pointing was a bit much - 28 years in the Army and I had all kinds of bad stuff pointed at me, but not by my own side!

All in all, I think the Coasties are professional, whereas the local, especially county, water enforcement pukes are purely revenue raisers and most of them are surly and some not even aware of their own damned laws. A Stafford, Virginia county cop tried to tell me I had to have my vessel registerd in Virginia, even though I was active duty military. I explained to him that federal law says differently and it was only after his older partner agreed with me that he backed off - but then had the gall to tell me that he was watching me carefully so I better not step out of line. Jay-sus! A good hard backhand across his mouth is what he deserved, but he had the badge and gun, so I had to just put up with it.
 
Wil: I think he was right for registered vessels. They are supposed to be registered in the state of primary use. And if the state of primary use requires documented vessels to be registered, then you have to comply.
 
Nope - Soldier's and Sailor's Civil Relief Act of 1940 states that active duty military are exempt from local state, county and city, registration and license requirements for automobiles, vessels and aircraft while they are on active duty and stationed in a state other than their state of residence. The boat was registered in my home state, Florida, and was displaying a current decal as well.

This is the same law that prevents states from imposing state income taxes on military pay of military folks that are stationed in that state pusuant to military orders.
 
I am completely against these boardings....what next - Fire department checking my smoke alarms and fire extinguishers in the middle of the night? Police entering my home at will to verify my guns are properly stored?

Enlighten me on the difference.
 
quote:

Originally posted by two_rocks

I am completely against these boardings....what next - Fire department checking my smoke alarms and fire extinguishers in the middle of the night? Police entering my home at will to verify my guns are properly stored?

Enlighten me on the difference.






Or the state requiring a safety inspection of your car every year...
 
And charging you for the inspection...

Wil: I was reading in the Federal requirements for boaters manual to get that point. However, it did not mention active duty military exemptions. So I cant argue against your point.
 
rwilhite

Just an opinion, but normally the deck gun is manned, and aimed "in the vicinity of but not at" the vessel being boarded. This changes, in sure, with the nature of the mission. If your vessel meets the "profile of a smuggling vessel", and you are in an area with smuggling issues, I would not be surprised if that deck remained trained on the helmsman.

My experience with such boardings goes back many years and my father's boat fell into the category of "a vessel commonly used in smuggling operations". We were boarded, more than once, and all such boardings were "crisp and by the book", and the deck gun was fixed on the helmsman ( ahem, uh, me ). To me, this is understandable, if unnerving.

From a LEO standpoint, every stop is a "take down" that halts if things are "normal". There is ( and should be ) very little or no difference in the approach of a suspicious vessel and the approach of "an innocent vessel". The procedure is designed to grasp full control at first contact, and to maintain that control till the session is complete. As disturbing as this may be to some, it does appear to the the safest method overall.

I am an honest person, but I am also, at times, a control freak. I do not like having control wrested from my hands. With the above procedure, while I may chafe a bit, I will comply without hesitation. If such a boarding were handled differently, I might be tempted to argue, complain, or otherwise become difficult. Even though I am honest, and not breaking the law. Such actions on my part might necessitate far greater "compulsion" on the part of the LEO, and greatly increase the hazard level of the event. This is undesirable, and unsafe. The other way is better than a "kid gloves" approach.
 
I could not find a reference in the SCRA that pertains to vessel registration being exepmted. Can you help me out here?
 
When I fished offshore, I was boarded by USCG and they told me when the inspection
was finished to document who boarded me, the date, and the boat they came off of.
He said next time a USCG hails me and asks for my boats name, my name, address and
phone number, it should be recorded and they probably won't board me again, without
probable cause.
It worked several times that year. I just gave the info. about the boat and myself,
what we were doing, where we went and where we were going and then I repeated the
info. about who and when I was boarded and they didn't board me at all for the rest
of the year.
 
"And according to the new rules Obama put into place, all waters are federal waters. Even your bathtub..."

Site please. Does this mean my rudder ducky needs to be documented now?
 
It's nothing official but if you have a current year Coast Guard Auxiliary Vessel Safety Exam Decal on your boat, Coast Guard and local authorities will usually go after someone else, unless you are doing something wrong. You should also hang on to the 4100 form they give you and show that the next time and they will usually move on.
 
quote:

Originally posted by MichaelNJ

It's nothing official but if you have a current year Coast Guard Auxiliary Vessel Safety Exam Decal on your boat, Coast Guard and local authorities will usually go after someone else, unless you are doing something wrong. You should also hang on to the 4100 form they give you and show that the next time and they will usually move on.






Just because it's worth repeating.
 
I got boarded last year because they though my chum line hanging over was a string of Stripers. Then they proceeded to cut my line with $20 worth of braid and a $35 Umbrella
rig. Nice.... Thanks for nothing.
 
Mike, it took maybe 20 minutes, very thorough, pfds, flares, fire ext, placards, poop tank valve, paperwork, blower, horn, hin. Very polite crew. The LT. told me the same thing you just reposted, keep the form handy and I will probably not be bothered unless I'm doing something obviously wrong. Are they supposed to give me a sticker? Thanks
 
Back
Top