VHF Squelch problem

Captain Crunch

Member
exMember
Joined
Oct 17, 2001
RO Number
6460
Messages
85
Approx. 3 yrs ago, I upgraded (or downgraded) my VHF with a Std. Horizon Quest. When first installed, was somewhat concerned that the squelch needed to be turned to about mid point for normal operations, which was not the case with the VHF I replaced. Now, on clear days it has to be turned all the way and still not filtering out noise (busy). I contacted Std. Horizon and they were of little help advising me to try an alternate antenna and if not fixed, send in the unit along with $65. (not impressed with their service). This is difficult as I don't have a second antenna on this boat and the problem isn't present at my slip location. Any ideas what could be causing this?

cc
 
Making an assumption that the radio is functioning within specs ( a reasonable assumption ), then the cause of the open squelch is RF noise.

The question is, "What is the source?"

Is the channel actually constantly in use? Does the problem occur on all channels? Does it occur regardless of your boat's location? Do the symptoms change when you cycle electric items aboard on then off? Is the antenna in the direct path of the radar? ( or above it... )

Odds are, that when you answer the above questions, the problem will become self-evident.
 
Bill,
I believe the VHF is picking up distant signals from all over instead of filtering out the weak transmissions. The radar was not in operation, was using the chartplotter/auto pilot and did not try shutting it down. I don't believe it was an issue on other channels. this occurred for long periods of time over multiple days so I'm confident its not caused by some idiot with an open mike. The only place it doesn's seem to be happening is in my slip, wierd, but, could be that its sheltered from distant signals. In pulling into my marina yesterday I noticed it improving the closer to the marina I got.
cc
 
This time of the year there is an effect called tropo ducting. This last weekend Thursday through Monday from New Jersey we were able to receive stations as far away as North Carolina and as far north as Boston. Usually the signals are strong enough the squelch fully closed won't blank many of these signals. Then again you could have a problem with your radio but it could be overload from strong stations out of band I just don't know where you boat but coastal tropo ducting happens quite often this time of year and it usually needs a stagnant high pressure weather system combined with heat during the day and cool air at night. Regards Bill
 
Another question... do you get the same response when the engine is turned off?

Try adding a toroid to the antenna and DC supply line close to the VHF radio. Radio Shack sells a two pack for $8.39. Just wrap the wire around it a 6 or 7 times and see what happens.

Joe

Snap-Together Toroid Choke Core-2-Pack $8.39
Model: RF Choke | Catalog #: 273-104

Cut down on RFI (radio frequency interference) with this snap-together Toroid Choke Core.
 
Well, it is likely that it is a signal coming through the antenna, though shielding the power supply would not hurt...

It could be:

Tropo ducting as described by BillyIII

Your ( or a neighbor's ) handheld is on, and they are sitting on it. ( or in the Captain's bag, on and xmitting )

Someone, anywhere within 12 - 15 miles, has a stuck mic switch.

It could be that there is greater VHF usage during the weather you describe. This translates into greater VHF usage, including over-the-horizon, and a much higher "background noise level". In this case is is no one point source, but the sum of the scattered signals over a very large area ( much of it out of useful range )
 
I dont think this is exactly the same, but I had a similar problem on my last boat. I'd get noise that was nearly impossible to squelch some days. It was often accompanied by a ticking noise (approx 1/sec). One day I was down in my engine compartment and I heard that same damn ticking pattern.....traced it to the depth sounder transducer (yes it was turned on). The pattern was identical to the radio interference/squelch issue. So I went up to the bridge, turned on the radio and there was that squelch problem. Turned off the depth sounder, squelch and ticking problem solved. I dont know exactly what caused the interference. It was intermittent and didnt happen every time the 2 units were turned on. But shutting down the ds always fixed the radio squelch......sold the boat....lol
 
Keep in mind how squelch works. It is not a filter. Rather it is a volume sensitive switch that disables your speaker until the received audio exceeds a set level. Your squelch knob sets this level. The system does not filter distant versus near sources; any audio signal which exceeds the threshold will enable the speaker (commonly referred to as "breamking squelch").

Note that squelch operates on the detected audio, not the received RF power. So, in theory, a strong but unmodulated signal would not break squelch. However, any electrical noise source on your boat which induced audio noise into your radio might do so. This is probably how your depth sounder caused problems.

Things you might try would be to try different frequencies (it is unlikely that an RF noise source would effect multiple frequencies), try turning off every electronic device on your boat (include battery charger, stereo, refrigerator and navigation systsm), try different locations (the problem getting better as you near your marina may be a good clue).

Mike
 
quote:

Originally posted by Billylll

This time of the year there is an effect called tropo ducting.





Hey Bill!

Thanks for that. I've been wondering for the past few years why my back-up Standard Horizon VHF (handheld, mounted in the cockpit) does this behavior every year around this time. I crank the squelch up full, and it still gives bursts of audio every few moments. But all other times of the year it's fine.

To the OP: My main VHF is also a SH. It does not replicate this behavior. Perhaps Bill might have some input as to whether that antenna question is relevant. I've always been impressed with SH customer service, so I don't think they'd steer you wrong.
 
I always thought that it was the presence of IF noise that activated an FM squelch circuit, and the lack of noise that opened it. ( In which case, a key-down mike with no sound would open the receiver's squelch ).

I'll need to review the topic...
 
Kurt, the antenna solution is not necessarily a poor response.

If the problem is tropo ducting, then switching to an antenna with a different sensitivity pattern may cure it. It is also a clever way for tech support to solve a poor connector issue: By changing the antenna, you replace the connector, too. If you had a loose or corroded connector ( possible culprit ), the act of changing the antenna would solve the problem. And since they sell antennas...
 
I wish there was a way to filter out the Ham Ops.....we monitor channel 68 at our marina...and there are about 6 that must have scooted out of the 2 meter band....and use this like a CB radio every morning starting at 0430. From listenting to their coversaion they are located about 40 miles apart and chatter about nothing...and this isn't from the ducting....it happens all year round
 
Barren...file a complaint with the FCC. If they are operating out of band the little mobile van will drive up to their house and confiscate their equipment. Seen that happen around here already when they thought 22a was a nice place to chat.
 
I seriously doubt any true licensed ham would bother using VHF marine channel 68 when we can operate from 144Mhz to 148Mhz legally. Yes I am a ham operator call sign AA2UK. Regards Bill
 
Kurt and all yes upgrading his antenna wouldn't hurt if it is more than a few years old. Squelch opens when a certain level (level set by the squelch control) of signal audio or no audio is detected in the IF stages of a FM receiver.
 
All,
thanks for this input. Billy, how long should a quality Shakespere antenna last before replacing?
 
How long would a good Shakespere antenna last? Depends on many factors, are you in salt water, has the antenna ever hit anything and is the connector falling off or the cable chaffed from a substandard installation? My guess would be 5 years in a corrosive environment. You can have the antenna tested by purchasing a tester from Shakesphere, use a Bird watt meter with the proper slug (the best method) or use a VHF rated SWR meter. If you have good equipment you could do a return loss on the antenna anything better than 13db would be good.
 
I have that problem too. All I have to do to "fix" it is to adjust the gain on my fishfinder. If the gain is too strong, it interferes with my VHF radio.
 
Back
Top