Whale Wars

PeteMrrs

Active member
Member
Joined
Apr 7, 2001
RO Number
4125
Messages
1,060
Anybody else been following this series on Animal Planet?

I believe that Paul Watson and his crew are giving a whole new name to eco-terrorist. He is so far off the wall that he was voted out of GreenPeace on a 13 to 1 vote, with his vote being the 1.

One thing is obvious as you watch, he puts the lives of the whales above those of his own crew.

Somebody should pull his Captains License.
 
I'm not convinced that he cares about the whales. I am convinced that he cares about the publicity and the funding.
 
Exactly and I think the ships would be more than justified in whatever drastic measures they take against piracy, including, especially, sinking the low lifes.

I do not approve in any way of whaling. There is no need for it anymore, even for some mysterious religious reasond. There just is no need any more. But this is the wrong way to make a point.

Letters, snail mail, will be going to Discovery and to all the sponsors of this abbomination of a TV show. As lomg as it is on, Discovery and all of their (sponsors) products are out of my house.
 
quote:

Originally posted by PeteMrrs

He is so far off the wall that he was voted out of GreenPeace on a 13 to 1 vote, with his vote being the 1.






I didn't think such a thing was possible.
 
I was really shocked Discovery appears to advocate such actions. These guys are pirates and liars. I am shocked they'd be so candid to the Discovery camera crew explaining their efforts to create an international crisis and blatant lying about "hostages".

I want my 30 minutes back.
 
If anyone ever tried to board my boat as they did I'd hit them in the head with a bat! I think they are fully justified in shooting these people.
 
Watson does make an interesting comparison in one episode, in Africa they shoot elephant poachers. All Sea Shepard is doing is harassing "whale poachers".
 
Capt. Bill states; ". . . All Sea Shepard is doing is harassing "whale poachers".

IF "harassing" includes; Throwing objects on to the decks of boats causing the crew to slip, risking injury or possibly falling overboard into ice cold water . Attempting to purposely disable a vessel,causing it to drift at peril in ice infested water, or illegally trying to board a vessel. Then I believe that the Captain of that vessel has the right to do what-ever is necessary to repel all boarders.

This ship appears to be a crew of misfits. A Captain who is willing to risk human life no matter what. A First Mate who does not appear to have a clue how to handle any situation and a crew of young naive kids who think they are doing the right thing, but are being used as pawns.

I wish Steve Erwin was alive to give us his thoughts on having his name attached to this program.
 
"Then I believe that the Captain of that vessel has the right to do what-ever is necessary to repel all boarders."

Sure. Just like the Elephant poachers shoot back. :-)

And yeah, the Sea Shepard ship seems to be run like a CF that's for sure.

But back to his point. Why is it considered OK to kill some types of poachers but over board or out of bounds to harass or even endanger others?

"I wish Steve Erwin was alive to give us his thoughts on having his name attached to this program."

His wife gave her blessing. So I doubt he'd have a problem with it. And the whales are being taken in an area that the Aussy goverment has declared a no whaling zone from what I understand.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Capt. Bill1

"

But back to his point. Why is it considered OK to kill some types of poachers but over board or out of bounds to harass or even endanger others?






What poaching? Hunting Whales as the Japanese are doing is still legal isn't it? It's the Sea Shepard that is violating the law. Not liking what they do is not a right to board them? That's Piracy
 
Read my whole post Art.

Like I said, it's my understanding that the Japanese are hunting in areas that are declared off limits to whaling by the Aussy government. (Hence I believe the ships name "Steve Erwin".) And the Japanese have been using the excuse of doing "whale research" to kill whale species that are endangered for food for decades.

Not saying I agree with all the methods that Sea Shepard uses. But harsh words rarely gets much response from "criminals" and governments. Nor focuses any media attention on the problem.
 
Next thing you know someone will brandish a beer can and then we can all agree this is dangerous stuff.
 
Are they in "INTERNATIONAL" waters or Aussy waters???If it's Aussy waters, why isn't the Australian Navy out there. If it's international, what right does Australia have to declare it off limits. Two wrongs STILL don't make a right and the pirates need to be sunk on sight.

But two Wrights did make an airplane.
 
"Are they in "INTERNATIONAL" waters or Aussy waters???"

Ah, there's the rub. I beleive Australia claims those waters as their own. But Japan does not recognize that claim.

But there is no getting around it, Japan has been breaking and or ignoring national and international bans on whaling for decades.

"Two wrongs STILL don't make a right and the pirates need to be sunk on sight."

Yes. But just who are the pirates here? Those doing the poaching? Or those trying to stop it?

I'm willing to bet a lot of people here would be singing a different tune if the Japanese were coming into US territorial waters and defying a US fishing ban.
 
Extremist in any form is bad news, however, the Japanese eat anything that swims and has gills. They take sharks for their fins and return the fin less sharks to the water to die. Fin soup anyone?
 
Bill:

If the Japanesse are breaking Austrailian law, then I would expect the Aussie Government to step in and take some action. If they are breaking International law then I would expect the International community to handle it through sanctions or what-ever means they felt needed. I'm not sure who gave Paul Watson any authority to enforce the law.

I know this is a television show and as such is highly edited to convey what the producers want it to show, but in the few episodes that I have watched, I have seen the Sea Shepard's Captain put four of his crew members in the frigid waters attempting a foolish stunt, "lost" another four members in a zodiac at night and had two crew members unlawfully board a vessel and then report it as a kidnapping. Not the actions I would expect from a responsible Captain.

As much as I believe in the cause, IMO this man should not be held up as a spokeman.

BTW; I'm not sure Steve Erwin's wife, Mindy's motives are the same as his would have been.
 
Why didn't the fishing boat just do a zig zag pattern? That would have capsized the inflatable if it got too close?
 
In one of the episodes the narrator states that most legal experts agree that what the Japanese are doing is legal according to the current regulations and agreements. While everyone knows the idea of the Japanese doing 'research' on these whales is a joke and they all end up going to market, I believe they do get their yearly 'research' quota according to international whaling agreements. Given that the comparison of shooting poachers breaks down, assuming the poachers are being pursued by law enforcement authorities operating under clearly defined laws. The 'Sea Shepards' is basically a freelance group with no legal authority trying to enforce their own beliefs and a questionable interpretation of the law.

To me this is the same as PETA deciding protests and media campaigns aren't enough and they start sending boats out to harass and attempt to disable commercial and recreational fishing fleets that are operating within their rights and following regulations. I was imagining what I would feel like if I was trolling for tuna 100 miles out and had a similar group throwing chemical bombs at my boat, trying to foul my props and come aboard. Thinking of it that way I think the Japanese showed a lot of restraint in not doing more, and for Paul then to say they took 'hostages' after they were boarded is ridiculous.

If they thought this show would be good for their cause I'd have to say they are wrong in my view. I found myself rooting for the Japanese whalers by the second episode... The SS captain and long time crew seem to have no regard for the safety of the rest of the crew, who are basically a bunch of kids who didn't realize what they were getting themselves into. They are playing very dangerous games trying to disable ships in Antarctic waters, I would definitely put them in the eco-terrorist category.

John
 
Back
Top