What should be differences between 2 prop sizes?

RM

Member
Joined
Jan 1, 2000
RO Number
468
Messages
325
What differences (speed, fuel burn, etc) would one expect between 2 different prop sizes?

Prop sizes in question are:

18 x 21 - 3 blade cupped

18 x 23 - 3 blade cupped

Boat in question is a 31' Tiara with Crusader 454s.

At WOT I get up to about 4050 rpm. Rated is around 4200 so I'm about 200 under.

The boat has 18 x 23 and the factory spec sheet shows 18 x 21. What differences would this make at criuise speeds? I am getting around 22kts at 3000 rpm, which is exactly what the factory spec sheet shows.

Started looking at this as the factory spec shows 1.13 mpg at 3000rpm at 21.8 kts.
I figured I am getting .68 mpg at 3000rpm at 22kts, so looking for ways to increase economy.
 
A fuel flow gauge should be on your "wish list". I'm a real non-mechanic type, but I had no trouble installing mine. Larger pitch-less hole shot, higher top end....and the other way around on the smaller prop.
 
RM,

Suggest you try the Prop-It-Right analysis that is free at Michigan Wheels website. You need to know basic info including boat stats and performance for what you have now and a goal. Near or on the last page there's a box where you can type in specific questions you want to address. Once you put in all the info you will get an auto email reply saying it will take xx days. I had a reply the very next day. Here's a link:
http://www.miwheel.com/MIWheel/propit/main.htm
 
WOT on those engines should be on the high end of 4200 - 4400 rpm. It looks like you have too much pitch for your engines which is putting a load on your engines. 18X21 would probably put you where you should be. You may want to get the props you have now scanned to see what the pitch really is before you invest in another set of props.
 
As a rule, the more pitch, the less rpm. Usually about 200 rpm per inch of pitch.
 
The WOT on 454's is 4500, go with the 21's, that should almost get you there. The mpg you think you will get?, that sounds better than it will ever do.
 
Agree that you will probably do better with the 18 x 21--but as suggested, get a prop scan and balance before changing--the prop scan will determine the exact pitch--and most likely you can repitch the current props.

However, I doubt if you will get the "factory" MPG. These are usually "light boats"-minimal fuel, water and no gear with a clean bottom etc.

I suspect you will always stay below 1 mile per gallon.
 
Using the info you give your speed will drop to 20 knots with the 21 pitch.Your fuel burn will increase about 10%.You don"t mention wot speed with the 23 pitch.Based on your information the calculated top speed for the 21 pitch could be 35 mph at 4500. These figures are from a prop calculator and are only as good as the info put in.Another thing to consider is the possibility that at higer speed your slippage will be less and that may send your rpms to 4600-4700 range.I would repitch to 22 and give that a try. Jim
 
I don't think your WOT is 4200. Check again - I think it might be 4400-4600. The newer FI are even higher I think. Your way over propped at 4050 RPM's. The load on the engines is too high - the motors are working too hard, and your efficiency will suffer as you are not properly pitched.

(Make certain you have the correct WOT RPM spec for your engines)

Make sure to get the correct pitch, getting your RPM's in the correct range. My last 454 was 4400-4600 RPM's. The newer FI models are higher I think.

Often, people assume if they go to a steeper pitch prop, they can go faster (at a given RPM), and get better fuel economy. It does not work that way. Having the wrong pitch that does not get your RPM's in to the correct range will result in WORSE fuel mileage, and lots more engine wear - possibly to the extreme.

No matter what prop you wind up with (3-4-5 blade, cupped, stainless, whatever), if your WOT RPM's are NOT in the correct range, you're going to have propblems...
 
Back
Top