What would you do

KnottyBuoyz

Active member
Member
Joined
Mar 3, 2006
RO Number
20406
Messages
1,584
if you were in my position? The wife and I are planning to build our next boat. A Jacques Mertens designed 28' Trawler in Stitch & Glue FG. (artists sketch below) I've been discussing our plan to build our own boat and have been getting a few differing opinions(some quite negative). Such as:
  • Why build when you can buy an old boat and fix it up?
  • Just buy a new one and go!
  • Do you really want to spend two years of hard work doing this?
  • You won't get anything for it if you go to sell it, why throw your money away?
The list goes on but these seem to be the most common sentiments.

Buying new isn't an option especially when you look at boats like the new C-Ranger 25' pocket trawler with a retail list of $110K US plus options. It's probably doable for us but I don't think it's a good value for such a small boat and toss in depreciation on top of that I really don't believe that represents good value. Buying new in the size we're considering to build would be anywhere from $125K - $200K US. We have a detailed budget spreadsheet and we're pretty sure that we'll be able to build the boat for $60K - $70K Cdn.

Well I have a short list of why's vs. why nots. Mostly it's because of:
  • It's a lifelong dream to build my own boat
  • I believe I'll get good value for my money if we build as opposed to bying an old boat
  • I don't like working on old boats (been there done that) it's just not for us
  • We'll use a proven design with a proven construction method using the best materials available
  • Through my work I have access to many marine professionals, naval architects & engineers most of whom owe me a favor or five (I have Tyvek coveralls & epoxy rollers with their names already printed on them) ;o)
  • It'll be fully inspected by Transport Canada for registration and will be compliant with all their small vessel construction standards
  • I (we) aren't affraid of hard work, not even two years of it or more
We feel we're able to build this boat, out of pocket quite comfortably, over the course of a couple of years and not have to borrow or sell the house to do it.

It's not about just buying a boat and going cruising. It's about the whole experience especially the pride in accomplishment and satisfaction that goes with having done it ourselves! Besides if I build it and it breaks I should be able to fix it, right? Any and all comments welcome and appreciated.

TW28_drawing.jpg
 
Nice looking boat,,,, needs a different flag though.
If you feel you can do it then do it.
 
Some of the best times my wife and I have on the boat are working on it together in the yard. If it's something you both will enjoy. Sounds like two years of good times.
 
I have the utmost respect for anyone building their own boat. There are +/- of course. you do get to customize it as you see fit and will know every intimate detail of the boat - and the quality of construction. There is the time factor and the labor involved. I built a 12' dinghy and can give you one piece of advice - be prepared to become very intimate with sand paper - it will be your new best friend.

Question on the design - hard to tell from the pic - but what is the deadrise; seems to have almost a flat bottom? Which, deadrise, by the way is an issue with S&G contruction given the limits on bending sheet plywood.

Do not harbor any illusion that you will save tons of $ building yourself - recognize that it is a labor of love.

Finally - check with you insurer on the ability to insure a home built vessel.

Best of luck, and should you proceed - tons of photos please.
 
Absolutely go for it. You've been around boats more than long enuff to know what you'll be getting into. That's a GREAT looking trawler. Are you sure you can do it in 28'?]:)]
 
Your first reason why is enough, build it.
 
Thanks for the positive feedback fella's. Nice change from what I've been getting elsewhere lately. I knew I was in the right place!

We're currently discussing some modifications with the designer to make her 2-1/2 feet longer keeping the same 10' beam. This will open up a larger cabin and saloon. Here's the original design for the 28'.

TW28_350.jpg


TW28_stern_500.jpg


We, the admiral and I as well as the cat get along on a 25' express now so we don't need heaps of space. Sure, it'd be nice to have a 55' Flemming but short of a lottery win that'll never happen!

I'm actually looking forward to the sticky stuff and being itchy all the time! I'm sure I'll need plenty of therapy afterwards! Oh yeah, mr. belt sander will probably be my new best friend! :o)
 
quote:

Originally posted by In the know

Question on the design - hard to tell from the pic - but what is the deadrise; seems to have almost a flat bottom? Which, deadrise, by the way is an issue with S&G contruction given the limits on bending sheet plywood.




It's a true displacement hull. Not much deadrise at the stern. Panels are virtually flat as they approach the stern. Panels are all CNC cut which is a bonus.
quote:

Do not harbor any illusion that you will save tons of $ building yourself - recognize that it is a labor of love.




Absolutely but isn't that usually the story with most boats and their owners? Sometimes it's a love/hate relationship but I don't see that being the case with this project. If it takes 3 yrs and an extra $10K to get it right then that's what it'll take.
quote:

Finally - check with you insurer on the ability to insure a home built vessel.




No problem there especially with being inspected and registered. I've got two close pals who are TC Steamship Inspectors who'll do the inspections and a couple of others who are marine engineers and surveyors. Told my Ins guy this and his jaw kinda dropped! :o) He asked if I'd build one for him too!
quote:

Best of luck, and should you proceed - tons of photos please.





Absolutely!
 
Wow great plan! Obviously well thought out. Dont listen to the naysayers. There will always be plenty of people standing in line to critizie. Please take pics and description of work being done (if you have time!)
 
One of my favorite quotes from Samual Devlin's "Devlin's Boat Building" is "You Gotta Hate em to launch em!" when he's talking about how the tasks just seem to keep comming and progress just seems to stand still while the snow is blowing sideways ect..

Slow and steady!
 
Go For It !!!

I really love the looks of that classic design and their website has nice pics of the nearly finished interior under construction and exterior shot of an essentially finished 28.

Advise not to build in the basement or living room. A few loooooong weekends should do it! Keep us posted.
 
all I can say is too follow your dream...you only live once on this planet and if that is what you want too do...then knock yourself out....you certainly don't need anyones permission....Go for it!!...I just wish I was handy with wood....cheers on ya!!
 
I love the J-M designs and have built a couple of their smaller boats. I can't see anything fundamentally wrong with your plan, but I do recommend that you take a couple months and make absolutely certain that there isn't a secondhand boat out there that will fill your needs.
 
I hate, hate, hate doing fiberglass work but after a while the itching goes away. Maybe I just got numb to it. Lots and lots of tape to pull off the FG from your skin. Best to get an indoor place to do the work if possible.:)

Good luck! If I were 5 years younger I'd tackle a DIYer.
 
"It's a lifelong dream to build my own boat"

That is the only reason that you need and it is very sufficient!!!

Good luck and enjoy your endeavors.

G
 
Go for it! It looks like a very nice boat and if you have the ability to do it I think that it's a way for you to fulfil your dream.
 
It appears to me that you have done your homework well...Great looking boat, looks like Roseborough.
Go for it, you only live once.
Dick
 
I think you should do it too. It sounds like you really want to, and have done your homework, but as others have said, I haven't heard anything about a shop to build it in. You need to consider what weather conditions you are going to face while building and plan for storing materials as well. With a two-year project like this, of course you will need your own blog to record progress and keep us informed. Good Luck!
 
Sweet looking trawler.

TW28_hullconstr.jpg


TW28_turkey1.JPG


TW28_turkey6.JPG


TW28_turkey2.JPG

I understand your passion and am envious of your dream. Talent and ability most certainly exist with me - but with a business to run, what's lacking is time. I would certainly do it otherwise.

Best wishes if you decide to go forward with it.

Steve
 
It sounds as if your plan is very well in place. I also recommend you read "Gourgeon Brothers on Boat Design" - it is the bible for epoxy boat building.
 
Back
Top