- Joined
- Mar 3, 2006
- RO Number
- 20406
- Messages
- 1,584
if you were in my position? The wife and I are planning to build our next boat. A Jacques Mertens designed 28' Trawler in Stitch & Glue FG. (artists sketch below) I've been discussing our plan to build our own boat and have been getting a few differing opinions(some quite negative). Such as:
Buying new isn't an option especially when you look at boats like the new C-Ranger 25' pocket trawler with a retail list of $110K US plus options. It's probably doable for us but I don't think it's a good value for such a small boat and toss in depreciation on top of that I really don't believe that represents good value. Buying new in the size we're considering to build would be anywhere from $125K - $200K US. We have a detailed budget spreadsheet and we're pretty sure that we'll be able to build the boat for $60K - $70K Cdn.
Well I have a short list of why's vs. why nots. Mostly it's because of:
It's not about just buying a boat and going cruising. It's about the whole experience especially the pride in accomplishment and satisfaction that goes with having done it ourselves! Besides if I build it and it breaks I should be able to fix it, right? Any and all comments welcome and appreciated.
- Why build when you can buy an old boat and fix it up?
- Just buy a new one and go!
- Do you really want to spend two years of hard work doing this?
- You won't get anything for it if you go to sell it, why throw your money away?
Buying new isn't an option especially when you look at boats like the new C-Ranger 25' pocket trawler with a retail list of $110K US plus options. It's probably doable for us but I don't think it's a good value for such a small boat and toss in depreciation on top of that I really don't believe that represents good value. Buying new in the size we're considering to build would be anywhere from $125K - $200K US. We have a detailed budget spreadsheet and we're pretty sure that we'll be able to build the boat for $60K - $70K Cdn.
Well I have a short list of why's vs. why nots. Mostly it's because of:
- It's a lifelong dream to build my own boat
- I believe I'll get good value for my money if we build as opposed to bying an old boat
- I don't like working on old boats (been there done that) it's just not for us
- We'll use a proven design with a proven construction method using the best materials available
- Through my work I have access to many marine professionals, naval architects & engineers most of whom owe me a favor or five (I have Tyvek coveralls & epoxy rollers with their names already printed on them) ;o)
- It'll be fully inspected by Transport Canada for registration and will be compliant with all their small vessel construction standards
- I (we) aren't affraid of hard work, not even two years of it or more
It's not about just buying a boat and going cruising. It's about the whole experience especially the pride in accomplishment and satisfaction that goes with having done it ourselves! Besides if I build it and it breaks I should be able to fix it, right? Any and all comments welcome and appreciated.