- Joined
- May 12, 2009
- RO Number
- 31236
- Messages
- 322
Guy calls me the other day, says he has spent the last three and a half days working on my boat in error. Apparently an arrangement was made a couple of months ago with the owner of a boat that looks similar to mine and which then occupied the marina slip that my boat now occupies. The arrangement involved a $3K fibreglass restoration job. Weeks after making the arrangement, the fellow comes to the marina and just goes to work on the boat that was in the same slip. Problem is, the boat that was supposed to be getting the work done had moved to another slip in the same marina. The fellow succeeded in removing decal stripes from the house sides, removing the non-slip from the side decks and foredeck, and stage-one wet sanding in preparation for cut wax, seal and polish on about 70% of the area above the gunwales before discovering that he was working on the wrong boat.
He admits the mistake is his, promises he won't leave me with the job half done, and says he'll be happy if gets anything at all out of the job. Meanwhile, the owner whose boat was supposed to be having the work done is chomping at the bit to get it done so he can use his boat.
No question that my boat needed cleaning and polishing work, and, if the job gets done, will look better for it. My boat is a 1982 Carver 3007 aft cabin. I'm not the type of person who feels particularly good about taking advantage of another person's mistake. On the other hand, I don't feel I'm obligated to make this guy whole either. My thinking is that when mistakes are made the onus is on the person who made the mistake to put the parties back as best as possible under the circumstances, and as quickly as possible, into the position they were in before the mistake was made. I think that's going to mean finishing the job that was started.
So… what would you do?
He admits the mistake is his, promises he won't leave me with the job half done, and says he'll be happy if gets anything at all out of the job. Meanwhile, the owner whose boat was supposed to be having the work done is chomping at the bit to get it done so he can use his boat.
No question that my boat needed cleaning and polishing work, and, if the job gets done, will look better for it. My boat is a 1982 Carver 3007 aft cabin. I'm not the type of person who feels particularly good about taking advantage of another person's mistake. On the other hand, I don't feel I'm obligated to make this guy whole either. My thinking is that when mistakes are made the onus is on the person who made the mistake to put the parties back as best as possible under the circumstances, and as quickly as possible, into the position they were in before the mistake was made. I think that's going to mean finishing the job that was started.
So… what would you do?