What would you do?

rapscallion

Member
Member
Joined
May 12, 2009
RO Number
31236
Messages
322
Guy calls me the other day, says he has spent the last three and a half days working on my boat in error. Apparently an arrangement was made a couple of months ago with the owner of a boat that looks similar to mine and which then occupied the marina slip that my boat now occupies. The arrangement involved a $3K fibreglass restoration job. Weeks after making the arrangement, the fellow comes to the marina and just goes to work on the boat that was in the same slip. Problem is, the boat that was supposed to be getting the work done had moved to another slip in the same marina. The fellow succeeded in removing decal stripes from the house sides, removing the non-slip from the side decks and foredeck, and stage-one wet sanding in preparation for cut wax, seal and polish on about 70% of the area above the gunwales before discovering that he was working on the wrong boat.

He admits the mistake is his, promises he won't leave me with the job half done, and says he'll be happy if gets anything at all out of the job. Meanwhile, the owner whose boat was supposed to be having the work done is chomping at the bit to get it done so he can use his boat.

No question that my boat needed cleaning and polishing work, and, if the job gets done, will look better for it. My boat is a 1982 Carver 3007 aft cabin. I'm not the type of person who feels particularly good about taking advantage of another person's mistake. On the other hand, I don't feel I'm obligated to make this guy whole either. My thinking is that when mistakes are made the onus is on the person who made the mistake to put the parties back as best as possible under the circumstances, and as quickly as possible, into the position they were in before the mistake was made. I think that's going to mean finishing the job that was started.

So… what would you do?
 
I'd work out a very cut-rate deal with the guy assuming that he completes the job ASAP.
 
I almost did that once before I figured out it wasn't the right boat. (His mistake: ALWAYS know the name of the boat!)
I agree with you that you're not obligated. I would, however, want to pay him for his work, but at a low wholesale level, and I mean low. Try to strike a deal based on his material costs (covering those) and, say, an hourly amount, perhaps based on your labor (as if you were doing the job yourself). You will give him good word of mouth, assuming the job is done right, and it won't be total loss for him.
It seems like a pretty high quote originally. Is he going to respray gel coat?...why remove non- skid?
You're probably in the best position to make this dollar estimate, as you have a better idea of the work done/yet to be done, more so than us at our keyboards and all. Just MHO.
Buzz
 
I think you have some options:
#1 part company at this point on friendly terms and finish the job yourself.
#2 offer to cover his materials only and let him eat his labor.
#3 As Les and Max suggest (which I feel is the right thing to do) negotiate a flat amount to complete the job, but in a very tomely manner.
 
Once I was presented with a legitmate bill of $4700 but because of circumstances that was a mistake on the vendors part, the price was higher than it should have been but I did get $4700 worth of product.
In talking with the vendor, I ALMOST said, "bring it down to $4000 and I'll be happy". Instead I let the vendor make his offer first. His offer was $3700. My response, "I can live with that".

Point being, sometimes it's better to keep your mouth shut and let others speak first.
 
I had the same thing happen to me. The marina serviced my outdrives by mistake and did not charge.
 
You could offer to take him to court for damaging your boat.(of course since he admits a mistake a suit is extreme.) Chances are, if he has a legit business he may be insured. After all you did not order the work and it would not be out of line that you had absolutly nothing in your budget to cover that type of repairs.
 
Obviously you don't have to give him anything. I would expect him to finish the job and get the boat back in shape. If i were happy with the work, and were happy with his apparant honesty and his not being a total jackass and trying to insist you owe him anything, if he was being the total stand up guy knowing it was his mistake i would offer at least to cover his costs on materials, and perhaps something small on top.

Neither of you get screwed, you get some good work done that you could use but didnt need and at a great rate. He gets to at least just lose time, but not $ for the materials.

Just my humble opinion.

Let us know how it works out.

thanks,
dan
 
Come on Larry! Another frivilous lawsuit to further tie up the courts? You're kidding , right???? Give the guy some money for his time and effort and be done with it. One of the biggest problem with this country is our willingness to sue and go after insurance companies.
 
If you were considering having this work done and you have the money to cut a really good deal, then both of you make out. If money is tight or you never had any intentions of doing this work, why should you be forced into an unnecessary repair?

If you like the idea of what he is doing, never thought about it before, and will be happy with the work he is doing and will derive satisfaction out of his mistake, then be fair and work it out. And yes, as the other poster said, let him speak first about the price.

Do not pay him a penny till the job is complete and you are 100% satisfied.

Best of luck, sounds like someone is going to have a pretty boat when all is done.

Also,
doing the right thing aleays pays back 10 fold.
 
The OP is in the drivers seat. That doesn't automatically imply that this should be a freebie. Work something out with the guy. It seems that you'll be getting the same work done as the other boat at a much lower price.
 
Ignore LarryB's advice and do the right thing. I like the idea of paying half as Bob suggested, assuming you have the money.
 
I agree. The right thing to do would be to at least offer to pay for the materials once the job is complete (which sounds likely, given that he is acting on the level so far), and then tell anyone that notices the work who did it, what a nice job they did, and what an exceptionally honest person they are to do business with. Then be happy you got such a good deal on such a good job - and maybe start playing the lottery.

Sue the guy? Are you kidding? For accidentally doing an extensive, expensive refinishing job that he admits was his mistake and does not expect nor demand full payment for? I could see thanking the man, but why sue him?
 
I'm fairly new to this forum, so I don't know people too well yet, but I think Larry was just offering another alternative. If the job doesn't get done, or if it's poorly done, or takes far too long get done, his suggestion is a course of action that may well have to be considered.

I've been in touch again with the fellow, who is at present working on the other guy's boat, and we're discussing the possibility of him doing bottom painting and refinishing work on the hull sides, subject to satisfactory completion of the job started in error.

My thinking here is that the fellow will do a reasonably good job finishing the work he started, despite taking a loss on it, in order to win fully paid work from me in the near future. He wins future work; I win a decent job on all the work performed, a portion of it for a substantially reduced price due to the error.

Money is an issue as I just bought the boat which, after the survey, haul-out, mechanical inspection, engine and transmission oil sample analysis, service work, foreign exchange, taxes, and fuel for the delivery trip, worked out to about 175% of my budget.

I'm still undecided on what I'll offer, if anything, for completing the initial job, but I'm a reasonable guy, and so far so is the other fellow; I'm confident we'll work out something equitable all around.

Thanks to everyone for your thoughts; it's been helpful having different viewpoints to consider.
 
If money is tight, explain your situation and try to work out a payment plan, assuming of course you agree on a price and he finishes the work.
 
There is nothing to discuss, until he puts your boat back together and in the water. And while many may not agree, you do need to speak with a lawyer.
 
Back
Top