What's your compass deviation...

Oh, and when it comes to True Virgins Make Dull Company, it helps to remember the words of that great American Poet, Ogden Nash, in Reflections on Ice-Breaking


Candy
Is Dandy
But liquor
Is quicker
 
quote:

Originally posted by Capt. Bill1

You should use True on your GPS.






Capt Bill- I respectfully disagree. It is a matter of personal preference which may relate to the operator/navigator's use of the compass. I choose to use GPS mag var to most closely correspond with keeping the indicated compass course and see no reason to make myself constantly mentally add the average 16*W local variation when glancing from GPS to compass underway, since the GPS is perfectly happy to do that for me, plus it's easier to see the current-set effect on boat progress as it corresponds to cross-track if both heading sources are mag.. The true/mag calculation is no problem during the relatively short time spent on pre-trip paper chart plotting for safe backup on longer trips. Just my preference.

As for deviation, never put a 7/0 steel hook on the dash within 8" or so of the compass, and make sure VHF remote speakers are WAY away from it, especially while navigating in thick fog w/o gps loran or radar. Don't ask.
 
quote:

Originally posted by Sandy

quote:

Originally posted by Capt. Bill1

You should use True on your GPS.






Capt Bill- I respectfully disagree. It is a matter of personal preference which may relate to the operator/navigator's use of the compass. I choose to use GPS mag var to most closely correspond with keeping the indicated compass course and see no reason to make myself constantly mentally add the average 16*W local variation when glancing from GPS to compass underway, since the GPS is perfectly happy to do that for me, plus it's easier to see the current-set effect on boat progress as it corresponds to cross-track if both heading sources are mag.. The true/mag calculation is no problem during the relatively short time spent on pre-trip paper chart plotting for safe backup on longer trips. Just my preference.

As for deviation, never put a 7/0 steel hook on the dash within 8" or so of the compass, and make sure newly-installed VHF remote speakers are WAY away from it, especially while navigating in thick fog w/o gps loran or radar. Don't ask. [:-ashamed]






 
Actually, for short distance nav below 70 degrees latitude, mag is ok, but if you are crossing long distances where you are clipping off longitude (i.e. West/East course) fairly rapidly, Capt Bill is correct. True is a better option. It is easier to measure, less prone to error and holds a better course. One of the things we teach our pilots is when they loose the Flight Managment Computer over water, is to reach up and move the switch to "True" because they will be able to maintain a more accurate track using a heading while they re-establish their nav computers if they can. If not they fly true headings until the coast in.
 
I set my GPS on Magnetic. This way it correspnds to my compass and I do not have to do any computations to use both readings.
 
I'm gonna miss cruising off the west coast of FL. Traveling short distances variation was basically a non-issue (and my compass deviation is also negligible). So I could basically use the compass as true most of the time.

One interesting thing about deviation is that it can vary with your heading, so when you ask "what is your compass deviation?", the answer could be quite long.
 
Last time I checked Lake Michigan was only a couple degrees variation. Out in Maine it was a around 17-18 degrees variation.

My bad, I thought the topic was about magnetic deviation, how much your compass would be off (if it were accurate) based on your geographical location.
 
Seems like a whole lot of boaters here need to spend a little time on the books "compass deviation" has little to do with the body of water, and much to do with the boat the compass is on and some to do with what is near the boat the compass is on.
I am a rookie, but this is all navigation part one, book one stuff.
John d
2005 meridian 411
Lake Huron
 
I have to disagree with Divedaddy. I had Jens Jacobs, a compass adjuster here on Long Island, come down to the boat and take it out into the bay and "swing the boat". While he does this his assistant reads headings off a master compass set up on a tripod in the stern of the boat. From the different readings between the boat's compass and his, he makes up a deviation card for the boat.
 
Ink,
Ritchie has a good description of the compass compensation process. Not really supposed to post links, but you can find it pretty easily. Go to the ritchienavigation dot com website, and under "My Compass" look for "Compensation".
 
quote:

Originally posted by Ernesto

I'm gonna miss cruising off the west coast of FL. Traveling short distances variation was basically a non-issue (and my compass deviation is also negligible). So I could basically use the compass as true most of the time.






Hmmm... I don't think I'll miss it after all... Just checked and it seems the agonic line nowadays is even closer to Prescott, WI (our new home port) than it used to be in Tampa. Is that right?
 
Gene, how does that work? The "master compass" on the tripod would be subject to deviation on the boat as well. Could be different from the boat compass, but still subject to deviation.
 
quote:

Originally posted by stmbtwle

Apparently not many know the difference between Variation and Deviation....





Just about any basic boating course teaches the difference; another plug for boating education.
 
To properly swing a magnetic compass one uses an Azimuth, reading from the sun. Another way to check your magnetic compass is to run a range on a channel. Your paper chart should show the range bearings. Line up on the range markers and see what your compass reads. It is also very important that your magnetic compass is properly aligned with the keel your vessel. Even a few degress of error can make for big problems no matter how well your compass is adjusted.
 
"Gene, how does that work? The "master compass" on the tripod would be subject to deviation on the boat as well. Could be different from the boat compass, but still subject to deviation."

I'll bet the "master compass" was either a pelorus or, as L.Keith noted, a sun compass.

And a hand bearing compass is not subject to a wood or fiberglass boats deviation if held away from any source of deviation.

http://www.irbs.com/bowditch/pdf/chapt06.pdf
 
It was easier when I was flying. You just taxied over to the "rosette" painted somewhere on the airport and wrote your compass deviation from the rosette on a card that fit under the compass.
 
"Capt Bill- I respectfully disagree. It is a matter of personal preference which may relate to the operator/navigator's use of the compass."

I was speaking to GPS use not compass use. But to each his own.

Also True is True with no corrections needed. And, for what's worth, it's my understanding that the USCG plots in True these days.

"I set my GPS on Magnetic. This way it correspnds to my compass and I do not have to do any computations to use both readings."

No need to do any computations. Plot in True. Use your GPS in True to steer by. Note what your compass heading is to use in the event the GPS goes out.
 
Not for me. I constantly use both compass and GPS to steer by and prefer they agree as much as possible considering wind & current. I note my pre-plot WP courses in both mag & true so that part makes no diff, & keeping GPS true and referring to the mag compass underway tends to hurt my tiny head before long. :D

Perhaps the larger USCG ships ( like all large ships) use gyro-compasses which indicate true N by employing the inertial & reactive forces relating to the gyro's movement with the Earth's rotation, rather than the conventional compasses' influence by Earth's magnetic field. If I had a gyro-compass (not just auto-pilot "rate gyro" -not the same) I would certainly use only true. I just disagreed with the blanket statement "you should use true on your GPS". Only if you prefer.

The last time I observed a professional compass adjuster working on a friend's 3 compasses he did use a type of hefty portable gyro-compass to find true as Les suggests, and added local variation to adjust onboard magnetic units as close as possible followed by the observation manuevers to draw up the deviation cards for each. He said the gyro unit he brought was quite expensive but still wasn't the true ship's gyro-compass which are way more expensive and much larger and take quite a lot longer to get up to speed and settle true.

If available, the gyro is certainly handier for an adjustment standard as the pelorus & suncard will not read exactly the same for each successive observation ( earth's movement changing the relative angle of the sun) so that should also be compensated for. In a very short period of use it may not make a meaningful difference though. I have still have a pelorus around here somewhere but haven't used it for 25-30 yrs......, and the suncard is simple and free. The Ritchie method is probably the easiest free adjusting method for most of us.
 
Back
Top